MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
StuffnSuch
About
- Username
- StuffnSuch
- Joined
- Visits
- 558
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
I'll kick things off by sharing: by SevThePuppy At first, I thought the best strategy would be to get a bunch of discard payoffs, like reanimation spells and Madness Cards. There are a couple Rogue tribal cards in black that could be worth thro…
-
@cadstar369 * Frigid Fortification probably need to cost more. The design is pretty great, but it's pretty close to doing everything Thalia and Propaganda do, while also taxing activated abilities. Perhaps you could build some down side into…
-
@Faiths_Guide Late night feedings are for binge-watching light television. If you try to do anything that resembles thinking, you'll either a) fail miserably because your brain doesn't turn on or b) actually start thinking about things and then not…
-
Thanks for your feedback. I agree, Boneyard Scavenger isn't a card that's easily playable, but I mostly designed it from a flavor perspective, a scavenging dino that gets bigger as long as there are dead bodies lying around, otherwise, it starves. …
-
Not a legendary creature, but thinking about this discussion 100% impacted the design of this card, and I think it actually is one of the best cards I've made in a while from a flavor perspective.
-
-
Also, props to everyone that's concerned and doing their best to give appropriate credit for their art. The problem with AI is that, not only do you not know where it gets its data from, no one knows where it gets its data from. There are some rea…
-
So far, the most prominent legal precedent in US AI art law is that art generated solely through AI is not the property of anyone. It cannot be copyrighted or trademarked. If you were to use AI as a portion of your process, the AI generated portio…
-
-
Nevermind
-
And here's a new one:
-
Turns out, out of all my cards, there're only 2 dragons. I flipped a coin and here's my "old card" submission.
-
I was doing so good! Last time I checked the standings, just a few days ago, I was undefeated, now I'm eliminated?! Ouch! I'll get you next time @Hinges @LvB Good luck to both of you in the finals.
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/war-of-casualties https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wandering-automaton Once you've finished the paper, I'd love to read through what you came up with. I imagine most of us Cardsmiths are at least a little into game d…
-
@smax765 Awesome work with that piece of art. It takes an artist to craft the right prompt and then be able to touch it up sufficiently to really be what you want it to be. I know that a lot of people are anti AI, but you're example is a great exa…
-
@Faiths_Guide Congrats! My wife and I are also expecting a little boy around that time! It's a lot of fun, but a lot of stress. I get it. Good luck in your baby journey!
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/goblins-gift https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/matt-master-mathematician
-
Wow, I step away for a couple weeks, and all I can say is, this discussion is aptly titled.
-
IN
-
I definitely prefer a well-rounded evaluation of a card. Most cards I make may excel in one or two categories, but have short comings in others. It wouldn't be fair if someone just happened to have a bunch of cards that are really flavorful, but o…
-
I love whatever I haven't done before. I love winning with complex and convoluted combos. I love wins where it gets to the point where I feel like I can just about do everything, for instance, I had a game yesterday on Arena where I had blinked Or…
-
I have two general approaches, and I think they align with a top down or bottom up kind of approach. Sometimes, I am playing or crafting or watching MTG content and think "wouldn't it be cool to have a card that did ___?" So I make a card that doe…
-
Battle - Duel (Any player may attack a duel. Any other player may choose to block a creature attacking a duel.)
-
@kaoz42 I did this before I saw your idea, but it's a battle type called Duel. Thought you'd be interested.
-
@TheDarkKnight1234567 Can you imagine the games? "Before I take this action, let me double check your library one more time to make sure you're not able to flash in some crazy answer." or "Okay, last game you had 3 of these, but now I only see 2. E…
-
Welcome @flatmap I'm not going to lie, I absolutely love The Sky is Falling. It made me laugh and yet is flavorful and simple and interesting, everything we were hoping for. @smax765 I have to say, the Eclipse Ritualist is pretty elaborate. The …
-
Idea: A Commander for Charge Counter tribal (Also, I love this thread. So many cool ideas!)
-
Anything that's in italics is not part of the rules text. (Though, if you "keyword" some elaborately complicated ability just to mess with this discussion, we'll all see through that.)
-
Yeah, there are lots of functionally similar cards out there. There are even some official cards that are more similar than mine. It's not really a concern to me at all. Maybe mine's for a mono-red devotion deck, where it would be an upgrade. Ei…