MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Project1734
I need some help making a custom set so I turned to the community for help. Please help out here if you have time
http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/4382/a-new-plane-custom-set-collab-contest#latest
About
- Username
- Project1734
- Joined
- Visits
- 81
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@Flameice with Llanowar Elves and Ashcoat Bears around, she can easily get those bonuses. And she only needs one of those bonuses to be broken.
-
A 4/5 with trample and lifelink that can also be tapped for wg is pretty damn powerful
-
@Flameice2 honestly I love the cards, the only thing I'm concerned with is Daisha's balancing lol
-
@HeroKP I'm glad!
-
Jesus
-
So far, here is the common skeleton. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1QxRefXK48eOTgBkBwUIvDEn1FywHOa9-adaMTcQYzyE/edit?usp=sharing Only done blue right now but it will be constantly updating. If you have an idea for an edit, comment below.
-
Since no one is posting any cards, I think I'm going to make a common skeleton in my spare time. Tell me if you guys have any ideas. Also, @MemoryHead @joerivlimpt the androids should be pretty futuristic in style, not steampunk or cyborg. I woul…
-
Ok I got it, sorry
-
I honestly like the ideas of cards that have greater payoff when they target a Masterwork, either like removals that deal 2 damage to a creature or destroy it if it's a masterwork, or just pump spells that give Masterworks some extra bonus.
-
Ok, I think I'm going to rework forget so that you can only destroy one of those cards.
-
It wouldn't hurt to have a pump spell that mentioned Masterwork. Something like "All creatures you control have +1/+0. Your masterwork is unblockable." Something like that maybe to fit the red pump spell common slot?
-
@ASubtleGhost Afflict is already a keyword name...
-
I'm just gonna try something real quick...
-
so have you guys settled on which mechanic to use yet?
-
@shadow123 welcome to the contest, my friend
-
@shadow123 just remeber, you're making a keyword with those terms, not a card
-
Return to hand (18), Creature tokens (1), Exile face-down (20)...interesting. Let's see what I can do. Also, is it just me or does nobody ever do their own challenges?
-
@IanLowenthal I love the mechanic, a lot of flavor. The things you can do with silver borders.
-
Ok, this is actually fun. I might use this regularly when trying to think up mechanics.
-
@MemoryHead yeah, I was scared about forget when I made it...
-
@EnvyReaper thanks a ton! I'll try and find the rest myself.
-
@EnvyReaper I wasn't exactly expecting to win (though I did actually want the circuit points lol), and I was not trying to come off as cocky. I forgot to add the artists, but ya know, it happens. Anyways, sorry, cya around,
-
@ASubtleGhost nope
-
Fixed, sorry for that
-
Give me about ten minutes
-
I might just do a completely new entry for blue if that's the case
-
@ningyouk Oh shoot welp let me fix that ._.
-
@ningyounk I just want to be a part of something lol
-
@ningyounk ok thanks for clearing that up, but...about my blue card, honestly imo if it was an instant or sorcery it would be...bad. Just, bad. I prefer it being an enchantment. Plus, you said Spike-friendly. Also, sorry if there are any typos i…
-
@PandaShoop That's a bit much lol