MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
TalentedTalonflame
About
- Username
- TalentedTalonflame
- Joined
- Visits
- 106
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@cadstar369: Fracturing Wrath is an interesting concept, providing a ton of versatility and not requiring you to actually run all three of its colors. I do feel like the overload cost should be significantly higher, say {3}{g}{g}, and similarly I …
-
@ShadowReign: Menacing Hydra is such a cool card! I love the concept of spending life for phyrexian mana altering how the card itself functions. The primary change I would make is including black in the cost, just because green doesn't usually get s…
-
The judges have determined that Trueborn Champion by @TalentedTalonflame is of quality: A+ The card is creatively designed and properly formatted, providing an engaging take on the consistent Human theme of +1/+1 counters. The restriction on the …
-
-
Next challenge: Make a Human creature that is built for a Human-tribal type deck.
-
The judges have prepared their evaluation of Lethargic Monolith by @TalentedTalonflame: A- The concept of the card is relatively simple, but it seems to work well. The card has sufficient stats for its mana value to compensate for the rather stee…
-
I have a card for the challenge created by @CS101.
-
The judges have determined that Nib Gerroth, Hopeless Spire by @TalentedTalonflame is worthy of a rating of: A+ The card is excellently formatted and has a really cool mechanic. The additional cost serves to balance out the card, and the card…
-
-
Next challenge: Create a legendary land.
-
@JackDraco I really enjoyed the contest, and thank you for your kind words. You can favorite whichever cards you want. Almost forgot: https://mtgcardsmith.com/user/TalentedTalonflame
-
@TheDukeofPork How many entries are we allowed to submit?
-
The judges have determined that Dreadswamp Hydra by @TalentedTalonflame deserves a rating of: B- The card is properly formatted and fits the stated requirement while having a fairly unique overall design that remains consistent throughout. Howeve…
-
-
Next challenge: Create a creature card with some additional casting cost.
-
As an official representative of the judging panel, I am pleased to report that Corrupted Howler by @TalentedTalonflame received an evaluation of: A- The judges expressed that the card was creative and thematic while maintaining good balance. The…
-
Anyway, I think I'll use the following tiering system to grade my entries. If anyone has any modifications or improvements, feel free to suggest them. The Tiers S: WOTC-quality formatting, well-balanced, creative concept, and focused design, with…
-
I wonder how the judge will feel...
-
Here's my challenge: Create a creature with an activated ability whose cost contains colors of mana not in that creature's mana cost.
-
@Tonysparks Yeah, changing the text to non-land could work. Personally, I sort of enjoy adding "X can't be 0" because it's sort of underused text, and I don't know if I want Muashi to be able to kill tokens. But, I also like your suggestion, as it…
-
2) Monored 3) Voltron 5) Command zone effect
-
@Tonysparks I didn't want people to be able to shuffle away lands, as land destruction is really cruel in Commander. Also, three blue to shuffle away a land as an activated ability is just broken.
-
2) Monoblue 4) Islandwalk 5) Command zone ability