MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
ThePhantomJoker
About
- Username
- ThePhantomJoker
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,856
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
ONE MORE CLARIFICATION TO THE RULES: Whenever you get any faves from this contest, send me the cards, that you want faved to personal messages (to save some space in the contest itself).
-
@Shmoohawk Oh, wow! This is so creative! I love it. It feels balanced, it looks extremely fun to play and as I've said - it is creative. You get 6 whole faves for this amazing card. @Tommyneko Your card has some major flaws, but I quite like it. Fi…
-
@KorandAngels I'm sorry, I don't really like your card. The artwork - though I apreciate it being hand-drawn - is quite messy and doesn't say much, the ability is weirdly worded and sounds a bit Unstable. I won't award any faves. @Ranshi922 We have…
-
@Ranshi922 Oh, nice, it was a new update, that I didn't know about. All is nice now.
-
@Faiths_Guide I - freaking - love - land creatures! Your card looks fantastic while also being reasonably powerful and very interesting. The minorest nitpick I would have is that there is supposed to be a dot at the end of the mana ability. But I ab…
-
@Ranshi922 Oh, and how did you manage to get rid of the number box in the first ability on mtg.design? I haven't been able to do that.
-
@TheSuturedHeartMan Yes, I very much agree! I like the overal idea, the mechanics and the question mark in the subtype is a pretty interesting touch. I'm feeling generous today, you get 3 faves for Angela. And here's a bonus: I really enjoy interest…
-
@SteampunkDragon You got it there
-
By the way I've made another clarification to the rules: If I award only one fave, it doesn't have to be for the posted card. I've changet this in the description as well.
-
@shadow123 Absolutely! I now, it's simple and that's the point. And I absolutely love your card. Amazing use of the iprint ability word and an overal interesting card. I'm struggling between three and four, but the more I think about it, the more I …
-
A clarification to the rules: you can submit another card only after you got feedback on the previous card you posted.
-
@Je_Suis_Oluwa Um, sorry, I'm not a fan of this concept. I won't award this any faves. @Vert Nice card! I slightly miss a race creature type, but otherwise I like it. It feels balanced while being good. You get 2 faves (one on the witch, one on som…
-
Love it. I'm deciding between 3 or 4 faves. But I think I gave you more than enough on the Scarecrow contest. Three will do it.
-
Really sorry that I'm taking so long, everyone has probably already forgotten about this challenge and I don't really have the time and enthusiasm to judge this properly. So I'll just announce cards that I really liked and award them faves. This wil…
-
Here's my little journey:
-
@KorandAngels Sorry, but the end date was 15th of October. I know I'm late, but I don't have much time. I'll get to judging soon,everyone.
-
@TenebrisNemo Oh, deffinitely! Finally somebody thought of using the long dash in the sorcery - adventure.
-
@Je_Suis_Oluwa I pick Boros Warlock then
-
@Credius Very nice and original card, indeed. You got the second fave on Globb. Have a nice day
-
@Revan Oh, I got ya. Would two more entries cover it?
-
@DARKSTEEL your fave is deserved It's a really cool card
-
Ok, let's end and judge this. 3rd place is given to: @DARKSTEEL I think that planeswalkers can tap, but that's a minor problem. You get 1 favorite of your choice. 2nd place goes to: @Credius You get 2 faves. And 1st place is: @SteampunkDragon Con…
-
Also, I fixed the image on the first comment
-
Oh, that was quite unintentional to be honest Yeah, I guess it is balancing, but I didn't reslise, that I wrote "creatures" and what that actually means for the card. Thanks for your response. I think, that Vehicle commanders are very unlikely to …
-
@Faiths_Guide How very fascinating! I don't regret letting you post more entries in the slightest. @Arceus8523 Oh, ok, I see now. Thanks for explaining! @Credius Your cards look very nice, I just think they're a bit overpowered. A 2/2 for two is o…
-
@Flameice2 I don't know what code you are using to post the image, but it should be changed by changing the value after: width="N" It should be in percents I think.
-
@Norzael Love the card! That second ability is awesome, I just like it, can't explain why. I'd just add to the wording - "each opponent loses 2 life" instead of "all opponents lose 2 life". Minor detail. And could you please add a flavor text or off…
-
@Flameice2 Could you please make the images a bit smaller? That Catacomb Crocodile is ENORMOUS! And it is quite disturbing... Also I like the idea of a color being added with each evolution, I just think that you should calm down a little with the a…
-
And here goes another one!
-
Here's my entry: I'll probably make more. Also: the thing that you say is "newly" seen in Eldraine, was actually already featured in Dominaria with Blackblade Reforged - "Equip Legendary creature"