MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
bnew07
About
- Username
- bnew07
- Joined
- Visits
- 10,453
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@ningyounk My responses: 1) this challenge was all about designing for a very specific set of constraints to test how well you embody “restrictions breed creativity”. Future challenges will have much more variation in rarities/other qualities tha…
-
@Faiths_Guide I think there were 2 reasons why it appeared I rewarded more “safe” cards rather than more creative or novel cards: 1) the challenge was to design for a specific rarity in a standard legal set, which really restricts design space, pow…
-
@TheCenterOfTheUniverse 1) I was quite unsure about how to evaluate that and looking back at the cycle you referenced I feel like those cards are minor bends (personal opinion, not WOTC verified), but probably okay for the reason you specified. I t…
-
@Aggroman15 all the scores and feedback are available in the google doc I linked above
-
@fiskerton You are correct that black does get land destruction, my mistake.
-
All Cardsmiths have now received one fave each
-
All right everyone the results are in! Refer to the google doc link below for all the written feedback and to the google sheet link for raw scores and some data. Let me know if anyone has trouble with the links. https://docs.google.com/spreadshee…
-
@Aggroman15 @Ranshi922 I am sorry but the deadline has already passed all entries are final at this point
-
All right everyone thank you for your submissions! Thanks for all your effort! This contest is now closed for judging! No more edits or submissions will be accepted from this point forward. I will post the results in the next 3 days.
-
@TezzeretofCarmot21 Understood, sorry you are having computer issues. if you change your mind in the next 20 min, just let me know and I will extend the deadline to 7pm
-
@TezzeretofCarmot21 The deadline is in 30 minutes...do you think you can have your submissions (according to the contest criteria) posted in 3 hours?
-
@TezzeretofCarmot21 You need to have at least one instant, one sorcery, one enchantment among your submissions. The last card can be any one of those four card types
-
@TezzeretofCarmot21 it’s okay if you submit them one at a time now since we are close to the deadline, I think you are the last Cardsmith left
-
@TezzeretofCarmot21 I noticed you starting to make some cards for this challenge but the ones you made so far Are ally color and they need to be enemy color. G/B B/W W/R R/U U/G
-
Again, just a friendly reminder, if you are making any last minute edits to your cards, please let me know by posting in the thread below.
-
Hunger: Renamed version of Drain to match the slang name that WOTC uses for this effect. Bloodlust: Change To “one or more creatures dealt damage” to reduce the amount of triggers per combat. Linger:
-
Just a reminder that there are about 12 more hours until the deadline. @TezzeretofCarmot21 @KJMartin @Shadow29870 @Jadeor @bigbadbooknerd @BorosPaladin You have not yet submitted your cards, so if you are still planning to enter make sure you ge…
-
@Ranshi922 sorry no previews, scores will only be given out when the entry period is over and judging commences
-
Now that judging is approaching, here is how I will be approaching a tie for 8th Place if it occurs: If 2 or more Cardsmiths are tied for 8th Place, then Cardsmith who has the highest total score of their best 3 cards will advance. If there is sti…
-
-
@Tomigon @Corwinn Any idea?
-
Hey everyone just a reminder that there are a little over two days left to get your submissions in. So far, 6 of 16 Cardsmiths have posted their submissions and I am excited to see the rest of them.
-
@Faiths_Guide I have already started judging the submissions posted so far so I want to make sure that if anyone makes changes to their cards that I see them and reevaluate my judging based on the changes. I think the best way for me to avoid miss…
-
A quick reminder: If you edit your submission after the original posting, just let me know
-
-
-
@Ranshi922 You just can’t use any non-evergreen named keywords, so if you chose to use that effect without the name that would be allowed
-
@Ranshi922 only current evergreens
-
@Ranshi922 Those abilities are not evergreen and thus cannot he used for this contest as named abilities
-
@Aggroman15 No need to fix the borders, it will not affect judging. It is up to you if you want to write a short summary for your submissions, it is allowed but not mandatory