MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Syrix
About
- Username
- Syrix
- Joined
- Visits
- 188
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
{Begin Salt} @FangQuil In a vacuum one could call it broken, because compared to similarly costed cards it is "inherently better" put this card into the rise of the eldrazi block. A set partially based on low costed defenders. It would not be worth…
-
If the intent is to turn it into a legendary permanent, it needs to grab my attention. I need to look at it and say "gee, that's a one-of-a-kind equipment." Just indestructible alone, and I'd probably run darksteel plate or shield of kaldra over tho…
-
Both the knife and the Locket could cost 3. One could be a rare (prob the knife for granting indestructible) and that should be okay. Not sure what to color the first ability. Fallen Child colors as Bx. I see you also added skullbriars counter abil…
-
@FangQuil ...that comes in the flavor of mythic. Do you remember Serra Ascendant? Rare. Put it into any format with bonus HP and it becomes a 6/6 Flying, lifelinking, powerhouse for W. Also see Kytheon that can for 2W become indestructible and also…
-
@Linjam To set these boundaries and limit what "cards can and can't do" is something that r&d doesn't do. It limits design space. And we're talking custom cards. Who is to say that one doesn't want to push the design space and create an enchantm…
-
Here is one that somehow even though it is completely balanced will still fall under the radar and won't be accepted as winning because it makes too much sense.
-
@ZendikarIncarnate Indeed. The first post says it all.
-
@Grimshac http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/kayus-agent-of-strife
-
@Grimshac no love for the Eris-based card?
-
@Missile1945 Something about that statement doesn't seem quite right...
-
@NarwhalKing Gotta say, if it's stupidest card you're looking for, you've got your work cut out for you. Do me a favor and don't apotheosize these to "Un-" status.
-
@NoahtheBoah36 Yes, New Phyrexia, formerly Mirrodin, formerly Argentum, formerly nothing, brought into being by Karn -Canon Karn created Argentum. Nothing fabricated here will change that.
-
Jangle, the Insufferable Location: Dominaria, unspecified Jangle was never quite like the other goblins in his Warren. Rather than violence, he turned his talents towards music. Normally this would not have been a problem, as the War Drums always w…
-
So as for the origin of the Multiverse, I can't explain how things became the way they were up until this point, but I believe that the "infinite" planes of existence were each carved out of the blind eternities by an equal number of Planeswalkers. …
-
@NoahtheBoah36 I would accept that theory except the fact that you included New Phyrexia in the mix. Karn was directly responsible for creating that plane (Argentum) in the first place.
-
In before Big Bang theory
-
Just a reminder this closes on Friday. Get those cards in!
-
@Suicidal_Deity I will look through your cards and favorite one when I get the chance.
-
@ZendikarIncarnate not sure if this was intended at me, but mine does have a drawback. It's a 2/1. It dies to most creatures and is blocked by just about every wall. Even after the delirium condition is met, graveyard hate reverts it back to a 2/1 a…
-
I pride myself on being a level 0.5 judge. I just don't have the time or the mentor to take the tests/judge events. Plus my LGS already has enough judges.
-
Assuming we have hit the upkeep and you haven't lost the game to any of the other conditions, you would "gain 10 life" which would be replaced by "draw 10/cards" further replaced by "return a card from your graveyard, if you can't you lose the game"…
-
In this case you would lose the game before the mayael win the game effect happened.
-
@Biblio1 Also, just food for thought, state based ACTIONS are as follows: 704.5. The state-based actions are as follows: 704.5a If a player has 0 or less life, he or she loses the game. 704.5b If a player attempted to draw a card from a library w…
-
This is why most win the game/lose the game effects are on permanents, not instants and sorceries.
-
@biblio1 and @fabiocbinbutter To put the matter to rest, I asked the judges at: http://chat.magicjudges.org/mtgrules/ This was the question (they wouldn't make a ruling on custom cards, so I had to modify the question) "better example i suppose. I…
-
Here's 2 for ya. Slightly used. http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/innocent-tableware?list=user http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/menacing-scrap?list=user And a favorite to whomever guesses the top down design.
-
@Suicidal_Deity you've apparently never been killed by a bobo enraged going "Niv-Mizzet infinite" through abundance and snake umbra/keen sense shenanigans. It happened the once, now I know what to look out for.
-
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/kings-chariot
-
All in all, it hardly matters how the spell works. And while I'm loathe to point out the glaring faults in the design of this card (mainly the needless "divide by zero" text) as a purveyor of the Unhinged/Unglued (have a mostly foiled Unhinged set a…
-
Here you are, a demon done for another challenge, posted here for your viewing pleasure. http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/possessed-conscript?list=user