MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Shagoth
About
- Username
- Shagoth
- Joined
- Visits
- 176
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Fair Nostalgia Basically a format which is Legacy, but the banlist would be wharped around the fact that Force of Will are banned, meaning that it would need to be less blue dependent and you can have more fair decks without as many combos (though m…
-
@Decaldor The monstrosity part is really weirdly phrased, unfortunately idk how you would phrase it.
-
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/bloodfalls I figured losing cards is worse than losing life, and it would take a lot of effort/jank to break this. Weird one; http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/haze-snake One might be too tough, the other is definite weaks…
-
Do you have a planned date on when the judging should theoretically end? Not trying to rush you, just curious.
-
It's super funny because I just had a little idea years ago that Bolas was in an Egyptian Block and pretended to be the plane's god and thus, was its ruler. Also, it was four colored but that's besides the point. I just feel happy that I was right a…
-
I like this card, and I think this one is pretty clever. http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/scavengegoyf
-
One's good for a spirit tribal deck and can be splashed for white or green spirits- -The other is a reanimation or removal spell.
-
@TomIsAmazing I suggesting putting in Iris and Karou.
-
@TomIsAmazing The rules of this contest say 2 planeswalkers, unfortunately.
-
I think this dude fits the bill.
-
This is my second one for this challenge, and according to the rules this will be my last one.
-
I have a couple of ideas. Blueless/Saskia-Anti permanent, aggro seems a little boring in my eyes. Whiteless/Yidris-Lots of looting. Massive draw, massive discard. Greenless/Breya-Pillow Fort, maybe go with artifacts(?) again, also seems a little bo…
-
@Ender Being a one use card is what makes this guy unique. It allows me to use horribly powerful abilities for a two mana walker without it being broken, so it acts more like a sorcery, where most planeswalkers act like attackable enchantments. I di…
-
I fear this maybe OP.
-
These two are both pretty funny, the black one seems unbalanced but if you know some subtlties in the game rules, it's really tough to actually play. http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/puff-of-disappointment http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/convoluted-plan-2
-
@Gelectrode and @KJMartin Thanks for the feedback. KJ, though I agree that's how it would work in a dual match, in commander, or god forbid Two-Headed Giant, this card is actually far more powerful than necropotence because in addition to the larger…
-
A removal spell while only being good or great in a deck like this. Keep in mind it's the quantity of creatures, not CMC, power or anything like that. So I think this thing is pretty balanced. Might want to run 2-3 because it may vary on how effecti…
-
I'm personally pretty proud of this one, though I'm sure it could use some work. Also careful reading is reccomended. I think this could be trade secrects level of broken in commander and useless everywhere else. @kltmtg99 I think that is a genera…
-
I guess I'll throw my hat into the ring as well.
-
Well, here goes nothing.
-
1. Fblthp, Acidental Walker by @mithandir91 - not because it's funny, this is legitimately the best card design in my eyes. It has virtually no flaws and it's designed in an incredibly flavorful, useful, balanced, and creative way. 2. Gaz, Mindrot N…
-
Judging today!
-
@TheFriendlyGeek yeah but if you use Harmless offering on it, you're opponent has an 8/8 creature and you're at 3 life and they have the same life total, which isn't exactly what the challenge is going for from what I can tell.
-
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/the-lier Surprised that mine is the first demon, given their flavor.
-
@MrRansom I think it can get away with being mono-green, it could work better if it had black in it though from a flavor perspective but mechanically it gives green something to build around. Very well balanced card, it's like a fixed version of a l…
-
Kind of have a feeling I made at least one of these OP. http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/shield-of-tranquility http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/lim-the-returned http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/necrotic-potence EDIT: Removed some if it's better and I added some…
-
@helioflare I would say maybe it's too tough, but then I thought of the original Zen block angel legends and it's maybe below average. It has really beautiful flavor, though.
-
Congrats, peeps!
-
Well, I have a meta few. http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/bear-of-hate-1 http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/bear-paw-1 http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/zombear-4
-
God this is going to be tough to judge.