MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Sweda
About
- Username
- Sweda
- Joined
- Visits
- 155
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@StuffnSuch if the goal was to hose exiling cards then can't you say put it at the bottom of the owner's library rather than graveyard, it's much harder to excess there than graveyard. Though I understand it doesn't fit with flavour of a gravekeepe…
-
@cadstar369 Kokunen's last ability can really cause sudden wins given the right combo card. You just need to have more life than an opponent and a card in play that says pay 1 life: there are a few old ones that do that and one or two modern cards.…
-
I was designing and templating multiple cards and I got a bit confused when I was reusing a card with the black/red frame but with green/blue mana so I though I'd make a card to capitalize on my brief confusion
-
@StuffnSuch @Tonysparks @cadstar369 Thanks for commenting, while I knew after running through my head that the win/lose effect didn't effect at all your play style making it a pretty weak draw back I thought giving phasing to an emblem was a pretty…
-
@StuffnSuch oof I think that's a very hard win condition, even if you cheat with proliferate you still need 10 other permanents in play to win the game and if you don't, well you just wiped yourself. The opponent can also actively screw you by sacin…
-
@stijnhommes I like the flavour but I agree with what others have said about the low power of the card. It did made me think about what it can be, I though up of this Saga I - Tap target creature, put a rest counter on it. Creatures with rest co…
-
@stijnhommes Feed the Earth sure is an interesting wrath and can be pretty hard to judge. It's an instant wrath, I don't think there are many of those if any and you can play it for 4 mana I think the mana should be adjusted a bit for that. Now, …
-
-
@stijnhommes This is quite expensive for what it does, you're looking at 8 mana for this card to be doing anything. On top of that you need at least 2 other card and specifically insects to swarm. Swarming has it's risks of getting 2 for 1 at mini…
-
-
@stijnhommes I think you can reword Fiery Temper to {2}{r} Instant Suspend 3 - {2}{r} If Fiery Temper was cast from exile, it deals 5 damage to each creature, planeswalker and player, otherwise chose one - - Destroy target artifact or enchantmen…
-
@stijnhommes Frogspawn Jumper - I think it's token generation is too cheap, it's actually negative mana to create a token when all other cards that can repeatedly create 1/1 cost mana, a card or both. The other abilities are probably fine but yo…
-
-
@cadstar369 ah yeah the ability to make the Tesla Coils is too cheap now that you listed some cards I did not consider. I was only thinking affinity, improvise, Urza and the handful of cards that tap artifacts as a cost, I didn't consider ETB stuff…
-
@cadstar369 Flagis certainly has an interesting ability in that it punishes tutors and strategies that can "index" (looking at the top few cards) and then using an effect to shuffle the library for better card selection, it denies them a draw every …
-
Watched the movie Redline (2009) recently so I'll make an inspired card of it for this contest.
-
Agnes, Fateteller is the wording for this good? I'm not sure how well the second ability is worded as you would expect it to work. From what it looks like it is during your upkeep look at the top card, you can play it, but the only things you can …
-
@Ashdust_II Neat card the closest I can find to it is Bygone Bishop. Yours does do a lot more in that your investigate trigger is much more easier to occur, it has vigilance and it can pass out +1/+1 counters. I think those additions are more than…
-
Was thinking about the new shield counters which lead to EMPs so then I made this.
-
FireOfGolden Thanks for liking it, initially Alecto had a return to your hand ability rather than Unearth but I felt it was a bit too straight. I think typically the play would be to suspend for 2 place 2 mark counters and kill a card when it enter…
-
@hileandr Thanks for reviewing some comments to your critique Uchigatana - I like your version better, it does pressure them better to pay and discard cards in not the most favourable situations. One should keep I mind that popping a blood token…
-
@CrimsonFox Arkanach is broken because flicker effects, you cast it, draw into more flicker effects, flicker it, draw more etc... it can be nuts. I would word it so the effect happens upon casting rather then enter the battlefield. If it was that …
-
@hileandr Mind taking a look at these? Keep in mind all were designed to try and pressure the opponent to send mana on the tokens rather than spending that mana on developing thier board. I'll throw in Patches here even though he wasn't part …
-
-
@FireOfGolden Bomber - So 3CMC for a 2/1 haste that if blocked blows up to deal 4. Playing through a typical scenario is you attack, they have 2 choices, block and take 4 or don't block and take 2, then Bomber dies to it's own ability and you take …
-
@FireOfGolden The only way to add physical copies of cards into your hand that can be destroyed, put in graveyard and hands and all that is this {t}: Choose a card you own in exile with an ink counter on it, put a card you own from outside the game…
-
@FireOfGolden So the way I'm reading this is Ink will make a copy of a exiled card and put into your hand, that you then still need to cast. Not possible in paper Magic, how will this work? You scribble the card name on a proxy, sleeve it and put …
-
@Ashdust You can but I think lifelink fits well with the colours. You can make it so you can't target it for untap during your second combat so you can't double it again. You will need to do something else to untap it if you want to get those huge …
-
@Ashdust This is quite strong, if allowed to attack you can pay 4 life to make it 8/8 and gain 8 from lifelink making paying the cost to double the attack not much of a decision. Then pay to get an extra combat pay 8 life and it's a 16/16 and…
-
@FireOfGolden if the flavour of error is to wipe all identity of a permanent then why not just {2}{b}{r}{g}: Target permanent loses all abilities and gains indestructible and devoid. If it's a land it has "{t}: add {c}". I still don't understand …