MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
TheAcidicSniper
About
- Username
- TheAcidicSniper
- Joined
- Visits
- 426
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@Brainifyer, nudge
-
@Class, today is the day, excited to see who wins, I've seen a lot of great entries
-
Reference the flavor text of Open Into Wonder, Nicol Bolas owns Amonkhet
-
Why do we have advocates for this?
-
What even
-
@Corwinnn, this challenge is finished.
-
And for our winner in the #1 spot, @Mila, your cards were almost exactly what I would picture if Kaladesh and Amonkhet combined. While the card art for both cards primarily leaned toward Kaladesh, the mechanics of your entries were phenomenal. Templ…
-
Moving on to our #2 spot, @Credius, I wasn't overly fond of the card art of Oversight Doomseer, but mechanically, this card was well made, both in balance and structure. I could definitely see a card of that magnitude in the Amonkhet expansion. As f…
-
Starting with our #3 spot, @sanjaya666, I felt that Aether Breastplate tied in well with the mechanics of Kaladesh while the card art clearly represented a mix of both expansions, though I felt the flavor text was a bit lacking. As for Aethercore Nu…
-
Awards and feedback will be given throughout the day today instead. I was busy last night and couldn't get to it. Sorry for the delay!
-
@Class, Soul Reliever is who I thought would go through tbh, but I agree that the artwork on Passionate Violinist is great. Gotta love the people of Pinterest
-
@Class, honestly the one I wouldn't have expected to go on lol
-
1st Place: @Mila 2nd Place: @Credius 3rd Place: @sanjaya666 Congratulations, I will give a more indepth analysis on your entries and provide your favorites and follows later tonight. Thank you everyone for participating!
-
Not accepting any more entries with the exception of the second entry from @MagicChess. I will be judging around noon, you have until then.
-
My entries (note that Prophetic Array is NOT supposed to be a common, it is supposed to be a mythic):
-
@MagicChess, yes you too, I was looking at it on my phone earlier, some comments didn't load.
-
@sanjaya666, @Decaldor, just a reminder that both of you are still short one card for your entry currently. You have until midnight.
-
@Platypusburger, seems like the challenge started only yesterday. Excited to see results.
-
Bump, good entries so far, just a reminder that for your entries to count, you must have two cards. Some of you only have one so far, and I'd hate to see the effort go to waste. For the sake of the challenge, I'm extending the deadline for cards unt…
-
@MagicChess, it's what modnation675 pointed out
-
@MagicChess, not gonna knock your entry for it, but I'd recommend readjusting the card so that the text fits. @modnation675, if you wish to change it, that's fine, but the art is ok by me if you wish to leave it. Can't wait to see the second entry…
-
@modination675 Thanks, I didnt really notice that before, but now I see the italics for reminder text on all the cards I look at. It should be fine for this challenge but I'll remake the cards afterward.
-
Cards from an expansion I'm working on that centers around a grand heist scheme. These cards showcase the Suspect effect:
-
@Class Will you be announcing which creature will be going on for each of us before the winner announcement?
-
(Nocrix's story happens between Shadows Over Innistrad and Eldritch Moon) Nocrix (Planeswalker Card) was a researcher from Innistrad who began to notice strange happenings within the city, such as deformation of life local life and dimensional tear…
-
My entry:
-
Here is my revision, I made some tweaks that will hopefully balance it:
-
@Class I'll do a revision of it within the next hour. It seemed a little broken to me, so I'm glad you brought it to my attention even further.
-
@Class I'd like to raise the point that starting loyalty can easily be hindered with instants that target Planeswalkers, but I do agree it could stand to be a bit lower. I wanted to make the win game 25-30 instead, but it only goes up to 20. I think…
-
Not brand spanking new, but I made it only about an hour ago and it is my most recent card. Let me know if it's still considered an illegal entry: