MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Tomigon
Wasabi!
About
- Username
- Tomigon
- Joined
- Visits
- 11,502
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member, Moderator
Comments
-
Aasehdd Betrayal [Cost] ([Cost]: If this creature would die this turn, you gain control of it instead. Any opponents may activate this ability.) Aggroman15 Hidden (This creature enters the battlefield face down as a 2/2 creature. Whenever it at…
-
@Faiths_Guide It is odd. But personally, making a reminder card like Monarch or a new zone/rules feel more odd. But you don't get minus points from being odd in this contest, so whatever you choose, I'm looking forward to seeing what you can come u…
-
@Streamjumper Sounds interesting!
-
@Faiths_Guide Adding abilities to face-down permanents is possible. Adding abilities to exiled cards is also possible( https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=delay ). So I believe adding abilities to exiled face-down cards works,…
-
@ArmisJoe Nice!
-
@sanjaya666 Oops, I didn't look at that card carefully. The challenge is about sending cards to exile face down, so that card doesn't count. Sorry!
-
@sanjaya666 Thanks for submitting 3 cards. I like (They are 2/2) reminder @ningyounk Like I said to Faiths_Guide, if you are ok with not shuffling the cache, then it's fine. Everything works on rules, I guess. You asked for an example of why I d…
-
@Corwinnn I think he's a very popular artist! XD
-
@ningyounk 2) Should you shuffle your cache every time you add a card to it? I would say yes. That's how WotC would design cards. Ghastly Conscription, Jeskai Infiltrator exile two or more cards in a face-down pile, then shuffle that pile so that op…
-
@Faiths_Guide I believe my version is cleaner and I like to have reminder on cards, but people have different preferences XD
-
-
@EnvyReaper How important the color pie is in this challenge? I think basically the transformed side shouldn't do things the original side's color can't do. Avacyn, the Purifier(mono red that deals damage to each creature) transforms from mono whit…
-
@Faiths_Guide Your Notion Mentoring's reminder already skipped a lot of informations, so I felt like why not remove the reminder! lol This is the card I made with my version of cache. I tried to make the reminder as short as possible, but it's sti…
-
@Faiths_Guide Oh, I was only looking at ningyounk's cache-zone card. In "cache target permanent", "cache" is your action. And cache-zone card says "When YOU cache a card, put it HERE." That means a permanent you don't own can go to your cache and…
-
@Faiths_Guide Where? It says "When you cache a card, exile it here face down". You also said "Cache target permanent" can happen. That means if you cache a permanent you don't own, it goes "here(your cache)", and allows you to put it into your hand…
-
@Faiths_Guide If you say so, that's ok. Then maybe you should make them say "turn the known cards face up" or something. Otherwise they would put sticky notes on your cards lol. Also, exile is the zone all players share. And you are trying to make…
-
@Faiths_Guide No, my point is, if you cache permanents or any other revealed cards, even if they become face-down, opponents would try to remember which cards are which by using this thing(I don't know how it is called in English) Check out Jeska…
-
@Faiths_Guide I see. You probably didn't have effects like "cache target permanent" in mind. That's fine. If your library is the only zone that you cache cards from, adding cards you don't own to your hand can never happen. But you still need to sh…
-
@ArmisJoe Anytime!
-
@sanjaya666 You don't cast the copy? https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=413765 Cards like Doublecast or abilities like Storm don't say "cast the copy", because their original spell were already cast. https://gatherer…
-
They changed "name a card" to "choose a card name". I don't know why. https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=452962 ----------- Flash When Mojo Prognosis enters the battlefield, choose a card name. Put all spells with t…
-
@sorinjace Yeah, that card didn't break any rules, but it just didn't have the point of exiling cards face down: Face-down cards should be like your 2nd hand/library(1st example card), smoke bomb that confuses your opponents(2nd example card), or s…
-
@Faiths_Guide Oh.. I discussed with @fabiocbinbutter a lot about his cache mechanic. He never agreed with me, but the problems of the original are- 1) No matter how many cards you cached, if you don't shuffle them, opponents can take notes and remem…
-
@RohanDragoon That's a very interesting card! But there are two problems.. 1) WotC would make it say "as a 2/2 creature" after "Return them to the battlefield under your control face down". But if you say face down permanents are always 2/2 creatu…
-
-
@ArmisJoe Those are very cool cards, but your Rooting Riverside doesn't count because it exiles the card face up. Sorry!
-
@shadow123 What a coincidence! Ok, I'll accept that card!
-
Check out the winners of "Mechanix challenge 38"!!! http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/4298/mechanix-challenge-38/p1 -1st Place!!! "Enticing Merchant" by @bnew07 -2nd Place!! "Bringer of Blizzard" by @TenebrisNemo -3rd Place! "Shackled Colt"…
-
It's time to announce the winners!!! Honorable mentions "Ancestral Spirit" by @sorinjace 4 mana is too cheap for two 2/3s with that ability, but I love the idea of giving your teammate a copy this card. It would make the game more strategic and f…