MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Scott_Anderson
About
- Username
- Scott_Anderson
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,298
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@ranshi That means each color combo only gets 2 multi or hybrid cards? In total? Let me suggest the following distribution: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1BnhSRV88l1vWkxMvMrqfQ9Ib4PUNqFKI/view?usp=sharing I've only completed the parts of the fi…
-
@ranshi is not going for the planet concept. Islands are fine. (It’s too bad Island is also a card name!) Please ranshi continue to propose the fiction that would go with the island concept.
-
@ranshi I think you had a typo -10 Two-Color Islands of 20 Cards. (200 Total) -10 Three-Color Islands of 20 Cards. (200 Total) -5 Large Mono Color Islands consisting the most heavily of commons and uncommons. (320 Each) Those mono blocks should b…
-
@ranshi got it. I’m thinking...
-
@corwinnn you know, I have tried that. There must be nonpornographic depictions of horse-men somewhere.
-
@tenebrisnemo great job. It’s very green but also clearly an artifact. Good use of the portal concept.
-
@leaf_juggernaut thank you. I will proceed under the assumption that we will be breaking up the Cardsmiths by assigning each the tiny planet of their choice. While I am a novelist please do not defer to me on story detail ideas or overall storylin…
-
@sorinjace the Investigator's Portal is marvelous. Maybe it's too expensive at 8? I mean to say it's a "win more" card rather than a win card.
-
Thank you @sorinjace ! It's always a treat to see what Corwinnn &c. like from my cards
-
Ben that's wonderful, thank you @benw yes, Nick Bottom, DUH
-
@temurzoa hm. I'm sorry for that.
-
My biggest creative weak spot is making red/white cards. I will be happy to create for any other color combination.
-
@DrakeGladis still early stages in lore/main characters but it appears we will have particular cardsmiths make contributions which focus on a particular color set (2 colors or 3 colors), particular tribes (pick a couple-three you like) and contribut…
-
@DrakeGladis oh they're both wonderful cards! The green aura is just right. It's 100% green, it's efficient without being cheaty, it's the right rarity, the picture is great and the flavor text is great. You did an awesome job.
-
@Ranshi, you could do a Radkos set? Or a Grixis? Or both?
-
@Corwinnn Gosh...
-
Anyway I have been brainstorming about all kinds of heroes and villains as well as a ton of Dwarf guys. Who knows what will be useful, but that’s where my mind has been: Legendary creatures and Dwarfs.
-
So... the various shards are more like planets in a solar system? Not exactly... Like, just spitballing here. imagine a region of space contained within a crystal sphere. You can see the stars outside but inside there is air to breathe all the…
-
I am not at my desktop at the moment so please forgive me for linking the page rather than presenting the card here. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/the-clandestine-machine
-
@benw great job
-
-
Announce it already!!!
-
Other ways to divide up the sets would be roughly 310/190 or 350/150
-
Super. Okay so shards. This is an important hint for storytelling purposes. Was there some point in the past when the shards were united or were they always separate? If they were together, then what happened to separate them? Is this a stabl…
-
The islands - are they physical islands on a common planet? Are they each worlds in a plane? Are they each demiplanes like the Shards? Are they all fully-formed dimensions of their own?
-
@AxNoodle - please get us back on track. I'm getting carried away.
-
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos It looks just like me! Also it's a marvelous card. Thank you.
-
Throne of Eldraine just did a fairy tale theme! Gosh. It looks like such fun that I’m tempted to buy some! Reason I mention is that we should probably not choose themes that are fairly close to what the real sets have been for the past couple of ye…
-
Sorry for the way OT cityfolk and countryfolk issue. @Axnoodle, I knew about the Serf tokens. Are there other Serfs...? No, it appears that there are not. Still, they exist. Are there other Citizens? There are several cards which make Citizen t…
-
@Leaf_Juggernaut - @Axnoodle is correct about Urza's and Masques. I meant power levels. As for the various tribes, I don't mean to propose anything in particular. I was only sharing some of the research I had done. If someone would like to take a …