MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
ShaperKyon
About
- Username
- ShaperKyon
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,664
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@fiskerton My entry:
-
@Arceus8523 I will look forward to seeing it.
-
@Arceus8523 Aw thanks. Same for you and I'm glad you like my work. You're doing great stuff.
-
X. Waktet and Hialnor, part 2/2 With the squid leading the way, Kyoniq, Seira, and Fei’wet continued down the eerie passages. More hawks attacked them, but were quickly subdued by Kyoniq. They had the unfamiliar mark of white mana. Finally, the …
-
X. Waktet and Hialnor, part 1/2 The fastest way to the Tower was, of course, as the crow flies. Quite literally in the case of the airborne aven planeswalker Kyoniq and his companions, Seira and Fei’wet, who rode on Kyoniq’s summoned drakes. Over…
-
@Jonteman93 When you called Planeswalker's Journey a disappointment, you're being too hard on yourself. Planeswalker's Journey was a really great and fun contest and you did a great job running a contest of this sort for the first time. That said, i…
-
@sorinjace Wow! So many prizes! Glad you liked Pumpkin Patch. For favs I would prefer if you take a look at my cards and pick your favorites. What is a trophy?
-
@Arceus8523 I'm seriously impressed. This is the biggest cardsmithing undertaking I've ever seen. Pretty incredible.
-
@Aggroman15 Yup. Lack of face-to-face really kills meaning. Anyway, constructive criticism must bring up weaknesses by definition. I can see that more compliments from me are in order though. The old Overgrown Elemental's weakness was that it was st…
-
@MonkeyPirate2002 Well, in Planeswalker's Journey the person in the lead was often the person with the most cards, not necessarily the person with the best cards.
-
@Aggroman Wow. That's embarrassing. I wrote incorrect names for not one, but TWO cards. Sorry about that. The real cards were Dreg Reaver and Gray Ogre. Friggin autocorrect must have changed dreg to drag. Gray Ogre I confused with the similar Hill G…
-
@MonkeyPirate2002 COTW sounds good, just make sure you're giving it to the actual best card of the week instead of the person that's most ahead.
-
@AxNoodle If you have decided to keep your existing planeswalker, then I suppose you are correct.
-
@AxNoodle What button? @Aggroman15 Just pointing out that Overgrown Elemental is REALLY weak. Like on the level of Gray Ogre and Dreg Reaver weak (by today's standards).
-
@Aggroman15 I get the flavor which is cool, but even though its power level is common its complexity is not. Perhaps you could instead say "Whenever you cast an Elemental spell or Aggrol planeswalker or activate an ability of an Elemental permanent …
-
@sorinjace Smother + Dispel on one efficient card...I like it! @spookoops Are you using this code? < img src="Card Image" width="35%">
-
@Aggroman15 15 quest counters though? Is that even feasible in a normal game of Magic? You'd have to be playing Commander I think… @Jonteman93 Still debating whether to keep Shaper of Souls, change him, or make a new card.
-
@spookoops Watch those images, they're kind of blurry.
-
@MonkeyPirate2002 Where's the irony? @Bobman111 Congrats to you both on getting this far. Keep up the great designs!
-
@Jonteman93 Wait a minute…What happened to your planeswalker Jonte? Last we saw he had passed the Trial of the Guardians and was in the Second Ring, but afterwards you only mentioned Kyoniq, Aggrol, and Axnoodle.
-
I just realized that Kyoniq's Aethereal Ascent and Kyoniq, Shaper of Souls have the same mana cost and rarity.
-
@Jonteman93 Soon to be amended, though I'm falling behind on my story. I choose Option A and my new color is black. @MonkeyPirate2002 Unfortunately it seems that in the top 5 there are two white-blue-black aven planeswalkers.
-
@berretgolden I agree with @MrPirate89, Ultimate Sacrifice is broken. Probably, so is Vagruk in the right deck. First of all, it's a 3-mana 4/4 to start, which White doesn't usually get. It negates Equip costs and produces a ton of energy. That's co…
-
@sorinjace Yeah I really like Feral Conflict now. It's elegant, flavorful, on-color, and powerful, and it can also trade off two more creatures. Nice work!
-
@sorinjace It's still Prey Upon for {r}{g} and with drawback. Maybe "target creature you control gets +N/+0 until end of turn and deals damage equal to its power to target creature an opponent controls"?
-
@Aggroman15 Putting narrowness aside, Break Down Defenses is still weak. Maybe add a few abilities like "creatures you control gain trample until end of turn" that still go with the flavor.
-
@Aggroman15 For Break Down Defenses I would change the text to: Until end of turn, all creatures with hexproof lose it and gain hexproof from non-Elemental, and all creatures with indestructible lose it and gain "Damage and effects that say 'destro…
-
@sorinjace Prey Upon for {r}{g} and with drawback...?
-
@KrampisZman This contest is closed for judging.
-
@AxNoodle No, as I understand it @Aggroman15 's enchantment for Planeswalker's Heritage is Water Infusion: Tide, Planeswalker Remnant is another entered card.