MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
StuffnSuch
About
- Username
- StuffnSuch
- Joined
- Visits
- 538
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Here's my spicy challenge: Create a card that has more than one variable value (X mana cost, * power or toughness, etc.) but that wouldn't seem outrageous to add to a beginner level deck. (P.S. My wife will judge the card, she's played four or fiv…
-
I consider myself a talented musician, and a mediocre artist. It didn't take much to become good enough to recognize what it is I'm drawing, but I know for a fact that even if I were to devote tremendous amounts of time to improving my artistic ski…
-
That makes a tremendous amount of sense. I hadn't considered the sourcing of the image generator to be considered theft, largely due to the fact that, if done by a human, certainly would be considered transformative enough to fall easily under the …
-
Create a multicolored creature with an ability that costs {1}: Also, thank you for the 2nd place rating! It feels great to be appreciated.
-
Maybe not my place to say, but tapping down other fliers (potential blockers) makes it much more evasive. I read this as absolutely complementing flying.
-
@LvB That's actually not the case. Creatures stay creatures, enchantments stay enchantments, artifacts stay artifacts. This only affects the sub-types, so if you have a Creature - Soldier, the Soldier part is the creature type, the creature part i…
-
@Creid233 Yeah, I wanted to just say subtypes, but I don't ever actually see that on any real card text, which, I agree, is weird. I agree, this would be a absolute rules nightmare, but, it's also a really cool effect that interacts with a lot of t…
-
@jpastor My office Wi-Fi blocked the image you attached. What was the cost I'm looking for?
-
@Creid233 This seems really cool. I'd be curious if future battles (that aren't sieges) will work with this, or if they'll become too good. We've all seen those cards that start fairly balanced, but then we get more stuff to go with them and they …
-
And this is why I'll never invite @TheKeefMan to my game nights. Cool card idea, though.
-
@theirintheattic I 100% agree that there is a lot of value to using real art, and you pointed out some reasons that's worth your while. I'm really concerned about your initial argument, which both seems unsupported and almost immediately contradict…
-
I think that the issues with AI art are more about whether they can compete with or even replace human generated artwork, as well as designating ownership of such art, since both the AI programmer and the user of the program both can claim it's thei…
-
A spell that copies something other than a creature: I'll take another box.
-
Dibs on copying something.
-
Me, too. Box please!
-
I can't design a custom mechanic and not design at least a few cards that explore the space. Now I'm not sure whether I'd rather show the card that's most interesting, most representative, or most powerful. While I'm thinking of it, here's the new…
-
I'll take a box
-
@cadstar369 Okay, I've considered a lot of options on how to run with this, but, the cards you showed were all enablers, and I wasn't really sure what the payoff would be to build P/T switching tribal, unless I designed a commander that is a pay off…
-
I definitely don't think it's over powered. I'm not sure it really fits with sweep since sweep always had returning lands to hands as the cost (which, admittedly, is why it sucks). Having an ability that depends on the number of cards cast and pai…
-
@cadstar369 You said most relevant effects aren't in red. Can you let us know what sort of effects you're wanting to work into the deck? Are there specific cards you'd like to make work?
-
I really like how you made the experience counters a resource, which makes it so you can actually go down in experience counters, which is something I don't think has really been possible before.
-
I really think it's a cool challenge to build a deck that features all 8 creatures that give experience counter to players. The obvious commander would probably be Sisay, Weatherlight Captain, since she can tutor for each of your experience counter…
-
Okay, I'm going with this one. I think it fits the entire challenge, plus fits it all in the text box.
-
Dang, that's a lot to fit in one text box. Dice rolling with multiple effects, something unique, and flavor text? I made a cool card, but I'm going to try a couple more ideas to be a little more economical with my design and fit the challenge bett…
-
I'll take a box.
-
@BT9154 That's what I was thinking, too. Non-zombie really makes it a much more interesting card. I've updated it as such. Thanks for the feedback.
-
@Hinges You can always make a saga on another platform (MTGNexus has a pretty straightforward Saga design tool). Alternatively, you can make a saga just by making an enchantment with the type saga and make the text something like: I - First Chapte…
-
@cadstar369 I love it! Thanks!
-
@BT9154 So, I was looking at Open the Graves and realized I totally forgot to make War of Casualties say "non-token creature". 'Cause, yeah, it's totally busted if it triggers off the tokens dying. Though, I might make it say "non-zombie" instead. …
-
Just missed the Champion Match, dang! But, can't complain, I finished the season with my first time breaking 2000 points.