MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
atrus159
About
- Username
- atrus159
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,041
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
I personally don't think our main cycle should penalize you for not having psylian life since that would make it really hard to make a 2 color deck that isn't psylian life based (and the plan is that not all of them are) and it's also incredibly par…
-
^Rhox faith mender for instance. wouldn't it literally go infinite with its self if they were the same numbers?
-
Here are my revisions. I was a bit concerned about the new highcourt fop but it is a strictly worse Ajani's Pridemate which is also uncomon so I think it's fine.
-
@ningyounk I'm still kind of concerned if it says instants and sorceries since you can potentially just get rid of all of their removal that would kill it. My powers of analysis are failing me on this one so I'm just gonna make a version that says i…
-
@ningyounk Ok fiiiiiiinnnee. I might re-make something like it later as costing WB with a different name. Also, concerning the Tomescrapper, neither this card nor courser of kruphix (which this card is based a bit on), are actually ramp since the l…
-
@ningyounk what if we upped it to "if you've gained 5 or more life this turn"? I think at that point to use it consistently you have to actually be a life gain deck or be trying to trigger it with 5 power life link creatures (in which case you are b…
-
@ningyounk white sometimes gets repeatable card draw if it requires you to build around a white mechanic. An example would be mentor of the meek which lets you pay 1 to draw a card as long as you have small creatures entering play, or pure steel pal…
-
Idk about this but I think its funny.
-
Speaking of B/W mechanics set, here are some uncommons. Vengeful strike may have to be a rare.
-
If we wanted to make ajani fit with the WB mechanic set of life gain/ loss I think the -2 as it is makes a lot of sence. Suppose we kept that, made the + make the token with life link and menace, and then made the ult something flashy that synergies…
-
@koover why thank you
-
@ningyounk, do you think it could cost three and just do the card draw? since 3 mana draw 2 lose 2 is a fair card but not especially playable and you trade needing an activator for being able to potentially activate it multiple times.
-
Not sure, thoughts?
-
yeah, these cards might not even get used so no use remaking them now
-
Well I went and made some mono colored tapped lands, we can use them or we can't. I also came up with some color-specific locations to use later if we want. Also I remade vixen and hustler with new hustler art and vixen giving menace. The ol…
-
@ningyounk I guess the red one could be menace? Regarding the tapped lands that gain one phylsian life, I was thinking of it as a land that enters tapped half the time (which is I think a similar rate to the SOI lands, tho those where bad) since ev…
-
^Maybe duels that gain you 1
-
Thinking about tapped lands that gain you two Phylian life when they enter the battlefield. They probably can't be duels right?
-
I made some stuff of u/r. It could maybe be expanded to a cycle. Tell me if I got the numbers right on these. Also if we have actual locations in the lore I can remake to use those instead.
-
kk
-
@ningyounk ok fair. Also, what does virtuoso mean? It's in the color description for red/blue as well as a few other places but its not in the mechanics list.
-
^Although i'm gonna back peddle a bit, maybe it should be a sorcery
-
@ningyounk I think I have to disagree. If you are playing a midrange deck, against a slower midrange/control deck, or an agro deck running some removal, this is not guarantied to do anything since your opponent will be more concerned with removing y…
-
@MagicChess Do we have any big names in red I should name-drop?
-
-
@ningyounk good point, ill change it in a bit. In the mean time I thought i'd make some generic utility cards but idk what the current thoughts are on what tools should or should not be in the set. Here's an idea.
-
-
Is it intentional that if you compose on your opponents turn the token lasts until *your* endstep?
-
@CaptainCosmotic Depends what meaning you want to get across but "Through a whisper" doesn't really mean anything. You could use "With a whisper" for both, which would probably make sense.
-
@stormtide here, sorry I took so long. I would have liked the cards to go to the graveyard but I think having a modern legal card that mills your entire library could actually be problems, even though you would have to run it as a one-of.