MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Scaccogaming
About
- Username
- Scaccogaming
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,073
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@LordTachanka123 It might be an interesting card after all, it just needs a good artwork. Surprisingly, there's a ton of fanarts replicating the Last Supper scene, so it might not be as difficult as expected. But the spell itself needs some refining…
-
@ningyounk Wandering Alchemist: So the masterwork effect is okay, but should it have something else alongside it? Faithful of Mossbark: If I have to print it as a mono green, then Trample should be a no brainer at this point. As a GW card tho, ma…
-
@LordTachanka123 kinda late to the party, but is Fated Dinner a reference to The Last Supper, the painting from Da Vinci?
-
Here's a first prototype, @ningyounk @LordTachanka123 @LyndonF @SteampunkDragon what do you think? I know it could be written better, but I didn't have enough space to fit the description for Masterwork, so I resulted on this format instead.
-
@LordTachanka123 we might use something similar to fling, given how Temur (Red, Green and Blue) is the wedge that focuses more on the Masterwork mechanic. So we need an effect that is fit both for green, blue and red. Or multiple effects, if anythin…
-
Primarch Vulkan of the Salamanders Space Marine Chapter, but if I gotta put a vote, then I'd say Alexander the Great.
-
@LordTachanka123 remind me what's Sling, please? Also, I was thinking more of a "search for an artifact" ETB effect, plus a masterwork ability. But that feels a bit too clunky for this specific card.
-
@LordTachanka123 https://mtg.gamepedia.com/Spellshaper Here, think of it as a spellcaster that sacrifices quantity of spells to enhance their quality of a few spells.
-
@LordTachanka123 I know, but the set is based on Italy. It's like you would put Donald Trump on Ixalan: yes it's America, but it's out of context from the flavor standpoint. Nevertheless... @ningyounk On the subject of Masterwork cards, I actually w…
-
@ningyounk Faithful of Mossbark: wouldn't it be too similar to your Endangered Winterhowl? @LordTachanka123 What I was trying to say is that it doesn't feel like something you'd find in an italian-based reinassance plane. You could argue that my …
-
That's basically a ripoff Saint Fiermin festival. Not exactly what you would find in a reinassance theme based on Italy. In fact, it's a spanish tradition and spanish people weren't exactly NICE during that period. Overall, I feel like it's an unnec…
-
...and has (or causes) crippling depression
-
@LordTachanka123 looks more like a knight of some sort to me. But this card is extremely powerful in a token/control deck.
-
@ningyounk I'm happy you like them now What would you add to Faithful of Mossbark in order to make it more white-ish instead of pure green? Anyway, I think I'll go print Grimwood Lyrist for good, using the "leaves the battlefield" instead of "dies"…
-
@LordTachanka123 Shirames won't say no, if a fraction of those sources will be sent to her plane: food is a real problem in her kingdom.
-
Here are my entries for the contest. The first one is literally me on the mirror because I'm a f*ing degenerate. The second one is quite old, but it kinda revolves around me not being exactly an important member, so I don't get noticed that much (or…
-
@LordTachanka123 no I mean... my Fervent Duelist IS a white 2/2 cat warrior with vigilance and first strike on conditions I made for Rezatta, but you're free to use the name elsewhere, since it's not a card I plan on keeping.
-
@LordTachanka123 Fervent duelist is my card, mind you
-
@dragonbornletter I did search for art that would fit the theme... It's literally in the first page for "animated armor fire"
-
@ningyounk I think I got it. How do you like these now?
-
Entry #3
-
@LordTachanka123 maybe delete the wolf and nerf her stats?
-
@joemamajoe no favourite? Sorry if I sound picky, last time I checked it was a common rule. Don't feel obliged tho
-
Yes, but that doesn't answer my question about the wolf token...
-
@LordTachanka123 Well, that's quite nice, but why would you give your opponent a free creature? Also, what's the card's power and toughness?
-
Sorry @LordTachanka123, I got a bit carried away. I'll provide some feeedback right now. Church's Wrath: I'd make it an instant, if anything. Very white, very simple card, but not very efficient. The drawback puts you in a major disadvantage in the…
-
@ningyounk Faithful of Mossbark: Giving a creature +X/+0 is called Firebreathing, and it's a mostly red ability. The "Damage calculated by toughness", on the other hand, is a VERY Green/White ability. Some examples are Doran, the Siege Tower and A…
-
Wait, I did a mistake: there's an Artist without Masterwork... So I guess I'll reprint it, but what would you add in order to make it "self-synergize"?
-
@tookie1 I like the flavor of the card, but it looks...out of place. Sand Land could easily be rewritten as Desert Land, since that is an official land type. I guess the "colorless" mana is supposed to be Sand mana, but still, you could've just said…
-
@SteampunkDragon Go look at all the common cards that we have, on the first page of the thread. If you pay close attention, all the Artist creatures have Masterwork. SO I didn't make it an Artist despite it being clearly fit for it, because of possi…