MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
feralitator
About
- Username
- feralitator
- Joined
- Visits
- 6,535
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Welcome back!
-
Back off Innistrad
-
* A planeswalker with less than three +/- abilities. * A Godzilla Card. * A burn spell. * A 1-drop creature.
-
If I were to make a double face card, would you count each side individually, or would they be judged together?
-
I think white/black/gold is fine, but I'd use the legendary version of the frame. The legendary frames are at the bottom of the list.
-
Wow, I won the first match? That's actually surprising. I look forward to our rematch @Corwinnn
-
Thanks! Currently, I'm undecided on my major. I didn't want to commit to anything my first year, and I'd rather explore a bunch of options rather than go down one path and discover that I may not like it. Although, I know that I don't want to go int…
-
As much as I don't want to do this, I need to pause working on this. I have been falling behind in one of my classes (adjusting to college life is hard), and I should be spending my free time catching up in that rather than doing things for fun. I a…
-
So I have some ideas related to archetypes: I think that five of the archetypes could have a third supporting color, similar to Rezatta. For example, since Emerge is BRG, I think it makes sense if BG specifically cares about emerge the most, and re…
-
It isn't Halloween without costumes and parties! https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/masquerade-2
-
I have realized that there is definitely some changes that need to be made, but this is what I have so far: White: (Spoiler) Blue: (Spoiler) Black: (Spoiler) Red: (Spoiler) Green: (Spoiler)
-
So I have been working on creating the first draft of commons, and although I have only completed the Red and Black commons, I am noticing that I haven't defined much design space in white, blue, and green. I think that red and black still need some…
-
I was looking at the Rezatta cards in cockatrice again, and despite being in the card image folder, the card images for these cards didn't show up: Ollo Spring Champion Vallo and Aura the Waltzers Eko's Crystal Violin Gobold Avatar of Vigor Iffy Doc…
-
I don't know if you've already had your interview before you read this, but good luck!
-
@jpastor I'm not sure if the phoenix should be counted as a 2-for-1, but athersnatch both "counters" and opponent's spell, and you get to cast another spell for free, all in one card.
-
There isn't much that screams halloween more than graveyards and zombies in my opinion. I present The Living Grave! https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/the-living-grave
-
The xml file worked for me.
-
@ningyounk Would it make more sense to start with making the signpost uncommons so I have a clearer picture of archetypes, and how much of each color should be devoted to that archetype?
-
When it comes to humans and other land-based creatures, the idea I had is that they are all living on one rather small island. This results in people needing to fight to survive, both against outside forces like sea monsters and the rising sea level…
-
Voted for a few, and for a card that wasn't listed
-
I'm currently having a hard time with coming up with an alternate idea to torrent, and I'm having a hard time with it. I know that I need a battlefield/combat-related mechanic, but I can't really think of anything that isn't similar to an existing m…
-
Here's the official cardsmith server: https://discord.gg/ANbD3Esu
-
After reading your suggestions and those of some people on discord, I feel like Torrent might not be a great choice for a mechanic. As much as I love the idea, I'm feeling a bit unsure about tapped matters because if any of its colors overlap with e…
-
Here's some other cards I came up with:
-
For the last mechanic, I have an idea, but I don't know if this is a good one. I know that I want this to work well with small merfolk creatures, so I thought that tapping synergies might make sense, since lorwyn merfolk did have some form of tap-re…
-
I did a little playtesting with Emerge cards, and here's what I got: * Emerge on noncreature spells is really fun, but it isn't as great when it requires you to control another creature. In addition, sacrificing a permanent creature for a one-time…
-
For Silver Monarch, shouldn't it say "Art creatures you control have ward {1}"? Typically effects that give bonuses to a specific creature type say "[Type] creatures you control". Also, I feel like its second ability is way too bonkers. It's a mix o…
-
@cadstar369 Delay is practically suspend, but I feel like it would have tracking issues, since shuffling a deck with a handful of face up cards might give easy opportunities to cheat. If you want it to be a library version of suspend, I would word…
-
IN - B Division
-
Question: Recently, I've been making cards in waves to test mechanics for my set, and some are more refined than others (Some may not make sense mechanically and/or flavorfully). If I were to enter, would A recent card instead of THE most recent car…