MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
StuffnSuch
About
- Username
- StuffnSuch
- Joined
- Visits
- 558
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Curious question for everyone on here: What sort of feedback are we looking for? Is this a place to share ideas you aren't quite able to get right to get feedback on how to make them work? Is this a place where you post your final product to fish…
-
Here's my take: Wilderness Redistribution 6G Sorcery Affinity for Basic Lands Exile all lands and land cards in graveyards. Beginning with the next player in turn order, each player puts a land exiled this way chosen at random onto the battlefiel…
-
@TenebrisNemo That is a really cool design. I love the flexibility and all the decisions that are baked in on when to have shroud, when to leave mana up, etc. It's definitely odd to have tap abilities on an equipment. I have a feeling this card w…
-
Happy May! (Well, we're a couple days early, but close enough) Here's your commander to break this month:
-
@Ranshi That's pretty cool. Let us know if you ever spot something.
-
New Commander coming next week! But, we're not done with Hans Eriksson quite yet. I think we're pretty close to making Hans a much more popular commander, so I'm gonna throw my hat into the ring and share a card that I think should be a lot of fun…
-
@Ranshi I'd love to hear your story
-
@Ranshi @LvB As I mentioned in the post, I really don't think that they stole my design. I actually believe Leyline of the Guildpact was spoiled before I even made my card. This is just a place to share those fun coincidences and to see what cards…
-
@Corwinnn You're doing amazing. Thanks for being such a positive protector or our community and for being fair and consistent.
-
@Mellow_MC I've already got several commanders I'm considering for May, but I'm going to wait until the last day or two of April to post next month's commander. If you have a commander you'd like considered, you can message me, and I'll look at add…
-
How is Raptor128 not banned yet? That's one that seems super obvious. At least delete the cards with blatant nudity and sexual acts depicted. Some cardsmiths push the line of what's acceptable, but this is just jumping over that line in a flying …
-
Remember when WotC banned a bunch of cards due to them being culturally insensitive? They should have just printed something like this! Hate on all the bad cards until no one ever even thinks about them again.
-
@Ranshi I knew that one, but lumped it in with the deleting discord comments in me head. I meant to include it. Sorry!
-
@Jadefire That's exactly right. That's how ninjutsu works. If you ninjutsu in a creature before the declare blocker's step, it's still able to be blocked. If you ninjutsu in a creature after the declare blocker's step, it can't be. The real fun …
-
@CultishCrusader I believe the turmoil of the site was largely due to a few specific points: * The inclusion of an AI generator in the card making tools * The disinterest in supporting the forums, including removing easy forum access from website …
-
Upon the commencement of this thread, I had not the slightest presupposition that it would, in due time, become a haven for those for whom their lexicon is not merely a tool for discourse, but a vibrant array of glorious artistry...but I'm totally h…
-
@TheCubicalGuy "mostly a pauper guy, if that means anything" Yes, that means you're awesome! Welcome back to the forums!
-
Yay, I got to use the report card button! Turns out, it wasn't really worth it.
-
@Mellow_MC Of course! This is just for fun. I'm trying to inspire creativity by building around a specific theme. If you're inspired to make a card, that's great. If you're inspired to make 10 cards, that's even better!
-
@Jadefire I just reread Balomora, and realized that instead of haste, you should have the creature enter tapped and attacking, so it can still be an attacking creature even if entering after the "declare attackers" step.
-
We are officially halfway through the month and have three great cards, but I think we need a few more for Hans to really become the go-to Gruul deck. Tag a cardsmith (or more) that you think could design a perfect card and I'll go favorite a card …
-
Aww, I missed all the fun. I've seen that "report card content" button so many times, and now I missed the chance to actually click it!
-
Remind me to never play against you! Historic spells have STORM! That's a LOT of Ornithopters.
-
@Mellow_MC I can't hear that poem in any other voice than Geoffry, the buttler from The Fresh Prince of Bel Aire. Any else remember that episode?
-
Here's a card I made that I'm positive can be broken, and have thought of some possible issues, but, I'm not sure how to get an "anti-leyline of the void" effect without it also enabling a bunch of insane nonsense. Let me know if you have any ideas…
-
@Mellow_MC A lot of the time, when an ability triggers on a creature you don't control being tapped they'll include the clause "if it's not attacking" just to scale it down a bit. With something like drawing a card for each tapping creature, you're…
-
Here are my entries:
-
@Chagren I love the card being such a faithful follow up to the "cycle" that's started with Akroma. I do wonder if stapling Future Sight (already 2UUU) onto a massive body with great keywords and then throwing on a huge cost reduction might be too …
-
You know your pleas are falling on deaf ears when people start posting here due to it's high visibility.
-
I like the protection thing, but I'd just give it trample, so a 1/1 can't chump. Love the design, though. It would be an auto-include in a Hans deck.