MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Scott_Anderson
About
- Username
- Scott_Anderson
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,298
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@warriorcatinahat oh gosh that’s very sad. I’m sorry to hear it. We shall see what happens with that. If you have some cards I would love to see them. Also I just noticed what your avatar is. So cute
-
Withdrawn
-
@shadow123 that’s great to hear. I can’t wait to see some cards and themes.
-
@ranshi that’s a great mechanical hook to hang your set on.
-
Not to worry fellas. It looks like we're all behind the 8 ball here. Just keep thinking and make some cards when it feels right.
-
@izittru that’s a great concept. I’m so glad.
-
Hey everybody! Let's check in to let each other know how we're doing! Naya v Dimir @DrakeGladis Grixis v Selesnya @Ranshi Esper v Gruul @WarriorCatInAhat Bant v Rakdos @AxNoodle Jund v Azorius @Leaf_Juggernaut Sultai v Boros @Scott_…
-
Quite coincidentally, I have one.
-
Make wider cards
-
@firestarter787 LOL love it
-
That’s okay, it sounds great!
-
@blackmage740 It looks fair. But why has it got a nonzero converted mana cost if, when cast, it can’t stay on the battlefield? Why 1WB in particular?
-
Oh very good
-
@ranshi no worries. We are all working slowly as it turns out. Your name card is a marvelous concept and especially so since you’re working with curses as a central theme! The ability to tutor repeatedly is already very strong. Is it possible th…
-
That sounds like a wonderful story @WarriorCatInAhat ! Are there any main characters? Stuff for Legend cards and/or planeswalkers?
-
@shadow123 it’s ever so slightly behind the power curve. A 3/3 for 3 in two colors is not efficient. That’s not a bad thing. Not every card has to push the limit. It’s got great flavor from name to art to flavor text so I like it a lot. You do…
-
I'd like to thank the 8cademy...
-
@warriorcatinahat sounds like a great start! Have you thought up a premise or a setting so far? That can help spur your imagination.
-
Great work. Let us know when you are ready for critique. @thewanderer with a couple of exceptions the whole collection is excellent in terms of mechanics and every card has awesome flavor. Very good job.
-
Hey guys! How’s it going? Got anything to show?
-
I've made another error, but this one is a happy error: We each have FOUR Mythic slots. So the total number of cards you should prepare is 85, but you get two additional Mythics.
-
@Shadow123 Excellent constellation of spells there. Very pretty top to bottom and some nice innovation. I left comments on some of the card threads. Dream's End feels white to me. Storm Elemental is the name of an existing card. https://gatherer…
-
Great, @Shadow123 ! I’ll look and let you know on the card pages tomorrow.
-
Hey guys is everyone familiar with the mechanical differences between hybrid mana cards and multicolored cards? I don’t want to tell you something you already know but it’s good to have a refresher once in a while. Can someone tell us what’s up …
-
@Fantastickill7 of course you know how popular Aven Windlord's Charm is by now. I did comment and fave it. Pouncing Yeti is just perfect. It's so very Temur. It could definitely see print in a real set, at uncommon, just as you have it. Guys when…
-
Dragons and horses!! Horses are prey animals. They wouldn’t go to war on their own. Are they special in some way?
-
Hey everyone, Tell us a little about your story and maybe show us some main characters! Let’s see what folks are brewing!
-
Legends was designed as an homage to a D&D campaign. All the Legends in that set came from characters in the game world. Here is a set I made for my last D&D campaign, ca. 2018. https://mtgcardsmith.com/account/sets/29834 I may make a se…
-
@Dom_Rocks don’t worry about it! Make the cards you want and we will all critique each other. If you look a couple of pages ago Potato13 savaged me here. It was the right thing to do and it made my collection better.
-
Here is the card I made up before and its namesake: