MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Tonysparks
About
- Username
- Tonysparks
- Joined
- Visits
- 4,331
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Ok looks like everything is in order @Corwinnn, take it away.
-
Thanks for hosting. Congrats winners
-
@Corwinnn Once spellpiper posts their favs can you close this challenge.
-
@SpellPiper2213, I'm sorry but this challenge did not pick up as much heat as I wanted it to, you can have 5 favorites of your choice and ill close this one.
-
@BT9154 : You get 5 favorites (3 of your choice and 2 of mine) @samconsumespie: You get 3 favorites (3 of your choice) @SpellPiper2213: You get 2 favorites (2 of your choice)
-
(Individual feedback for the remaining cards) 4th: @SpellPiper2213 's Karri, Master Of Spears: This card is theros material, I really liked the heroic javelineer feel of Karri that the +1/+1 counters had. Im a little disappointed that exalted didn'…
-
Sorry for keeping you guys waiting 1st Place is @BT9154 's Egil, Heart Of Steel The card was everything I asked for. It made me think of a heroic warrior, leading his battalion by example, and shaping their hearts into steel with his sheer inspira…
-
(entry) Alum's party has always valued convenience, especially with their negative history with magic, they have never been ones to trust anything except human ingenuity to keep them safe. They travel using spell bound caravans, crafted from moon-s…
-
I guess we are not doing this then?
-
The new deadline is June 23rd, if less than four people join, I will give the cardsmiths who entered 5 favorites each instead.
-
I'll extend the deadline a little bit since this didn't pick up that much traction if you guys don't mind.
-
Sorry I'm behind, Judging will begin soon
-
@spookoops, I summon thee.
-
Bump.
-
Bump
-
@KorandAngels I'm enjoying putting this series together. I actually have one more idea for a contest but I will wait a month after these ones. I don't wanna flood the forum with them.
-
@Void_Retainer, yep, that counts as a hero, he is just a hero of phyrexia. A villain to others, but a pyrexian hero.
-
I'm not in this contest but here is a judging reminder @Commando
-
@Zaheer_The_Grim 5 entries total
-
Thank you for hosting the challenge @SpellPiper2213 I would like 2 of my favorites to go into your favorite hero or villain in my Fabled Heroes or Nightmarish tyrants set. https://mtgcardsmith.com/user/Tonysparks/sets/58967 https://mtgcardsmith.c…
-
I'm updating the list to add Exalted
-
@LyndonF that's fine, but I'm not necessarily judging based on weather the mechanics fit the set, rather how the mechanics work with the card.
-
Bummer, was really looking forward to it.
-
@SpellPiper2213 not necessarily but you will lose a point for fit and finish since it adds to the aesthetics of the card.
-
bump
-
I noticed that people might want to include flavor texts, so if you are out of space, I'll allow you to right a short flavor text under it instead of crowding the card.
-
@KorandAngels Sadly no. I view vigilance as unwavering resolve and stamina.
-
The challenge ends at June 15th
-
-