MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Tigersol
About
- Username
- Tigersol
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,803
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Hello there, it's Tigersol the lurker. This has been silent for a while so I thought I might chime in on the mechanics. Specifically, I would like to offer my thoughts on Masterwork and Discover. First, I believe that there should be no cards that…
-
Thanks for changing this. I do enjoy pizza.
-
I don’t feel like ranting about this. Can we get @Letstalkaboutthis in here?
-
Dude.
-
I second @Aggroman15's question. If this has not died yet, I would like to join. What planes are left?
-
Is is acceptable to design a card for a character that exists within official Magic the Gathering canon, and is, therefore, not my own creation?
-
I remember the last time their was a thread concerning squirrels...
-
About sixth months ago Mark Rosewater announced that he had recently playtested a set with faeries in it. While this confirms nothing, there has been quite an amount of speculation that we might be returning to Shadowmoor very soon. If we did return…
-
Okay, it sounds like you're doing a big ol' Conflux here. If I were you, the best way to represent a clash of cultures is usually a mulitcolor themed set. It has been tried before, and, usually, it works. For example, the Invasion block used multico…
-
Hello, I'm Tigersol, and I am here to ruin everyone's fun by giving design advice. First of all, wording mechanics can be very tricky, but I think the the best possible wording for Compel as of now is the way @MemoryHead phrased it: "Compel target c…
-
Wait, how many sets is this? May I also mention that small sets and medium sets do not exist any more.
-
I really like discover, and I believe that is ticks off all the boxes it needed to; however I would remove the "flash" aspect of it and put it onto sorcery speed effects.
-
"You call this a war," he says in a old, crackly voice. "You children these days have never seen the horrors of what war truly is. It's terrible. I remember fighting in the trenches of Bidoof territory, dragon fire and Squirreltopian artillery blazi…
-
It's only one more day till I'm done with first semester finals, so I may be able to enter soon.
-
Ooh... that would be super cool.
-
Nice! Looks fun to play!
-
@FizzyGig Artia is very, very powerful.
-
@EnvyReaper I am merely saying that you will need some lore element to make this concept possible as a set in a combat based game. For example, Rezatta is a renaissance plane, although we are working on a set conflict. For Dumaran, perhaps the farme…
-
Eureka! doesn't really click for me. I enjoy mechanics that increase power, such as support, but there are many times where a Eureka! card is just really bad if an opponent controls a creature with high power or toughness. Perhaps something that dea…
-
Everyone here, Magic the Gathering is a game about violence. You can't make a MTG set about peace, as nice as it may seem.
-
@pjbear2005 So could I be from an existing Magic the Gathering plane that accidentally stumbled across a gate between planes?
-
@Ningyounk Oh, okay, I get it now. Thank for clarifying.
-
I don't believe you should add a farmer creature type, although a new mechanic that goes of creatures, representing them being farmers, probably works.
-
The set name seems odd, considering this is a game about killing your opponent with fire, death, and horrific monsters before your suffer the same grisly fate at their hands.
-
@EnvyReaper I can help with your set if you like.
-
Hello there! Just a few quick questions: - Is this set in the Magic the Gathering Multiverse? - Do were have to follow one of the Dungeons and Dragons classes?
-
I had a friend give me two Kaladesh booster packs for my birthday once. I puled a masterpiece Aether Vial.
-
@Ningyounk I don't think elated and cycling should be restricted to two colours. Elated supports too many archetypes to have it be constricted and cycling generally smooths out every colour.
-
@EnvyReaper Tricks and deception is blue's thing (i.e tapping effects, counterspells, hexproof giving combat-tricks, freezing effects) On death: White sees it as a terrible thing that must be avoided. Blue sees it as the end of life, and not much mo…
-
@Ningyounk I may be incorrect, but should we begin to think about limited archetypes?