MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
ShadowKnight1224
About
- Username
- ShadowKnight1224
- Joined
- Visits
- 892
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
I'm not sure if we're supposed to choose one of our submissions to be included in the set or if we're submitting a new card to it.
-
For Refraction:
-
Well, I wish I had had an opponent, but I shan't complain about victory. Great contest thus far!
-
Thank you for the contest!
-
All right, I think your first and last ability are fine. My suggestion for the middle one: "Spells in your graveyard can be cast for {b}{b} if their converted mana cost is equal to or less than the number of runes you control."
-
No problem, glad to help!
-
Take a look at the last part of Psychic Battle. "Changing targets this way doesn't trigger abilities of permanents named Psychic Battle." There's rules precedent for "X doesn't trigger abilities of Y." So I'd word it as "Unavowed (this card doesn'…
-
@touchstone Thanks for the feedback, but I think you're overlooking a very important aspect of Intervention: Because it's played on your opponent's turn, it allows them to use sorcery-speed answers before you can get value out of the card you're pla…
-
@MagicChess That's an excellent post! I love the story you built by piecing things together! One thing I think would make it even better: if, near the climax, the other races/planeswalkers intervened so that it isn't just a single character vs. Nic…
-
@IanLowenthal: Is there a limit to how many cards we can add to the set? I've been wanting to illustrate more about the creatures in each of the colours, as well as their cultures, so I was wondering if I could take the set up to 30 cards.
-
Well, just throwing some feedback here. The contest idea is very ingenious and original, but it demands a lot of work for a format that's not popular and which also curtails creative freedom by forcing you to build a specific deck in a specific way.…
-
@unicornsareevil3579 Well, those are certainly the classics, so I can't fault you for that. WR aggro, UB control and Green ramp are some of the staples of the game! Exile and chance sound like very interesting mechanics. I most definitely encourage…
-
@unicornsareevil13579: It's actually a very interesting take on a plane; one within someone else's mind. It's a cool concept, one that could illustrate some interesting mechanics. Looking forward to it!
-
@zizick123 I think the problem is that you can have a turn 1 play where you play a basic land, tap it for mana, play a 1-drop, then sac the land and pay 4 life for a 5/5 trample, putting the opponent on a ~3-4 turn clock (that can only be feasibly c…
-
It's a bug that happens when you write on the Subtype box. To fix this, either input Power/Toughness before you input Subtype (even if the boxes go away, the values are still stored and will show up in the card) or go to the Type dropdown menu, sele…
-
@Yenvon: Looks good! I think the mana refund on Lead Engineer is a bit high, but otherwise it looks pretty interesting and easy to grasp.
-
I'll submit this set of counterspells from my latest set.
-
For an individual effect, @Faiths_Guide's suggestion sounds pretty good. For a global effect, I'd take a look at the chain veil. [cost]: For each planeswalker you control, you may add X loyalty counters to it and [effect].
-
@Yenvon: It's very flavourful! There are some interesting decisions (like the Red elf), but otherwise I think you capture the feel of a plane corrupted by Phyrexia fairly well. That said, it doesn't feel mechanically unique; it's missing a mechanica…
-
Thank you for taking the time to give feedback on the mechanics! It really makes me feel invested, personally.
-
Congratulations to the winners! Some very creative entries this time around!
-
@Rednaxela Tfw you both show up to the party wearing the same dress. XD Jk tho, I like your take on Whiteless!
-
I do think you'll be the only one to submit it to the contest, yes, as people tend to avoid steering too close to other people's designs. You might find it hard to believe, but people have been designing custom mtg cards for longer than we've had t…
-
I've seen it a few times over the years, in fact! :P I have a few cards I could submit for this, but I was wondering @MagicChess if we could submit old cards or if we had to create new ones. Thanks!
-
@IanLowenthal I think I need to retrieve the link through another path. Does this work? http://mtgcardsmith.com/user/ShadowKnight1224/sets/16304
-
@Rednaxela : What's the goal of destruction? Why do they want to exile cards from the graveyard? What's the play experience you want a destruction player to have? What's their game plan? It's clearer in Creation: You want the players to sac lands f…
-
My submission:
-
Congratulations to the winners! I'll submit this for faving, thank you.
-
I think the set is ready for review. I'm definitely all ears when it comes to suggestions and feedback. http://mtgcardsmith.com/user/ShadowKnight1224/sets/16304 There's a planeswalker and an associated card there, because I wanted to provide a pos…
-
Thank you! Glad I made it just in time!