MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Red_Tower
FYI other humans, my pronouns are they/them. Thanks!
About
- Username
- Red_Tower
- Joined
- Visits
- 635
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
I'm interested!
-
Definitely going to try and participate! Just have to decide on a theme.
-
@sorinjace Omnipresence is very fun and neat internet persona. Also if you're offering, I wouldn't terribly mind a card...
-
I voted pretty early on, but since we're saying we voted, I voted!
-
Going to just bump this again since it's been a while.
-
I'm not the best at evaluating decks, but commander is my main format, so I can try and give you some feedback. I think I have two big questions more than anything. 1: What is the deck trying to do? What is the plan for winning? My view of the dec…
-
I feel like if I wanted to make a card for you @OmnipresentAnonymous I'd have to make a mini ARG haha
-
Casual bump
-
I just realized I still need to do a write-up for this!
-
Name: Red_Tower Challenge #: 4 Challenge entry 1/12 Card name: Giant's Reproach Card link: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/giants-reproach Card image:
-
Loving the cards so far!
-
First entry, I had an immediate idea of basic idea to work off of and just had to iron it out a bit. Interesting mechanic, if maybe a little limited.
-
@FORFUN I'm also interested!
-
@TheRacingTurtle We will watch your career with great interest.
-
I've been making an effort to look through cards of 2020 since I was on a bit of a hiatus last year. Y'all have been absolutely killing it! Since this is the last day of nominations, I had to pick someone's card to add, and I absolutely loved this c…
-
Well, for my third entry I decided to give my hand at doing something with planechase, so I present my Dominaria tribal card: Originally it cared more about the plane, but it ended up not really feeling cohesive so I cut back on it.
-
Second entry: Curses! Also @AboveAndAbout if I wanted to make a card dealing with Planechase, would it need to care about the plane subtypes, or could I do a card that cared about planeswalking? Or would you rather just none of that?
-
@FORFUN I actually don't have much feedback for your second card beside maybe lower the p/t a little? But it doesn't have any immediate impact and most Shrines aren't super cheap, so it might be fine as is. Sorry to disappoint.
-
@FORFUN Looking at Sand-Scarred Necromancer first. The first ability is very strong. Having cards with high cmc but low p/t on the field is a pretty easy condition to meet to start pumping out big scary skeletons with a sacrifice on attack trigger. …
-
Sorry @AboveAndAbout and @FORFUN I had started writing my post before forfun had posted, but didn't finish writing until after but didn't see it.
-
Very excited to see what happens with a rework of scoring. I imagine this will signal a new direction for the Colonisers series.
-
@AboveAndAbout Overall I'd say that the overall design and balance of the card are pretty good. I think Scry 4 might be a little high, especially since it makes it so much easier for you to win the clash, but not a deal breaker. The wording/form…
-
I wasn't able to spend much time around here last year, and I feel like I missed a lot of great cards by a lot of great cardsmiths, and in my efforts to catch up on some of that I've seen one person in particular doing some really impressive work an…
-
Alexander the Could Be Worse
-
Going to go ahead and put my cards here and I'll try to add my story tomorrow! https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/elph-vigilant-of-winter https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/mists-of-winterblossom Background: Elph is a young winter fae born under the winte…
-
I can try and make something!
-
Going to heavily consider this, if I have enough time. I might have to revisit an old character of mine.
-
For clarity/confirmation, the legendary creatures we're supposed to base our cards on are supposed to be from MTGCardsmith, or actual Magic cards?
-
First entry: Shrines! https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/shrinetender
-
I'll probably make something for this, just gotta decide on a concept.