MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
SPyBondPlays
* "Good design is having a lot of tools in your toolbox and knowing how to use them; great design is knowing how to meet your needs using as few tools as possible."
About
- Username
- SPyBondPlays
- Joined
- Visits
- 22
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Second place, nice. What does "PF" and "PA" mean?
-
Okay yeah well I didn't really know about costing of fuse, thanks.
-
@cadstar369 Comment on these please. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/drive-shot?list=user https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/inspiring-plea These are a fuse card. I put which one it fuses with so it isn't confusing. If I had more room on afton I would'…
-
@cadstar369 For the pitich drowner, I think that it should say "opponents control" instead of your guys, and it shouldn't exile it, just make a 2/2 when it dies. But other than that its a very cool card, though I think its maybe too powerful than i…
-
@Globert-the-Martian Introducing... Viscid Brusier!
-
@hileandr Very nice card, I think you made it well and costed it well, you've defintely have to build around it for it to work, but It would work potentially. Can you please critique my william afton transformer card? Thanks. I posted it above a bi…
-
@Jadefire That's good though? No cards should have absolutely no answer for them.
-
I don't really know? I mean you can steal your opponent's spells and then it costs less if you countered spells that turn. Why did this effect have to go on a untouchable/untouching 0/20? So it can't be removed? It seems interesting. However it allo…
-
Can I enter the "Here's Johnny" duel against @Jadefire?
-
Here is my (art) card. I made this art in a photo editing program by grafting pieces of the two time walk pictures onto The Persistence of Memory by Salvador Dali. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/time-walk-51 I did this because I swear that the…
-
I get that, I understand how it is strategic and makes the game have an extra angel, I'm just saying that for a beginning player it would be pretty bad. I think its a cool card, and you can play around it in interesting ways.
-
@jpastor Can I open a mystery box please? Thanks.
-
I think that stalling things is generally better than getting rid of them, as your opponents did have to pay for the tutors. In the case of fetch lands, I think it should make them go onto the battlefield untapped. Honestly though the bottom ability…
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ninja-grenade So I made a new mechanic called utilize where the flavor is that you, the planeswalker, are utilizing the artifact for its effect. The cost to activate an utilize ability is paying the cost and revealing…
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/resurgent-lagoma-3 I think I've finally got a good version of arise. The casting cost is normal for flashback costs (2 more usually) and you can only activate the ability any time you can cast a creature, so if you c…
-
Yeah, but without thinking about it too much seeing your opponent's hands is crazy and very appealing. Anyway, here is the improved version of Transparency. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/transparency-1?list=user It lets you scry, but you reveal t…
-
To be honest, If I was making a card like Telepathy, I would've costed it at 3UU or 5U. I think that Maro is definitely right about how most players "have a hard time figuring out the costs of [cards]".
-
Oh my gosh. I didn't realize that there was a {b} you get to look at your opponents hands. I've really got to go to bed but I think that Transparency is pretty bad compared to that, so yeah I would definitely make it cost less and like give some eff…
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/transparency The paintings black and white which is kinda lame.
-
@CrimsonFox That Orion thing seems way too OP. I mean removal does nothing against it and you get it back brand new without summoning sickness every turn, so the more permanent ways of dealing with it: enchantments, counters, or equipment just pop …
-
@Sweda I actually did look at the bouncing stuff, and I thought it was fine, because you can regrowth instants and sorceries with flashback, which I thought would be a similar interaction. Yeah, Arise isn't supposed to activate at instant speed. I'v…
-
@cadstar369 Also though, I meant to have the extra cards go on the bottom, as keeping them on top would be pretty bad honestly. @CrimsonFox I think this card is maybe balanced, but I would take off the "indestructible until end of turn" thing for t…
-
I think this would be better if it didn't function if X was zero. Because right now even if no insight counters are going on Tranquil Insight you are still getting to look at the top cards of your library and get one each turn. I think being able to…
-
@ShadowReign I lol'd at "Myr you control have haste". But anyways, I think that this is someone unbalanced because a 0 cost 1/1 is unprecedented and there are other 0 cost artifacts which you can sacrifice to its ability. I think that this needs to…
-
Ohhhh, it just exiles the token. Okay that makes sense. I thought it returned the card to the battlefield under your control and then exiled it, not creating a token. Sorry.
-
@CrimsonFox can you give me feedback on my card please? You're supposed to give feedback then post your card. @hileandr For the Grusome Puppetry card, I like it, but I would put sacrifice instead of exile because that would be really annoying with…
-
I quite like Black Market Salesman, though it looks more like a woman (like an old hag). I think that the ability for any player to activate it is very interesting and I think that this could be quite interesting to play with. However, it should say…
-
@Globert-the-Martian I actually meant to put "creatures you control" on there but I forgot.
-
Hold on hold on. Do you understand that when you have five mana with this card in hand you can mill 20 or more cards and then win the game? That's way too overpowered with the "mill X cards from the top of your library clause". I think that the sacr…
-
Oh, I didn't realize that the opponent got to choose.