MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
bnew07
About
- Username
- bnew07
- Joined
- Visits
- 10,453
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
RED: Angrath's Brawler — I want to have one vanilla chivalry creature at common in each color to minimize complexity so I like keeping it free of other text. How do you feel about a 2RR 3/2 chivalry 2? Stormkin Summoner — I changed this to rummage …
-
@ningyounk Wow!! That token is incredible! I can’t beliebe how good it looks thanks so much! You really have a talent for this kind of stuff! I appreciate the thoroughness and effort you put into your feedback. You made a ton of excellent points. …
-
DISCLAIMER: All ideas, cards, and concepts predate Throne of Eldraine and the recent spoilers. At long last, the first draft of the common design skeleton is complete! You can find it in the link below: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/17S990…
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/heliods-treacherous-strike?list=set&set=32749
-
Here are some other minor innovations I plan for Carmaton: -Noble and Serf creature types (Serf has only been used on tokens so far and nobles are brand new). -Gold tokens (same as treasure tokens but with a more medieval flavor)
-
Brief update: I have made almost all the commons—I expect to post the common design skeleton in the next few days before Eldraine previews. I have refined the draft archetypes as follows: WU: Quest Midrange UB: Hi CMC Control BR: Power greater tha…
-
@Faiths_Guide 1. I don’t think any plane currently has flying cats. One idea is that it could go on Naya as an evolution of the cat people post conflux. The visual aesthetic (minus the wings) fits existing Nayan art decently enough. 2. Perhaps an ac…
-
@HeroKP That card effectively says "Pay 4 life: Add one mana of any color." This is 100% busted. Personally, I don’t believe you should have a card that can pay life for mana like this in a standard legal set unless it requires a heavy deck constr…
-
I slightly modified the wording of the mechanic by swapping "Creature or Vehicle" with "Permanent" as this is more concise and has the same functionality. All my entries are themed around Naya.
-
I believe Ethan Fleischer did a prehistoric plane for his GDS2 submission. Might be worth checking out for inspiration.
-
5) Individual Cards One thing I notice is that the removal seems to be on the expensive side, with very little cheap removal. Is this intentional? It is not necessarily a bad thing, but does make control worse in the format. • Let it go: This is a…
-
@ningyounk Here are my thoughts. NOTE: I am reading this for the first time, so forgive me if I say something that you address farther down in the post. 1) The World of Rezatta It seems to me that despite the Renaissance theme being very well defin…
-
@murkletins Do you include Arthurian Legend as a fairy tale (King Arthur/round table/etc.)?
-
@ningyounk Thanks a million for your feedback on my Quest mechanic! Based on your feedback, I had a Eureka moment and reconcepted the entire mechanic to solve a ton of issues. Here is the change: Old Version (Keyword Ability, only goes on creatur…
-
@ningyounk You make a great point about the secondary trope theme. Right now I don’t have an idea for one but I think there is an opportunity for it to be included. FYI: Imisspoke in my first post — the set is Arthurian Legend meets Class Struggle.…
-
@Temurzoa Thanks for the feedback and compliments! I agree 100% that all the mechanics are creature-centric. The one caveat to this is nobility, which will almost exclusively go on noncreature spells (otherwise it is not as interesting). I also am…
-
Absolutely
-
@ningyounk @Faiths_Guide @temurzoa @TheCenterOfTheUniverse Would love to get your feedback on my custom set!
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ula-the-creator?list=set&set=32743
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Greed https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ambitious-inheritance
-
@ThePhantomJoker Are 7 mana cards allowed?
-
Top Down Excalibur