MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Ral1000
About
- Username
- Ral1000
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,289
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@TerryTags I believe that's correct! (; Now you see why we might not want to have Tempo N...
-
@tookie1 I see what you mean about Harmonize. I've been convinced! Do we like the idea of taking out Rebound and making Tempo worded: Tempo (At the beginning of your upkeep, put a verse counter on this creature. Then, if it has two or more ver…
-
@LyndonF I really like all of your suggestions! Just a few thoughts- - If we used these mechanics they would end up as Rhythm/Tempo N, Harmonize N, and Renown N. While I'm all for switching out for Renown, that's a lot of N's... I'm not sure if …
-
@shadow123 Sounds great, I like this version more also. Thanks!
-
@LordTachanka123 I'm certainly open to having one ridiculously powerful song at mythic, I like the idea! @TerryTags I also like Tempo more- Seems like a great mechanic for design space and creativity. I think we'll be doing this instead of Reb…
-
@TerryTags Good idea! Here's an overview of each of the possible mechanics, and a brief note concerning each one: Harmonize N - Target noncreature permanent becomes an N/N Song creature in addition to its other types until end of turn. While t…
-
Question: What do we think of taking out Tempo? The whole transform mechanic can get overly complected, and it seems like we have enough as it is... Three new mechanics are plenty. This would be a way to lighten the load, and also make room for mo…
-
@shadow123 Yeah, you're definitely right about this. Rebound was just never going to get anywhere. I also like Harmonize, and I think this should make for an interesting balance of mechanics, since Songs won't appear until the uncommon and rare sl…
-
Since 4 new mechanics seem like a bit much, I would say we should take out Harmonize. The ability kind of just gives a keyword to many other effects in magic, and while we might not call it "Harmonize," we can still include some animation of lands, …
-
@shadow123 I really like the song mechanic! The one thing here is that it probably won't appear in common. There haven't been common non-aura enchantments in a while, and sagas follow the same rule. However, I would love for songs to make an appea…
-
Still thinking about this version of Harmonize, it seems like it fits better than the original, as songs don't go on forever, and the until end of turn effect is nice for this purpose. If no one has any objections, we'll be using this version for …
-
@TerryTags The one problem with that suggestion is the fact that it can only be on nonland permanents. I wanted to open it up to instants and sorceries as well, to add some more variety. Since our other new mechanic, Tempo, doesn't work on Instant…
-
@LordTachanka123 That's definitely the plan! We'll have at least one planeswalker like that, right now the thought is a Motzart-inspired young musician. He'll be someone for every student at the school to look up to. @TerryTags Just saw your s…
-
@tookie1 that's good, I think we're just going to stick with that version of Tempo for now, where it always trriggers on your upkeep. About Harmonize- How do we feel about this version of the mechanic: Harmonize N- Target noncreature permanent b…
-
@Arceus8523 Do you think this would work? I also like Tempo a lot more, I think it flows better and fits more with the mechanic. Question: Would we want to have different kinds of Tempo's, such as: Tempo Upkeep- At the beginning of your up…
-
(Submission retracted)
-
@LordTachanka123, @shadow123, @TerryTags While I do like Rhythm, I feel like we need some kind of play on it, instead of just the word "Rhythm" as the mechanic name. Who knows though, maybe it could work! Does this not seems awkward to anyone …
-
@Arceus8523 , @shadow123 Like Shadow said, the evoke thing wouldn't really capture the whole rhythm theme. We also need a new, flashy mechanic like mutate, and the double sided cards are sure to fit that slot. However, we do need a new name for t…
-
OK, here's an example for an "offbeat" Harmonizer, where one side is better than the other for balance. I'm honestly liking the upkeep shift a lot... I think it will help balance the game and not get too obsessive with end steps, ect. I also like…
-
On second thought, I like the double-sided cards a little more, since they would have much more room for design space with things like "when this creature transforms, ect." The level frame seems a little more tight, and kind of intrudes upon the ori…
-
@ningyounk Thanks for the thoughts! I'll definitely look into the unstable contraptions for balance and creativity. - About keeping everything on one side of the card: I think the easiest way to do that would be to use the level text: I'm just n…
-
@shadow123 sounds good! I'll be interested to hear what you come up with! @TerryTags This is interesting! I see what you mean now about the Tempo thing; It could certainly help the mechanic develop. I definitely want to start playing around with…
-
@shadow123 I honestly do really like the "until end of turn" thing, now that I think about it. Do you have any ideas for another name for it though, since we need more mechanics and Harmonize has been taken (Below)? While Animate seems appropriate…
-
@ningyounk, thanks so much for all the feedback you offered on the set! I answered your questions if you want to take a look... Please let me know if there is anything in particular I should do for Rezatta. Is there a specific theme or something I …
-
Hey @ningyounk, thanks for all the feedback, this was really helpful! As I'm not an experienced set maker, it was good to hear all this from you. Here are some responses to the points you made (Sorry, might be a bit out of order): - About Harmon…
-
Oh OK, sounds good @SNAPcreator7!
-
@ningyounk I know this might be a bit to ask, but do you think you could offer some feedback on the new intro I posted for the music set I started earlier this month? I know you've helped a bunch already, but I was just wondering if there was anyt…
-
Thanks for the heads up @Scaccogaming. @SNAPcreator7, is it really a problem if I also use a mechanic named "Enlighten?" I can always change it later if our sets interfere too much.
-
@SNAPcreator7, I'm not angry or annoyed or anything, but which set is this again? I scrolled through your Veru, Land of Dinosours set, and didn't see a mechanic named "Enlighten" anywhere... If it's a different set, could you post a link? Don't w…