MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Tonysparks
About
- Username
- Tonysparks
- Joined
- Visits
- 4,331
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@cadstar369 Unfortunately I can not give you any more reviews for this card that I haven't already given prior so I will mark your card in my post for the next person to review before mine. Card by @cadstar369 review this first @Shelko I ap…
-
@jpastor no pressure, but the humor and commentary is appreciated.
-
@theirintheattic ngl, you are A league. I hadn't even noticed you tucked into B-league
-
@Sweda Avatar of humility is a kind off unbalanced in my opinion. It's not to say that it is broken, it just feels a tad too unhinged for it's cost. It essentially grants an overwhelming splendor effect for 4 cmc as long as you can get stun count…
-
Welcome back @TenebrisNemo tell me your thoughts on Nimbu's battle when you are done reading, because I think @shadow123 did an epic job.
-
@FireOfGolden For py'tex stuff It got too wordy fast si I couldn't do it the way they did with the sleeper
-
@cadstar369 -Applications In regards to Eryan, Reticient Archivist, I think it is a powerfull card so I took the liberty of finding potential combos that may work with it despite me not being a big Izzet fan. Izzet feels like a printer to me, all…
-
@cadstar369 I have to back @Sweda 's points, what you failed ti consider and I failed to bring up is the fact that in general reanimations are one time use while equipment tends to require specific attention to remove or board wipes otherwise they…
-
Right of the bat without going into to many details, I noticed you missed adding "Elemental" to its types @Sweda. I will review the card thoroughly on my next posting if it isn't reviewed yet.
-
@Castiel_Demiurge You have to leave a review of the card before you before posting.
-
Holy frick, I didn't know @Tomigon was a master editor. The more you know I guess. Good stuff.
-
@cadstar369 While making Draconarch Prototype and Phyrexian Draconarch, I wanted to embody the time of lesser time travel (temporal acceleration) as in moving time forward, and an improved multidirectional time travel. I figured that the passing of…
-
+1/+1 or -1/-1 counters* for Phyrexian Draconarch. Minor typo.
-
@cadstar369 In regards to Spellbreaker Shaman, there is not much to say compared to Blackflame, I think the card is actually as perfect as a gruul themed rate can get. It has a decent body, a flavorful effect, and fits the color and costing well. G…
-
@cadstar369 Fair enough.
-
C(omplete) R(ural) A(utomization) B(omber) Karl ?
-
My comment above is just a personal review, the next poster if not me still has to properly review both of the previous cards above
-
Holy frick @cadstar369, I am not even posting right now but I gotta tell you while you do get points from me for a dragon card, Blackflame is wildly broken. It won't end games early but once it is down it can cause some serious damage. You can simpl…
-
FireOfGolden minor typos here and there but other than that it is a pretty good card. I would personally just let it be forgotten and get my 2/2 black token with fear. I know Heju deals with discard alot so you can keep them in battle consistently, …
-
I was gonna make something on my main to that effect
-
@cadstar369 You made many compelling points. I must say that Trabor, Silver Adept doesnt rely on only a single card to get it's trigger, the more accurate term would be it relies on only two cards (which doesn't sound any better). Otherwise you ar…
-
@cadstar369 Valuable feedback as always. My reasoning for using {c}{c} in the alt version of Trabor instead of generic is because of how easily accessible generic mana is, the idea is for an opponent to use effects like Chromatic orrery's to cheat …
-
@cadstar369 Thank you for the feedback. Innitially I did have Driz's cost to {2}{R} but ended up having it all {R} since I figured red mana is not really that hard to find. I probably will change it once I upgrade the account (or not because I kee…
-
@TheGamingBolasChannel Lets air out a few dogs before I adress your card as a whole. One, I am not a big fan of reusing mtg art unless I have to so excuse me if I critisize the card a little harshly because of it. It does not reflect on your abili…
-
@cadstar369 by counter I meant in the blue sense of the word. Not in the removal sense in which the aforementioned goal of board wiping would have been accomplished. I mean you can use cards like rhythm of the wilds and simar effects to make it unst…
-
@FireOfGolden I really dig the Stickman sets. I ended up going in and liking a couple with one of my accounts. I love it when other cardsmiths make sets that tell a story. I just want you to know that from the war to one man, it's some pretty good s…
-
@cadstar369, I'd say 8-9 cmc would not be a bad change considering the fact that creatures are harder to counter, and the fact that large creatures can be made easier to cast by smaller creatures.
-
@cadstar369 Even so, I think a cost alter is inevitable for Cannoniant considering Wakening Sun's Avatar, even for an 8 cmc mythic, in a color that specializes in board wipes, still has conditional destruction that is not even targeted, and has a po…
-
@FireOfGolden, I gotta agree with @StuffnSuch . Take for example Realm-Cloaked Giant, which you might have subconsciously or intentionally taken insperation from. To achive both those effects in your one card, it would require atleast an 11-12 mana …
-
@cadstar369 As always, your reviews help me gain insight on making better cards, so thank you. With that being said, let's address a few points. In Regards To Tyvar: Yes, I know that the repeatable, modified board wipe, counter, land destruction…