MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Usaername
About
- Username
- Usaername
- Joined
- Visits
- 2,835
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@shadow123 what a lovely coincidence, a card for my challenge! It may be bad judging form to give critique, and so I wont, which sorta goes against the thread, but the card is near perfect regardless! I love simple, ordinary cards like this and I th…
-
@KorandAngels did he though? You don't get to choose which one you're assigned
-
@CassZero the prompt for that one was pretty vague yeah but this card looks great!
-
I made two cards cuz why not? https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/herana-of-the-consuming-root https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/heranas-warleader @RandomFandom gimme another!
-
im in
-
@TheDukeOfPork oh my god I totally didn't notice it said upkeep thanks for pointing that out!
-
ooh this thread is neat. I like to draw, but none of it is card worthy
-
I also voted pretty early on, but I voted! come, practice democracy you youngins
-
@jpastor one thing you could do (if you're up to the task, it would take some effort) would be to make a dedicated website for mystery box challenged. I believe google sites is free any allows you to add a comments section feature. You could then us…
-
I'm in, but I will say, I think something you might want to do (if you can) is create a better way of organizing this. I think what you're doing is really cool, but as is, it's ridiculously confusing and takes up a lot of space
-
@MemoryHead and @Everyone I will allow partner pairs to be submitted in one of two ways: 1: Both cards are submitted to a challenge as 1 entry. Barring the 5 color commander challenge, BOTH of the cards must comply with the challenge requiremen…
-
Del Rynn Demographics: Race: Human Birthplace: Mercadia Lifetime: Mending Era Relevant Magical abilities: Increased skill in ascertainment and acquisition of valuable items, thoughts, and people, as well as being able to directly convert monetary w…
-
@TheDukeOfPork nice card, but I recommend you read the prompt again
-
here's my take
-
@Jadefire I'll do that, thanks
-
Hey @Jadefire. Isperia's Verdict doesn't match challenge number 10, as it has no casting cost. This is different from a card with a casting cost of 0, which is the object of the challenge
-
hey @AboveAndAbout, I'm sorry to say but Flux isn't a card type as is, rather it's a supertype, like basic, snow, and legendary. It's certainly an interesting mechanic, and one I hope you include in some other cards going forward, but unfortunately …
-
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos what a delicious soup you've made!
-
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos already did, unless you're suggesting a further revision
-
@MemoryHead thanks for the idea. I'll do that
-
@Jadefire good point, thanks for pointing that out. There are some mechanics that do use keyword abilities. So yes, Foretell is a mechanic. Flash on the other hand is just "You may play this card any time you could cast an instant," which isn't real…
-
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos unfortunately, flash is a keyword ability. You could technically call it a mechanic, but it doesn't count for the sake of the challenge Also, @Everyone I am removing the requirement for MTGCS links ONLY for Challenge #23, as …
-
@Jadefire looks fine to me
-
Hey @Jadefire. that's a super sweet design you've got going on there! I might be willing to bend the rules slightly if you can do your best to make it in MTGCS. You might be able to fit the static abilities in with the -3 ability.
-
... really @bronx?
-
@TheRacingTurtle that's correct
-
@Temurzoa I knew that rule was a good idea... Seriously though, that's impressive! shine on you crazy diamond. @Ranshi sure did! I felt I came up with some things that were pretty good, and though to make a challenge out of them! @MemoryHead woah …
-
a better comparison for Nitris would be Murmuring Mystic: It makes creatures of the same type, but does it every time for 4 mana. Personally, I think Nitris is pretty terrible. It's either an effect of a common or the effect of an uncommon, but wit…
-
I guess we'll get all these updates Corwinnn's been talking about since june when Silksong comes out
-
@shadow123 @AboveAndAbout thanks for submitting entries! And starting off with two absolutely epic designs!