MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
RohanDragoon
About
- Username
- RohanDragoon
- Joined
- Visits
- 4,520
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
-
Blunt Strike:
-
@littledemon Sometimes I get the flavor text right haha. This is by far one of my favorites
-
My second entry. I went for a little red for some flair.
-
Blast: Oracle:
-
Irate:
-
I gave it a try, however, he might be just a little too powerful:
-
@TrippleBoggey3 The contest is specifically for a replacement to Path to exile, which means the spell has to exile, not destroy. It's like the first criteria of the challenge
-
Congrats to all of the winners! Good luck to all of you in the next round, and @ningyounk I wish you the best of luck in your PhD endeavors
-
Gave it a go:
-
Didn't play test energy counters until today and I actually love them. Thought I'd might as well give this a stab before it ends
-
probably incredibly OP, especially in any artifact deck, but I saw the art and dall I could think of was Kaladesh
-
@TheClayKnight Some people just have all of the luck. My only real big hit for luck was a box from bfz where I pulled Ulamog, Gideon, Drana, Ob, and Noyan Dar and a whole bunch of lower mythics like dragonmaster outcast and Akoum Firebird and like p…
-
@DragonFaceEater One of my most expensive cards is also Tamiyo, the moon sage for my general tazri ally/superfriends edh deck, and I'm also working incredibly hard to get doubling season. On top of that, I've got Nahiri still getting some good mon…
-
I'm not a big modern player, so I might make some changes, but I like the general idea I have here. It might be a little overpowered in the fact it's got two plus abilities, but so did Knight-Errant and she seems to be a good modern walker. I might …
-
I'm trying to work out this planeswalker, cause I absolutely love the art. My biggest problem is that I'm trying to balance him as a higher mana cost planeswalker. The only real planeswalkers with 7+ cmc are Karn, Ugin, Bolas, and Garruk (Apex Preda…
-
@Bellycuss If you want, I can change it. I really actually meant it to be an uncommon and just completely forgot to change it
-
@Faiths_Guide When this contest was started, Oath of the Gatewatch wasn't out yet
-
Should've been uncommon or rare but I'm past it now
-
I love oaths. I play a General Tazri Super Friends and Allies in edh, and the only noncreature, nonplaneswalker spells in the deck are either a planeswalker oath, Call the Gatewatch, or Deploy the Gatewatch. (I know I need a copy of Doubling Season,…
-
@IanLowenthal Yes. It was a very sad attempt to balance the first ability, however it could be a huge problem. I think my biggest challenge is that I don't see charms as being worthy of rare or mythic, however the fact that it's four mana of four di…
-
I've really been struggling with my second card because I really like the idea of charms as being uncommons so I want to make a card that each effect is worth an uncommon level without being too much one sided that people only choose one really stro…
-
@llamalord44 It literally just means that I saw that this contest wasn't getting much activity, so I said "bump" to "bump" it back up into the list of recently commented challenges. I'm just trying to draw more attention and more people into the con…
-
bump
-
-
Here's one that is blue, black, and red: Unfortunately, there was no room for flavor text, but it would have been "The powerful do not make mistakes because they are inherently stupid. They do so because I tell them to."
-
Uhm I just wanted to bring this up, but I saw a card skyrocket in favorites, and I was a little concerned. This is it: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/xiz-the-infinite I checked through most of the accounts favoriting this Xiz, and almost all of them h…
-
@TrippleBoggey3 It sounds reasonable, however I personally just thought of it as a really good mythic. Also, I believe you forgot to take note of the fact that there is a 2/3 with renown 2 and vigilance that's an uncommon. So I think the vigilanc…
-