MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
SPyBondPlays
* "Good design is having a lot of tools in your toolbox and knowing how to use them; great design is knowing how to meet your needs using as few tools as possible."
About
- Username
- SPyBondPlays
- Joined
- Visits
- 22
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Hey guys, I'm back. I will give feedback on Kuk Kuk, the Treasure Hunter from FireOfGolden and then post my own cards. First of all the text needs to be cleaned up but I get what its doing. The biggest thing that strikes me about this card is its …
-
@FireOfGolden Toby Fox shouldn't be legendary. There is no reason a legendary creature should have the text "this creature isn't legendary" (basically), just make it not legendary. What you should do instead is make the text on cards like Aeve, Pro…
-
@Hergusbergus I get what your doing there, but I would be careful with that, because Wizards hasn't printed anything that can stop -X/-X effects or -1/-1 counters straight up. I would change the card to "exile target creature and return it under to…
-
I've made some pretty stupid cards in my time. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/audio-surveillance?list=user https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/radioactive-dancing-blacksmith?list=user https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/venomous-tiger?list=user https://mtgcards…
-
@Ranshi Yeah that's fine.
-
@jpastor lol, that's not my card. That's @FireOfGolden's.
-
@cadstar369 Yes, white can draw specific cards, but cards that are white-aligned; equipment, small creatures, etc. Green's whole philosophy is about harmony through acceptance, and is the color that most mingles with other colors. Therby it would m…
-
@cadstar369 The whole idea with Rule of the Alpha is tying into green's philosophy of natural selection. If you've got a guy who is bigger than everybody else, than you can get rid of every other creature. The whole "when a creature dealt damage by…
-
@cadstar369 It's just barely balanced, as the ability isn't that great and it costs two colored mana instead of 1 and a generic, but you can pay for it with two types so its not as much of a downside. I would make it a 2/1 or 1/2. The ability seems…
-
Thanks man, that's really cool. Are the streams saved on the Twitch? I want to listen to it but I know that it happened yesterday.
-
@Globert-the-Martian The card seems balanced I think and I really like the flavor text. Does doing zero damage trigger "whenever ~ deals damage to a" abilities? I think its balanced, because its prone to removal, and pretty situational. I think tha…
-
Just favorite any cards of mine. Thanks.
-
@tookie1 Reform Spirit looks good and balanced, don't really have much to say about it honestly. Seems printable. Here's my card, land planeswalker. I mean, it works within the rules. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/sparking-wood?list=user or, a …
-
Yeah I know. I just thought it would.
-
Wait wait wait. You don't have to pay life to use Soul's abilities? Oh. I thought the loyalty counters were tied to your life, like if you gain or lost life the counters would go up or down. The card seems like an interesting concept, but the gamepl…
-
Alright, this is my first Magic the Gathering Cardsmith card. I made this on September 28, 2018 during school. It is a card of the meme Thanos Car. As you can see, the card is off color, badly templated, and I thought that the artist credit was…
-
@FireOfGolden Your cards seem cool, but they have a few problems. After seems balanced and good, probably my favorite card in the three, but I have no idea what "Return After to your hand unless there is a card named Sans, the Lazy Bone in your g…
-
Well @TheGamingBolasChannel, I was wondering what Herrescher of the End was, so I looked it up and went on a few wikis to learn about Gun Girls Z and the Herrescher of the End. I do think it could be a bit more powerful, but you get not only a board…
-
@TheGamingBolasChannel I'm not a big weeb, and haven't ever heard of "Gun Girls Z", but I tried to rebalance Herrscher of the End. I removed all of the "Honkai" and Commander related mechanics. Here it is: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/herrscher-of…
-
11, 1, 13 Radioactive Dancing Blacksmith (and his token) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/radioactive-dancing-blacksmith https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/equipment-22 The counters mechanic is a little clunky with the token, but the idea is you can pu…
-
@cadstar369 The dragon barbarian is far too good, I mean that's just crazy. Having that ability on a 4/4 trampler is busted. I would probably make it a 1/2 and then have it be only the first creature spell they cast on their turn.
-
@jpastor I would make the Estonia land make the next two lands enter tapped if you want to go any color, or if you make it a dual land have the next land you play enter the battlefield tapped. Having every land enter the battlefield tapped is a huge…
-
@hileandr I really like the art. This card's color identity is a little messed up. I would make it white with hybrid in green and blue because the recursion matches both of those colors. Still have it make blue and red humans though, that's good. Th…
-
@jpastor I figured it out! The cosmic ability stops the creature from being targeted by interrupts because those don't use the stack. They use the batch, which doesn't exist anymore so they are independent from any timing rules. Not sure why this w…
-
Here's the mechanics that I have made: Utilize COST - EFFECT (Pay the cost and reveal this artifact from your hand. When this ability resolves, put this artifact in your graveyard. Activate this ability only as an instant and it counts as an instan…
-
@Sweda That's pretty strong. I would put it at 2W instead and make it so it only triggers at the end of your tun. Also, I think that this card is a very "feel bad" card, because you Conclave Tribunal for example some threat that your opponent contro…
-
@cadstar369, I wanted to write "activate only as a sorcery" but there wasn't enough room, so I just left that off.
-
@FireOfGolden You need to first give feedback to the most recently posted card, and you can only post one card (there are some exceptions) before someone else gives feedback to your cards. Its a chain of "feedback, card" "feedback, card".
-
uhhh soul is inherently broken because you can lose on turn two. Here's how a game would go with Soul: Your Turn 1: Forest, play soul. Opponent Turn 1: Swamp Your turn two: Forest, play a two mana spell or something. Opponent Turn 2: Mountain, Drea…
-
watched the ending scene and immediately thought of this.