MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
StuffnSuch
About
- Username
- StuffnSuch
- Joined
- Visits
- 538
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/goblins-gift https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/matt-master-mathematician
-
Wow, I step away for a couple weeks, and all I can say is, this discussion is aptly titled.
-
IN
-
I definitely prefer a well-rounded evaluation of a card. Most cards I make may excel in one or two categories, but have short comings in others. It wouldn't be fair if someone just happened to have a bunch of cards that are really flavorful, but o…
-
I love whatever I haven't done before. I love winning with complex and convoluted combos. I love wins where it gets to the point where I feel like I can just about do everything, for instance, I had a game yesterday on Arena where I had blinked Or…
-
I have two general approaches, and I think they align with a top down or bottom up kind of approach. Sometimes, I am playing or crafting or watching MTG content and think "wouldn't it be cool to have a card that did ___?" So I make a card that doe…
-
Battle - Duel (Any player may attack a duel. Any other player may choose to block a creature attacking a duel.)
-
@kaoz42 I did this before I saw your idea, but it's a battle type called Duel. Thought you'd be interested.
-
@TheDarkKnight1234567 Can you imagine the games? "Before I take this action, let me double check your library one more time to make sure you're not able to flash in some crazy answer." or "Okay, last game you had 3 of these, but now I only see 2. E…
-
Welcome @flatmap I'm not going to lie, I absolutely love The Sky is Falling. It made me laugh and yet is flavorful and simple and interesting, everything we were hoping for. @smax765 I have to say, the Eclipse Ritualist is pretty elaborate. The …
-
Idea: A Commander for Charge Counter tribal (Also, I love this thread. So many cool ideas!)
-
Anything that's in italics is not part of the rules text. (Though, if you "keyword" some elaborately complicated ability just to mess with this discussion, we'll all see through that.)
-
Yeah, there are lots of functionally similar cards out there. There are even some official cards that are more similar than mine. It's not really a concern to me at all. Maybe mine's for a mono-red devotion deck, where it would be an upgrade. Ei…
-
Just for fun, here are the two cards that I made back to back that inspired this discussion:
-
It is the big day, so I thought I'd drop one more creepy card. Not really sure what category it fits best, but, this is just for fun anyways, so, who cares.
-
@FireOfGolden At least you have a definitive answer. I, however, have managed to draw as many rounds as not.
-
Yeah, I don't know if I've ever scored this low. I don't really care (I'm not especially proud of most of the cards I've got going this week), but I am really curious what aspect is being judged that would be so low scoring across the board.
-
@Jadefire Love the Pun!
-
So, I just made both sides of a double sided card and was curious, since it's been forever since I tried the double sided thing, does this league score them separately or together?
-
For the "Oh the Horror!" contest:
-
@FireOfGolden I can't say how awesome it is to see so many amazing cardsmiths exploring my Relapse mechanic. It's really cool to see the ideas that I would never have come up with on my own. I absolutely think Body's Disintegrate is one of those g…
-
Can you review The Blob? Would be a nice Halloween special if you want to wait until closer to the end of the month.
-
That's really cool! I like the fact that his ability is most potent in the graveyard, but also that's where he's most at risk of getting shuffled away and lost forever. I love cards that are walking that line of helping and hurting themselves.
-
Well, at least I'm consistent. I scored 85, 85, 85, 85, 85, 80, and 85 this week.
-
@jpastor I don't believe the equipment would work, because the creature is not equipped anymore when put into a graveyard, but I really like the modal spell (though that option might have to read "this card gains relapse as it resolves" or something…
-
Really like the Challonge setup. It's nice, when taking a loss, to also see I have 3 cards that got a score of 93, so I'm not actually doing so bad, just had a rough match up.
-
Awww! They're so cuddly...sorta.
-
Is The Blob a classic Halloween monster? It's definitely a classic monster, and I really like this design, so I'm putting it here:
-
Okay, so we're at: Relapse (When this card is put into a graveyard from anywhere, shuffle a random card from that graveyard into it's owner's library.) I think that works and, somehow, is also the shortest reminder text I've put up so far.
-
I think this is what we should go with: Relapse (When this card enters a graveyard from anywhere, choose a card at random from that graveyard and shuffle it into it's owner's library.) Any issues with that wording?