MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Potato13
About
- Username
- Potato13
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,052
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@SNAPcreator7, even though something came up, I'll still input my action to do when that something gets resolved. As V'glua needs to get acquainted with his new surroundings, I do some searching / clue finding in the right hall.
-
I can't wait to not help people with their escape route-related troubles!
-
@SNAPcreator7 , in as the Telepath if possible. Race: Nightmare Role: Telepath Background: V'glua is an anomaly in every sense of the way. Manifested by the Planeswalker Ashiok, he never faded out of existence from the Planeswalker's power. He…
-
@TenebrisNemo , I'm going to second Animist on this one. Antagonism doesn't need to be keyworded.
-
@TenebrisNemo , I find the card to be decent, but nothing particularly exciting. Might be able to make it have Decay 9, due to how pushed recent sets have been.
-
My two cards for this round.
-
@Commando Really, it's up to you as to what you want to do. The card itself isn't that broken and is really good, but I'm not one to speak about if you want to bring it back - because that's your choice.
-
@ChoyBoi , the card itself seems slow for constructed play. Casting 5 legendary spells is no easy feat and being rewarded with a 4/4 for 4, even with lifelink and indestructible, isn't too good. In addition, most legendary-focused decks are Superf…
-
@Commando , the original card is fine and actually seems like something that would be printed in a real set. To constrast Bradster's opinions, a 6 mana 5/5 with haste is underpowered considering cards like "Glorybringer" and "Thundermaw Hellkite" e…
-
@Bradster2002 , I'd call this card broken. Free sac outlets attached to lands are already dangerous, especially when this is just a swamp with upsides. But then you turn the free sac outlet into a removal spell. Examples of this being busted includ…
-
@jpastor - Your Round 1 Mystery Challenge: Create an Enchantment card that mentions Volrath in the flavor text. A card that's an ode both to the flavorful cycle of "Form" enchantments, and "Phyrexian Obliterator". It probably won't be good e…
-
My primary concern regarding Monsoon is the fact that it's a human, and Humans is an immensely powerful subtype in Modern who can, among other things, get the Witch in at instant speed, cast it on turn 2, and play it in a 5-color deck. Not only is i…
-
I apologize for beating a dead horse, but once again, there are way too many 4< mana creatures and large bombs, especially for draft. Average good draft decks have 4~ cards above 4 mana. I could keep pointing towards certain examples of unnecessa…
-
In general, you definitely need to cut down on the amount of tribal things and big clunky 3-color legends (5< mana is clunky). There's so many big clunky cards that I'd say you have to alter most of the cards to be less cmc and color intensive. I…
-
Question: Can we post a deck which is CEDH (Competitive EDH) levels of broken?
-
@fire12 The wording should be "Whenever a creature dealt damage by a creature in your party this turn dies, you may exile it...". Otherwise, decent card.
-
@Tomigon , the two mechanics I choose this week are: Decay X (This creature enters the battlefield with X +1/+1 counters on it. Whenever this creature blocks or becomes blocked, remove a +1/+1 counter from it.) by seaspray4TF3 [cardtype] Scrap N (…
-
While I don't agree with Hardened Blurg (it's just Bestow), I can appreciate the effort that each and every person put into this contest.
-
I'm decently well connected to limited and other formats like modern (7-1 7-2'd about 16~ times on MTGA). So, I'm going to give my thoughts on this set, and particularly the mechanics, in limited and modern. Antisocial seems as if it has very l…
-
@QuetzalPali , cards are looking much better now. I only have a few issues: 1. Gourthun doesn't feel black in any way. 2. The phrase "Enters the battlefield..." and "Other attacking..." does not work well together; I'd suggest for it to just give o…
-
Considering that I joined the contest for fun, I am glad that my Artifoul Demon stood out as card of the week material. Congrats to Bnew, Ranshai and everyone else!
-
@QuetzalPali , My thoughts on the cards posted. * Red doesn't get Enchantment destruction or hexproof. I'd suggest making it a 6/6, remove the Hexproof, and make it destroy Artifacts. Also, make it always give a buff, regardless of if the ability d…
-
My two submissions for this week. As for the mechanics I choose: Bloom _____. (Put a bloom counter on _____. It is bloomed for as long as it has a bloom counter on it.) by Tomigon. Pact [Cost] (You may cast this card without paying its mana cost a…
-
My submission, using Blueant's Recall. The idea is that it gets all creature cards it recalled back, and then can recall itself to get itself back. Very long game!
-
I will come to the defense of joemamajoe: If general or specific criticism like his is not given out, we get cards like Oko and Smugglers Copter, or narrow mechanics like Faithless Hour and bad sets like Iconic Masters that really don't work. Someti…
-
@ningyounk , this has been the most fun I've had with a contest in a while. Thank you for doing it!
-
My third, and first old entry for this contest. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/speckcharmer
-
@CassZero These "Generals" and the Sliver Lords are very different; not for power reasons, but for going against a format where the cards are fundamentally simple. All of the Sliver Lords are very simple, things like "All slivers have flanking" …
-
I'll be real; I don't like how this set is going. Things like 3 mana 3/2's that have flying, additional upsides and give lord effects should not be in pauper, same for 4 mana 2/4's with flying and vigilance with such lines as "Angel creatures lose …
-
@DomriKade My cards for a Commander Precion, with explanations behind them: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/the-world-machine Firstly, an artifact commander. It controls your draws and triples your triggers, at the cost of being an extremely fragil…