MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Scott_Anderson
About
- Username
- Scott_Anderson
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,298
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Thursday, May 17, 2018 Challenge: Choose one-- (2)-- Create a dual land with a coastline in the artwork.
-
@jpastor I spelled the card name incorrectly. If I win today I will decline any prize. It should say COURIER asset. I conflated courier with carrier.
-
@henrythehatter that’s great flavor. It might be more like 5 CMC but it’s a wonderful card flavor wise.
-
He must really hate flyers
-
@shadow123 the card is good. The flavor text is excellent. Very good card.
-
-
Did you have a concept too? What is it?
-
@gelectrode thank you. Even though Wizards is not a big fan of land destruction, I like it as a control strategy. So I occasionally play in that design space. Here is Port Blockade: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/port-blockade
-
Does it have to be a wizard or something if it's a creature, or could it be a soldier or a dragon?
-
@shadow123 thank you for looking and giving me your opinion. It looks like Taz can be assigned as an attacker and then returned to your hand, at which point it bounces a creature. I think this is fair, because it has summoning sickness in between. …
-
Wednesday, May 16 Challenge: The next circuit challenge I may propose to the admins will be to create a new creature type called Homodeus. It's technically May 17th here, but I started the card about an hour ago, during May 16th. EDIT: fixed the…
-
What about a sorcery that creates legendary creature tokens? Does that work?
-
She is beautiful. A very appropriate goddess.
-
can you mock up a card here with the art? It doesn't have to be a final product - just so we can see it?
-
tba
-
Serra was a person but she became an ideal, or abstract concept. There’s nothing wrong with the religion of this plane being devoted to her. That’s a nice idea.
-
Help! https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/bad-manners
-
@dramalahr welcome! Good, interesting card. @bnew07 that dragonfire ambusher is a very interesting design. It feels more {r}{g} than {r/g} but it’s definitely in the right colors.
-
I too would like to know what kind of card you want to see.
-
Sure, like a Jackal Pup
-
Yes he needs to be a 1 or 2 power. Potentially filling your hand in one attack is too much.
-
@jpastor he’s dreadfully strong. Probably strong enough to be a legend. He is at mythic, which is fine. He appears to be the top of the curve in a very low-down red aggro or a utility guy in a 5c midrange aggro similar to Modern humans. My brain…
-
Thank you! It’s nice when a vanilla creature can win. Cards don’t have to be mechanically elaborate to be interesting pieces of art, I don’t think.
-
@faiths_guide that is an optimal solution.
-
Coming from the plane of Rabiyah: It wasn't only mechanics that were unpopular.
-
I am very unhappy with the art. I don't feel like I got either side right. I think her name is pronounced "SEV-a-LUNE" Lune like Luna like the moon.
-
@Flatfish "Megamorph is the lowest-scoring mechanic of all time." That's astounding. Also: I like delve!! Oh well
-
Cumulative Upkeep was okay
-
Was Ninjitsu popular? I thought most everything in Kamigawa was a big failure
-
Megamorph was unpopular? I though Ferocious and Outlast were worse