MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
StuffnSuch
About
- Username
- StuffnSuch
- Joined
- Visits
- 538
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Here's one. Hopefully I'll be able to make some more before Halloween.
-
Cards inspired by, and using, the artwork you provided:
-
Well, I thought about what a scarecrow actually does, and I came up with one thing: scare away birds so you can get more food. Here's how I'd translate that to Magic:
-
@FireOfGolden You'd word it, "Choose a color. Choose another color for each time this spell was kicked." and "Destroy all creatures of the chosen colors." You're really close, and I like this idea of a board wipe, It's pretty well costed for wh…
-
@jpastor Your survey says select any number or leave blank, but you've made it a required question, so you can't actually leave it blank. Consider adding a "None of the above" box for those of us that just design mystery boxes for the challenge, fu…
-
@FireOfGolden I really like that you are trying to stretch the bounds of what MTG is. I wonder if there are too many unfamiliar ideas on this particular card for us to be able to give very relevant feedback, though. I'm assuming you've got a card …
-
@cadstar369 I, honestly, have no specific role for my caretaker to play. I think it would be absolutely funny to turn off imprint and suspend and impulse draw while also enabling extra flashbacks and such. I also think it could be a great enabler …
-
@cadstar369 I think I'd be wise to add a clause that says "-1/-1 counters cannot be removed from Cemetery Caretaker" to eliminate a few combos, but I think saying "It's broken with Solemnity" just means it's a pretty normal Magic card. There are hu…
-
@FireOfGolden With our other two one sided board wipe on a big body examples, they're both very much tribal board wipes. I think Cannoniant, which already has a tribal ability, could just switch to a tribal board wipe rather than targeting an oppon…
-
@cadstar369 You could also make it each opponent loses life equal to the number of times a source an opponent controls caused you to lose life. Then you could still pay life, but it wouldn't be counted for the end step trigger. @FireOfGolden 7 man…
-
Wow, I leave for a few days and come back to not only an interesting challenge but a Win under my belt. Thanks! My latest challenge was to create a creature that boosts other creatures of the same color. Here's what I came up with: https://mtg…
-
@Faiths_Guide Here's how I tackled the same challenge, in case you're interested. http://https//mtgcardsmith.com/view/mana-explosion-3, https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/inspiring-speech-6, https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/flaming-arrows-3, https://mtgca…
-
Here's a challenge I really enjoyed tackling, and you may enjoy as well. An instant or sorcery that can be a permanent.
-
I know you said final card, but you might want to go change it to untap target land, not lands. As it stands, you could untap every land on the board if you want. I think that'd be pretty OP if you drop your big 6 mana planeswalker and immediately…
-
I was just thinking about making a card with Level Up, only to realize I don't know how I'd do that on here. Guessing it's not an option yet. Also, I was wondering, since there are other custom card sites, could you provide an option to add an enti…
-
@Globert-the-Martian I like the idea, I think I'll change it to mill and/or return to hand with Delirium turning on double strike. Great suggestion. The card definitely needed a tweak, and I just couldn't put my finger on it, but making double st…
-
I got tired of people saying "Math is for Blockers". This was the result. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/matt-master-mathematician
-
@LuckyLeopard665 First, a rules point, you'd want to either say the creature that dealt the damage is destroyed, or that the controller of the creature sacrifices it. Just saying it must be sacrificed doesn't really work anymore. It has to be sac…
-
I'm up for another box.
-
@Sweda Oh, I 100% know that it's going to destroy you as often as not, and that honestly was the point. That's the game: does your opponent let you stack up counters on it, knowing you might instant speed kill a creature and win on your upkeep, bu…
-
Okay, well, there have been some side conversations, but I believe the last card was Mindripper Adept, and I don't really have much to add to the feedback already given, but I think it's a cool card, though I'd imagine it would whiff as often as not…
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/matt-master-mathematician
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/its-morbin-time
-
Affinity, but not for artifacts or any type of land.
-
I was supposed to make a red and blue creature that could scry as an ability. I really thought it would be fun to make scrying feel as red as possible, so here it is: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/illiterate-researcher In retrospect, I do wonde…
-
I love all the great references to old school Homarids and yet not feeling to old to have some fun with in the more modern world of MTG. I especially like the addition of Ward, since this guy's going to have to sit around for a while before becomin…
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/corizeth-sky-healer
-
My Box was "Create a card that uses shatter as a custom ability". I wanted to really explore the ability, so I made a mono-red cycle of three cards that all use the Shatter mechanic at each rarity. Since shatter destroys permanents, I decided to g…
-
@feralitator the rules said submissions made before or after shark week wouldn't count, but said nothing about when the cards could be designed.
-
I'm a little confused. Am I using the card Shatter to inspire an ability on a card, or am I developing a new keyword ability called shatter?