MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Temurzoa
About
- Username
- Temurzoa
- Joined
- Visits
- 3,616
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@Mallwan, I am confused why Spectral Phoenix is an Illusion, besides the name. Illusions are primarily in Blue's color pie, and Spectral Phoenix is fine without the creature type. Also, "form" should be "from." Nice card idea though! Thoughts on Bi…
-
@TenebrisNemo, a brilliant, well-designed card. I would just change the name because it is too Lovecraftian, which is more blue/black. What about something that summarizes an event? Like "Exodus of Mortals"? Thoughts? https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/…
-
Does the mechanic have to be created after the beginning of the contest? I have designed many abilities before, but I am unsure if I am allowed to reuse them.
-
Congratulations to all who made the top 5! @fiskerton, it was an honor competing with you, and your brilliant designs will be missed as we move on. Good luck in the future, fellow 'smith.
-
Sorry for no images, I'm traveling. The mythic is mythic because of the cmc restraints. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/prismatic-sentinel https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/prismatic-underwarden https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/prismatic-virtuoso https://mt…
-
@Hergusbergus, you might want to zoom into the artwork a bit, because it just looks like a nonpermanent card. Otherwise, I really like it! Oh yeah, might want to add flying as well, because, angels. Thoughts on this vertical cycle? https://mtgcards…
-
@bnew, can you please favorite these five? Thanks! https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/prosecute https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/numosha-city-of-choice https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/verdant-reclamation https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/protoplasmic-revelation h…
-
-
@brcien, I am sorry to see you go. We will miss you!
-
Thank you for your patience, here are my entries. I think the fundamental problem with Clues is creating new design space. This is perhaps why Clues are such a good mechanic: they are flexible, grokkable, and good for any kind of deck. So with thes…
-
Going back to my delay time, 2 days would be awesome. Thanks!
-
For Investigate, am I allowed to design cards that deal with the investigate mechanic and Clues, or just investigate?
-
Hello, I have a busy weekend and would like to delay my deadline. Thanks!
-
Are the booster packs from Return to Ravnica or Guilds of Ravnica?
-
I am switching to Investigate for Azorius. Sorry about changing so soon, it has much better design space in my opinion. This is my final choice
-
@shadow123, I think you used the wrong ability. It should be Cohort, not Rally. Thoughts? https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ryklada-synthesis-savant
-
- DELETED -
-
@Lujikul, you will be sorely missed in the future challenges. I am sorry to see you go so soon! I wish you better luck in the future, fellow smith.
-
From cardsmithing experience, hybrid mana is one of the most frustrating mechanics to get right. With strict rules and limited design space, the line is fine between creating mature, well-thought-out cards and...not. Since there were many restricti…
-
@Fiskerton, I really like that concept! Just be careful, "4" should be "four."
-
Thoughts? https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/skullbiter-sprite
-
@KanekiDemon, the reminder text for Populate should go behind the ability. Also, the cost of the ability should be after Undergrowth. Might also want to reword the last ability as "Whenever a nontoken creature dies," because you can activate sac out…
-
Guess I'll kick off the discussion. My first card, Impelled Scholar, is a common creature with hybrid mana in its activated ability. Thoughts? https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/impelled-scholar
-
@Lujikul, the correct ordering of Outcast Werepyre's abilities is flying, first strike, menace. Thoughts? https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/sirocco-elemental
-
-
Nice job to all who entered and congratulations to those in the contest! I am honored to be competing with some of the best smiths out there.
-
First of all, I am positively gobsmacked by all of the amazingly creative entries! The ingenuity of MTGCardsmith always blows me away. That being said, my biggest gripe against most of these entries are by how complex the cards are. I feel like man…
-
@Ranshi, can you please resubmit the image? It isn't working on my end. Thanks!