MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Scaccogaming
About
- Username
- Scaccogaming
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,073
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@ningyounk Sinking City: Now, this looks like a job for me! I'll try to give it a shot by creating lands that don't look like shocklands/scrylands per se, but these are experimental versions, mind you. Blue: absolutely Venice, no questions asked.…
-
@fire12 I believe you chose the wrong frame, but I can't blame you, since colorless instants only appear in Zendikar and we don't have that sort of frame yet. Your best shot could've been using the Black border and put a black mana cost (even if it…
-
I'll try with another design for the glassblower: (Purpose: works basically like Mad Ratter, but with a pinch of repeatability.)
-
I'd like to know my scores as well. Altough, let's be honest. I won't judge about your rates about balance, but Cass' cards, altough they do look cool, are not what you could define as REALISTIC. Also, giving personal preferences isn't exactly fair.…
-
@ningyounk I showed some of my friends my two cards (scornful defender and torturer of Malebranche), and they said that they do are strong, but they are fit for uncommon. I am not saying that their judgement is more valuable than yours, but I don't …
-
@LordTachanka123 I actually expected you to comment on most hindu cards, thanks for the nice feedback
-
I'll try to at least become a finalist, if I don't make the cut. Enjoy some of my best cards
-
Ok so, I think it's time I too contribute with more ideas. Scornful Defender (2)(W)(W) Creature - Angel Soldier Flying, Vigilance Whenever Scornful Defender blocks, you may pay 2(W). If you do, exile target attacking creature as long as Scornful D…
-
@Tommyneko You had to click on the </> on the right side of the text box before putting the html code. Just copy what you wrote, cut it, then click </> and paste the text. It should be fixed, in theory.
-
I was genuinely troubled about the prize if we didn't reach almost 7 contestants, so that's a relief...
-
Gasheen is inspired by Ganesha, the god of knowledge, spiritual truth and power, if I'm not mistaken. Shazekt is inspired by Sekhmet, the daughter of Ra, the brutal goddess of the desert and war. Hæfnir is inspired by Heimdallr, the god that watches…
-
@LordTachanka123 The fact that you're not even naming your cards is very taxing for someone like me, who wants to review them... White token-maker: On paper, this card is useless. 0/1 creeps with vigilance? Why would they need vigilance if they can…
-
@ningyounk Effigy of Valor: I didn't know about that rule about art cards... Then we can make it colorless and keep it as an artifact creature - art angel, can't we? Ultimate Banquet: I might be biased, but I like it white more, honestly. And yes, …
-
@DrakeGladis You tell me, most of my cards don't have more than 1-2 favs, and I'm far from being a smith on par with most of the big guys here. But that doesn't mean I can't try! Besides, you do are a good smith.
-
As I stated before, here's my try at Effigy of Virtue. I liked the idea of it having uneven P/T, it makes the statue's "imperfection" more evident (In the artork, you can see how the statue is cracked and covered in vines, while also retaining a maj…
-
@GameQnQ @ningyounk I literally have the perfect picture for Effigy of Virtue in my artwork folder, I'll post it eventually.
-
@ningyounk I went on a web exploration and Discovered these pieces of art, for Balena: Very medieval-like, but I'm not exactly fond of it. Let's pretend the ship on the bottom right doesn't exist, shall we? xD This is honestly my favourite. It…
-
@ningyounk I understand, altough I don't think that we should make that many cards about artists. Sure, they can be interesting, but the problem is that even if we make perfect cards for the set, would that be worth it if in the end we cannot find d…
-
@ningyounk I think I found out some art that might just be good enough for the artist cycle, altough it does need some thinking since there's only four pictures, with the lack of a White card. The artist is Christine Mitzuk: Would it be ok for it …
-
@TerryTags [...] "(and ALL of you) are far better artists than I could EVER be" [...] I wouldn't be too sure about that, I'm using Paint for my artwork, it's a pain in the ass and it's not even so good to look at when you put it in a card, so don'…
-
@Ranshi I didn't see your comment, I'm very sorry. Looking at how the introduction is written, I guess that you could post any card you wanted as long as it is new, so I posted my most recent cards... But now I suppose we're done, I'm very sorry.
-
Already? well, ok. I'll leave the links to the preferred cards, if you don't mind. 1- https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/yukari-the-masked-beauty?list=set&set=53872 2- https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/nataliya-the-self-made-army?list=set&set=53872 …
-
These are my personal best cards, I am aware they are not perfect, but I aim to fix them whenever I'll gain a premium
-
Is this too many cards?
-
@GameQnQ Caustering Bolt: the description is still saying "Mock the Divine". Nevertheless, I'd nerf its damage to 2, given its additional effects. But I'm not a fan of burn decks so my judgement might be a bit biased. _____________________________…
-
@ningyounk Then what if we put Magmatic Rebuke as a 3 drop that initially deals X (I was thinking about 3 initially, but I'm not sure) damage and punishes life decks by pinging the user? Sorry for being obsessive, but I feel like a card like that w…
-
@LordTachanka123 The mana cost is very steep for a 1/5, but I don't really see the "blue" part of the card, while the green is very feeble... The very fact that you can add 3 mana for free (supposedly) on turn 4-5, makes it very powerful as a ramp f…
-
@ningyounk On the contrary, I think that anti-life effects CAN and SHOULD be a common mechanic in both Red and Black, but I can see your reasoning nevertheless. About the balance, I think it wouldn't be too difficult on paper: green and white (allie…
-
@LordTachanka123 we demand answers!
-
@GameQnQ Just wanna say that I really lime your card concepts, I think they would fit right in, but I have some problems with a couple of them: Delve into the Unknown: I like it, but the wording is quite clunky. What does the "if you don't cast thi…