MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Scott_Anderson
About
- Username
- Scott_Anderson
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,298
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
The producers wanted NBC to bring Fat Albert to Saturday mornings, but the network programming managers refused because the series was too educational. Bill Cosby and a new production company, Filmation Associates, then took the property to CBS. T…
-
Withdrawn
-
@Futbol I think they had epic in an older set but I can't find it. Like an epic sorcery or something. In any case, it's a fine ability. It might even be overcosted. But it's in the wrong color. Blue doesn't do life gain except in conjunction wit…
-
Incidentally, there’s only on green Minotaur and no colorless ones. Four blue, six white, and the remainder black and red.
-
They are cows and bulls. Herd animals; prey animals. Herbivores. They spend most of their lives awake, on hoof, grazing; chewing over terrain and observing closely the world, lest they be taken by a predator. The bull is passion, youth, confusion.…
-
I have a completely different take on minotaurs @tigerfang8 . I think they are Jeskai at heart. They're bull people - bovine - cows - contemplative - philosophical - passive resistors - fight when they have to, but prefer peace and quiet. That's no…
-
I have a ton of commons ideas. However, the Psylian Life is still out of my grasp
-
There is not enough room on these cards for decent flavor text. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/hurloon-diplomat
-
Wait, when can I ask for another one
-
@Battlesocke and cardsmiths in general: My pet peeve is that sooooo many creatures we make have hexproof even when there's no flavor reason for them to warrant it. One of the key premises is that every creature should have a good way to deal with i…
-
Great job, you furry punsters! Congrats to the winners and a hearty Bronx cheer to the weiners with their unbearable puns!
-
Scotty2Hotty is definitely red, yes.
-
Shadow I like it. I Forget what I said on it but I faved it
-
general question; not specifically about this one. I have noticed that there is a flurry of interest for most contests withing the first 3-4 days, and then almost no interest after about a week. Why do contests run for so long? Anyone have a theo…
-
@jpastor - A Mystery Challenge: Create a noncreature Artifact with Sunburst (This enters the battlefield with a charge counter on it for each color of mana spent to cast it.) Thanks! https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/clockwork-oracle
-
Fat albert! Yay
-
When I re-focused on the planeswalker, I thought about Baron Sengir, of all things. Now obviously that card is way down the power curve compared to today, but I thought about how it made me feel when I saw it or played against it. I felt hopeless, l…
-
Wait, is this for season points? I thought it was just for fun Man o man @jpastor, I would like to open 1 million mystery boxes please
-
@daveottley This would be fairer if the life loss was like 2 or 3 per turn. Putting this kind of clock on the game on a shrouded enchantment seems too strong.
-
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos - Based on lots of input from other smiths, I made a moderately big redesign on your card. Errors included color pie breaks, super-efficient ultimate, and lack of strong flavor. I liked it. But I'm very new to planeswalkers tb…
-
Thanks Sylux. I don’t think Tormenting Ancestor is playable to be honest. The cost is too high. There are plenty of spells that draw you cards, and none of the playable ones have such a steep cost. Printable? Yes! Playable? No.
-
Hm. I made that mistake but I don’t know... should black be fear and blue be sadness?
-
@shadeshinobi1 I missed something. Does Decujoh have some cat thing going on?
-
May I suggest? Blue's emotion is sadness. A way to use that offensively is to inflict sadness and despair. Therefore I think there should be a higher than normal number of blue cards that say "tap target [PERMANENT OR PERMANENTS]. It/they do not un…
-
I'm having trouble telling whether this is playable in draft, playable in standard, playable in modern, or broken. I think it would be really good in commander. I really can't tell. It's a hard card for me to judge. Can someone help? https://mt…
-
@Scott_Anderson Your mystery box contains: - A Mystery Challenge: Create a green creature with an additional cost to cast. - A Mystery Challenge: Create a common, white Bird creature.
-
Ohhhhhh I changed the posts with my entries to reflect those rules. Thanks @Kalamekhar @WickedShadow196
-
@fallen_lord_vulganos Bolas is the premier Grixis planeswalker so naturally his abilities serve to inform other Grixis types. On the other hand, he’s kind of a cheatyface because he can do things with plus abilities that other walkers do as minus ab…
-
I may have to pull the CMC 2 planeswalker. I'm getting some static on it.
-
"life matters" is looking harder and harder to implement in a satisfying way.