MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
TheClayKnight
<a href="CARD PAGE"><img src="CARD PREVIEW"></a>
About
- Username
- TheClayKnight
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,310
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@ChaseTheHuman Almost every forum does that actually. I've been on (and moderated) several forums over the last few years, none of them automatically deleted old threads.
-
@Oduda I'm starting to think it would be easier to just call it "Grey Mana" since it behaves like a 6th color.
-
@Sylux yeah Chase decided to post on a ton of old threads at once. Apparently the timestamps don't show for him.
-
@Corwinnn That's a good idea, but I'm not sure how it will fit with the stories I've come up with. I might have to fudge things around a bit in both directions
-
I've been working on a set with 6 major characters (each has their own color) Each of them will have a "Trials of ____" card, that will somehow parallel how they became the people they are now. Unfortunately, I have no idea how to relay their origin…
-
There is a timestamp for each post directly under the person's username.
-
Whats with all the threads from April and May of last year being replied to?
-
@stormbreath you mean like this? http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wisher-for-storms Note: that is not my entry, just trying to help out.
-
@IzzetMadMan That card's image isn't well centered, you might want to redo that or find another image. Also, while the katana was in use during this time period, the middle ages typically refers to Medieval Europe (which doesn't include Japan) of co…
-
@Tomigon, could you clarify what metrics we are judging these cards by?
-
@Nicholas_Bolas That doesn't look like a creature...
-
@Tomigon @grimshac care for a slice? http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/the-color-pie
-
@dudedaniel They are bad and you should feel bad. Oh wait read that last line wrong. oops...
-
@AlphaOmega I initially went for Japanese, but the cardsmith couldn't read the characters, so I went with dutch. Wish I had thought of Latin.... good luck!
-
Here's mine for all 9. Went for a more humorous approach. Entry: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/kleine-timmy?list=user Translation: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/little-timmy?list=user
-
@Chasethehuman He said it has to be a language you aren't fluent in. If you aren't fluent in English that's fine, if not it's invalid
-
@Boomfat "Hey Gideon, we need you to pick up the takeout." "I swear to you, on my honor-" "JUST GET THE DANG NOODLES"
-
I'm fairly certain I can do all 9 with one card (if I'm allowed use a translator for 9)
-
Both cards are very good, but they do entirely different things. The sand ninja's mechanic is very cool for a creature, but the Nightblade Commandment is the prototype for a whole new type of cards.
-
I know we don't know much about the new Colorless, but in terms of overall balance what do you think of this? http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/conjured-avalanche?list=set&set=5458
-
Mhmmmmm color pie...
-
@dramon Will of the Council was made by Wizards of the Coast http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Search/Default.aspx?text=+[will]+[of]+[the]+[council]
-
A card about thoughts http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/psiomancers-adjustment?list=set&set=5431
-
@Tomigon 28 cards is a lot when you're evaluating balance, flavor, artwork, interaction, and sometimes which of 2 versions is better. Of course it's worth going through them, it will just take time.
-
@tiagoabner looks like you published that one anonymously
-
@ginge That's fine, but if you're going that route it would have made more sense to base these off of the old Oath cards (see the link i posted)
-
I agree, the explicit purpose of Planeswalker Oath cards appears to be getting or using Planeswalkers. Most of these look like the existing non-planeswalker oath cards http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Search/Default.aspx?name=+[Oath]&output=spo…
-
Here's a card I put thought into, but maybe not enough. http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/dissolving-sorrow?list=set&set=5431
-
@gelectrode I'm not sure you understood Tomigon's post. He wants us to PM our votes. Also @Tomigon how long do we have to vote? There are a lot of cards to go through.
-
It's really strange so few people want free feedback on their cards.