MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
StuffnSuch
About
- Username
- StuffnSuch
- Joined
- Visits
- 558
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Dibs on copying something.
-
Me, too. Box please!
-
I can't design a custom mechanic and not design at least a few cards that explore the space. Now I'm not sure whether I'd rather show the card that's most interesting, most representative, or most powerful. While I'm thinking of it, here's the new…
-
I'll take a box
-
@cadstar369 Okay, I've considered a lot of options on how to run with this, but, the cards you showed were all enablers, and I wasn't really sure what the payoff would be to build P/T switching tribal, unless I designed a commander that is a pay off…
-
I definitely don't think it's over powered. I'm not sure it really fits with sweep since sweep always had returning lands to hands as the cost (which, admittedly, is why it sucks). Having an ability that depends on the number of cards cast and pai…
-
@cadstar369 You said most relevant effects aren't in red. Can you let us know what sort of effects you're wanting to work into the deck? Are there specific cards you'd like to make work?
-
I really like how you made the experience counters a resource, which makes it so you can actually go down in experience counters, which is something I don't think has really been possible before.
-
I really think it's a cool challenge to build a deck that features all 8 creatures that give experience counter to players. The obvious commander would probably be Sisay, Weatherlight Captain, since she can tutor for each of your experience counter…
-
Okay, I'm going with this one. I think it fits the entire challenge, plus fits it all in the text box.
-
Dang, that's a lot to fit in one text box. Dice rolling with multiple effects, something unique, and flavor text? I made a cool card, but I'm going to try a couple more ideas to be a little more economical with my design and fit the challenge bett…
-
I'll take a box.
-
@BT9154 That's what I was thinking, too. Non-zombie really makes it a much more interesting card. I've updated it as such. Thanks for the feedback.
-
@Hinges You can always make a saga on another platform (MTGNexus has a pretty straightforward Saga design tool). Alternatively, you can make a saga just by making an enchantment with the type saga and make the text something like: I - First Chapte…
-
@cadstar369 I love it! Thanks!
-
@BT9154 So, I was looking at Open the Graves and realized I totally forgot to make War of Casualties say "non-token creature". 'Cause, yeah, it's totally busted if it triggers off the tokens dying. Though, I might make it say "non-zombie" instead. …
-
Just missed the Champion Match, dang! But, can't complain, I finished the season with my first time breaking 2000 points.
-
Then I'd suggest "Exile all creatures and planeswalkers. For each card exiled this way, it's owner puts that card in their graveyard and creates a 1/1 black and red Zombie Cat creature token with deathtouch and fear." Though, there are almost no ca…
-
Oops! I started commenting, but had to go away for a while, and obviously, some more posts came through before I got to finishing. My bad. Let me give some more feedback: @LvB Zombie Apocatlypse needs to be worded "Each player sacrifices each cr…
-
@LvB I think that Stellar Ring is a pretty busted card. It's, if nothing else, a free spell. I'd make it come into play tapped, so it can't immediately give back the mana spent to play it, or make it cost 2 (or even 3) to play. Both would be fine…
-
I agree, though, if it's an artifact heavy set, I'd consider Charge counters, which are basically what you're going for, but generally artifact specific, just like oil counters are also very similar but phyrexian specific. I'd find some term that r…
-
Here's a simple idea for a modal spells matters commander. I made it 5 colors, to allow for all the charms, but if I were to make it more flavorful, the B/R hybrid would just be R and the U/G hybrid would just be U. I don't know what colors you're…
-
Wow! What cool synergies. I can't believe you were able to fit Fortify, Inspired, Battalion, Annihilator, and Decayed all on the same card while making it neither incomprehensible nor hard to play with. Also, I love pickpocket. That needs to be …
-
@cadstar369 I'd love to be a card. Make me a Sculpture!
-
@FireOfGolden I'd meant for it to only pay for black pips in a cost, in other words, that it can't be spent to pay generic costs, which, as I'm explaining it, I should have it just say "this mana cannot be used to pay generic mana costs." Thanks fo…
-
@feralitator Rules question: is your high score tracked independently by different permanents, or is that a quality you have as a player? For instance, if you lose all your permanents that have score, and then play a creature with score, do you s…
-
@FireOfGolden I worded the land specifically to mean that you could only use it on actual black mana costs and only on one spell or ability per turn. I felt this a) gives it less chance to become completely busted since it can't ramp into every bla…
-
@LvB That's a good idea. I honestly considered it, but decided not to go legendary, just because it seemed like so much more work to come up with legendary sounding names. I guess I shouldn't have let laziness get in the way of good card design.
-
@LvB I've been thinking about interesting indestructible designs since you brought it up, and I came up with this one. In retrospect, it's probably over-costed, but the design for indestructible is what we're here for, right? Your comment also i…
-
@Creid233 I love the idea of Nihility. I recently built a deck with the specific restriction that no cards in the deck could produce colored mana, so I'm totally on board with the design. I wonder if you'd be able to phrase it like that "If the co…