MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Potato13
About
- Username
- Potato13
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,052
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@jpastor this is technically a Shapeshifter that is a Dragon. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/shepherd-of-outcasts Also, the mystery prize I create is "This duplicates another random prize that another person in this batch got (The original prize wi…
-
@jpastor I decided to do three of the four challenges for lucky 0. FantasticKills Challenge - https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/belle-tinkerer-of-fates My Challenge - https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/hexed-prism Hergus' Challenge - https://mtgcardsmith…
-
@Lastjustice my only submission for this, a decently statted creature that can double as plausible removal. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/sporeshafter
-
I've come to review the rest of the cards, and some old cards that I overlooked. 1. Queen of the Moor is too good. 3 mana and 10 life for 5 cards is value that cannot be matched, it'd likely take over standard and possibly modern with the help of …
-
@Ranshi , I apologise for calling them bad. However, bluntness is the best way to make progress with card design and for improving balancing. No use beating around the bush when there's a proper set to make, after all. I'll try not to be too criti…
-
@jpastor , jeez all the favourites! Put one favourite on this card. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/flame-vexed-apprentice Next box, please.
-
@jpastor , I wish to ask what Chapter IV has written on it. As for the favourites, I'd put one on Bark-Tush Boar and the card for the challenge: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/risk-of-rags Another box, please.
-
Of the cards that I could see actually being printed which aren't strangely underpowered or too good for seeing print, they are: 1. Wolfpack Tactics. A variant of the common fight effect that hasn't really been done before. 2. Seal of the Sentry.…
-
In reviewing the cards for the set so far, there are a few that are a problem. 1. Father of Autumn doesn't feel like a Mythic Card. If anything, it feels like an Uncommon card. 2. Asleep for A Hundred Years is woefully busted, mainly in Izzet Ph…
-
However, the themes also play into the draft archetypes. If the themes are poorly designed, then the set falls apart. This is what is happening here, we have a separate person each designing a 3 color combination versus an enemy 2 color combinati…
-
@IzItTru I did not once mention theme. I am talking about draft archetypes, and every set needs them. even the most chaotic of sets, for example Planar Chaos, had draft archetypes (B/W Rebels, W/G Saprolings, Slivers). Your example of Modern Hori…
-
Also, right now the design process is a bit of a mess. We've got one person making a techno, very non-mtg theme, and everyone else just designing cards while throwing lore and ideas at an unstickable wall. We need to focus on gathering our though…
-
@Ranshi Baltrice seems a little odd on the +1 and probably should be tinkered with a bit more for the following reasons: 1. Unlike any other planeswalker, it has an ability that relies on it's loyalty counters. The reason why that seems iffy is bec…
-
@jpastor Put the 1 favourite on the card I made for the challenge, a callback to Eternal Dragon. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/eternal-aura And another box, please.
-
@jpastor This card has its own merit as a good mono-colored card in limited. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/bark-tusk-boar The community box prize that I choose to add is, as follows: "Pick a plane in the MTG Lore. Each person in the next batch w…
-
@Scott_Anderson I don't think it can be anti-black. Generally, the only way a creature with a multicolored combination can hose a certain color is by: 1. Hosing the color which is the enemy colors to both of the allied colors. 2. Hosing the card's…
-
My one entry: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/kallt-land-deviant (Art is not from MTG.) Pretty much, Eldrazis do not have enough support as a tribe. Nothing provides Tribal synergy, and all of the Eldrazis are colorless and are thus very poor as co…
-
@jpastor By ability, do you mean no activated abilities, no keywords or only passive text like Tireless Tracker? Edit: Or do you mean a Vanilla creature?
-
@Scott_Anderson also, regarding Antoneta le Guen, she is WAY too powerful and pretty much unprintable for the following reasons: 1. She dodges Assassin's Trophy, Fatal Push, Dismember, Drown in the Loch and can't be blocked by Death's Shadow, all …
-
@Scott_Anderson I'll try to help by judging all the cards for Modern, Standard and other formats like commander. Aether Archipalago is a strictly worse version of Reflecting Pool. The most convenient way to make a legendary land that MTG has bee…
-
@jpastor I realised that I never actually sent my Godzilla card, but after about a year of experiencing Magic, the card design and it's wording I have decided to join back in on the mystery boxes. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/lordzalla-layer-of-w…
-
1. Moth (Primary name I use for any website, if available.) 2. Male, but gender doesn't matter that much. 3. Mono-White, Mono-Black, U/G 4. Death & Taxes, Devotion, Morph 5. I hate Planeswalker Commanders for several reason (My entire play group…
-
@RayearthIx sorry about that! But for question one, it would work as a printed card (Bloodghast) has a very similar ability (Certain thing enters, triggers from graveyard, returns from graveyard) that works as intended. And for number 2, I was juggl…
-
Here are the three cards I have chosen for this contest: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/featherfell-phoenix (Couldn't fit flavor text for this one, but the idea is that the Phoenix is "consuming" the giant creature for fuel to it's dying fire.) htt…
-
@ningyounk those look good for reprints! My other suggestions for new commons and reprints are as follows: White: 1W 2/1 that has "W: First Strike until end of turn" 2WW 3/4 with Vigilance and, when it attacks, tap target creature an opponent contr…
-
As in, commons that don't use the set's mechanics.
-
Alright, with that explanation it sounds better. I might try to make a few of the more "Pack-Filler" commons that every set has.
-
A story. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/nicol-bolas-orderer https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/parished-pizza https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/karmatic-cooking (Note: this is more of an joke than anything.)
-
And outside of Physian Life and Elated, the synergy between mechanics isn't really there. Discover is just blatant draw and masterwork doesn't synergise with the other mechanics in many ways. I feel like we need to tone it down a bit and figure out…