MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
bnew07
About
- Username
- bnew07
- Joined
- Visits
- 10,453
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Peace has graced Carmaton for many years, mostly due to Velior. As one of the realm’s knights he protected it from harm for many years until a plague decimated the royal family. As the last remaining noble, he ascended to the throne
-
@Ningyounk You got W/U!
-
Batman is a double-faced card.
-
@ningyounk The only thing I would say is that tribal aside, if for example your theme is instants and sorceries, just being an instant or sorcery is not enough to be an enabler. The spell's effect must in some way enable your themd
-
@ningyounk You are absolutely right on each of the scenarios
-
@Bowler218 An archetype is a mechanical theme that is shared by a color combo . Examples. U/R Spells, W/G Tokens, B/R Madness.
-
@ningyounk @TheCenterOfTheUniverse @Faiths_Guide @Temurzoa I am amending the rules to make one restriction: your Archetype theme CANNOT be tribal. I intended on including this in the first place but didn’t realize until now that I had forgotten t…
-
@ningyounk In your example it would just be an enabler.
-
@TheCenterOfTheUniverse Yes you may do that. A single card can count for both categories.
-
@TheCenterOfTheUniverse You got Blue/Green.
-
@Temurzoa Blue/Red is yours!
-
@Faiths_Guide Black-Red is yours!
-
@ningyounk I saved the best (aka most complicated) for last The Archetype theme doesn’t have to be supported in the current standard, just a generic standard set. For example, U/R artifacts isn’t viable in standard now but it would be fine for th…
-
@Temurzoa @Faiths_Guide @ningyounk @TheCenterOfTheUniverse This stage is now open for business! Post your choices for your two-color combos below ASAP. Also, please request any favorites you may have earned from the last challenge.
-
@Faiths_Guide I am glad you found the feedback helpful. @TheCenterOfTheUniverse While it may not be too flashy, Reap is the exact kind of mechanic that has enough interesting design space for a standard legal set at the appropriate power level. …
-
This is busted no matter which version it is because it gives you access to two mana on turn one. Very closely resembles Mox diamond and needs to be substantially reduced in power level.
-
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/castle-eldor-seat-of-valor-1
-
All right everyone the results are in! Refer to the google doc link below for all the written feedback and scores. Let me know if anyone has trouble with the link. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1G16aNlu4mCCmoKsKMHtO5FGFlIDDckNW_vd1oczS0Fs The…
-
Alright everyone this contest is now closed. I will be posting results in a few days.
-
@Faiths_Guide and @ChuckTesta 4 hours left! Make sure you get your submissions in.
-
all right everyone this contest is now closed! No more entries/edits will be accepted except for @Faiths_Guide and @ChuckTesta who have used 1 day of delay time each. Your deadline is 11:59 PM EST today 12/5.
-
@Faiths_Guide @TheCenterOfTheUniverse The deadline is in about 6 hours. If you need to use delay time, just post it here before then.
-
-
@Faiths_Guide Absolutely. You haven’t used any of your delay time yet, so you may use up to 3 days for this challenge. You have to let me know you are using delay time before the deadline in about 14 hours and how much you are using.
-
@murkletins Thanks a lot! Please fave: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/siege-defenses?list=user https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/cavalry-vanguard?list=user https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/conclave-conscription?list=user
-
@ningyounk Thanks a lot for the feedback! I definitely do tend to make Mel designs. I didn’t start out designing this as a vertical cycle so when I realized it could be one I put a lot of focus onto finding useful effects rather than novel ones. I…
-
@Temurzoa @ningyounk @fiskerton All your request faves have been delivered.