MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
feralitator
About
- Username
- feralitator
- Joined
- Visits
- 6,535
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
I just realized that Field of Ruin shouldn't be a problem because it has each player search their own library, instead of you searching each player's library. So I think that the choice should depend on who is interacting with the library.
-
In my last comment, I mentioned that I think it would be better to remove scrycast, and instead have a few cards that say "As long as [cardname] is the top card of your harbor, you may cast/play it". Maybe it would be fine if it's not the top card o…
-
I do want to give the option between your library and your harbor. The reason I brought up "main library" is that without it you could technically put the top card of your harbor on the top of your harbor, which is kinda weird in my opinion. "Each …
-
Should the second part of Seraphic Shield should say "Creatures you control with +1/+1 counters on them gain indestructible until end of turn"? Also, comparing it with Basri's Solidarity, maybe it should cost 3? The only other thing is that I think…
-
For a serran life archetype, could something like this work?
-
I basically predicted foretell. It's not exact, but it's extremely similar https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/kalimaru-astral-trickster-1
-
Does RG still need some ideas, or should I come up with some ideas for WG?
-
Apparently, there's some mechanic that someone else has made that's similar to Harbor called Archive: Archive X (As this enters the battlefield, shuffle the top X cards of your main library into a new face up library. Sacrifice this after the arch…
-
I think harbor should count as a library. If it didn't, cards leaving your harbor wouldn't count towards sink. I agree that "You can't draw from an empty harbor" doesn't need to be in the reminder text, but I think that it does need to be a rule, …
-
That's actually real magic art I mean, you can still use it, but I'm just letting you know
-
Looking at the two together made me realize that Silence in the Library says "cost" not "costs".
-
I don't mind changing the name later, but I think harbor is a fine name to call it for now. I really like that idea of a secondary face-up library. I came up with some designs for harbor. I probably made some mistakes with wording and such, but I t…
-
I guess harbor is still a possibility. I think I originally dismissed it because I believed it only really worked flavorfully with pirates. Admittedly, I'm having a hard time with coming up with card ideas for it.
-
Ooh, that looks cool, but I think the problem with it is that it messes up with shuffling your deck, as you will know where they are in your deck while shuffling. I also noticed that Lurk as a top-of-the-library mechanic kinda works against sink.
-
I think I might change Bounty because I feel like it doesn't work as a "wow factor" mechanic for a library-matters set. That being said, I don't want to fully scrap it, because I do like the general concept. I think I'll keep it as an activated abil…
-
I'm having trouble with figuring out how to make Bounty in WG. I would say that it's fine to have it in all colors, and just have a focus in UBR, but I feel like that can't happen with the "wow factor" mechanic of the set. Looking at things like Adv…
-
I believe it's a roman empire themed set. It features characters like Licia and Saskia.
-
I know that you changed the challenge, but I just wanted to point something out. The symbols of magic are actually called by their color, not by what type of land generates that mana. So, the symbol with the skull is actually called 'black mana', no…
-
I personally think that it makes sense as-is, but I could see some people thinking that you can't put it back on the top of your library. I think you could definitely change it to something like that, but looking at mechanics like surveil and explor…
-
Looking at Raiders' Wake, I do think that 4 mana is probably where it should be.
-
How about something like this? Probably would include an activated ability (maybe something like "{2}{r}, Pay 2 life: Create a 1/1 red Devil creature token with haste."?), but I think it works as both a very quick aggro card and a damage-dealing …
-
Here's a fairly simple one. Veridis Quo by Daft Punk https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/veridis-quo I feel like Veridis Quo would play at the climax of a film, so I felt like a board wipe effect would suit it just fine. In regards to the flavor text,…
-
I changed all of the existing bounty abilities to sorcery speed, and added two Bounty creatures. (If treasure tokens aren't used in this set, then I'll remove the treasure type and ability, but I still think this is a neat card that would be like…
-
I believe that as its worded right now, Bounty can be activated at instant speed, which is the same problem that you pointed out with Nyle's Hunt. I'm assuming that I should add on "Activate only as a sorcery" to get around that problem. I'll do som…
-
I think I'm going to playtest bounty soon. I think it's going to be a primarily UBR mechanic since that's probably gonna be the colors for pirates (I might add white, but I'm still unsure), so I made 3 bounty cards and one bounty support in those co…
-
I can't draw either. I usually get my art from places like Artstation. It's where at least some cardsmiths get their art from, and also has the artist credited (Which is a good thing to do when using their art). I suggest reading this tutorial for …
-
Typical Blue/Red commanders care about either instants and sorceries, artifacts, or drawing cards. Creating "better" commanders depends on what type of deck you have. Is it an instant/sorcery matters deck? An artifact matters deck? Or, is it somethi…
-
Delve has been used on one red card before, but it was used much more in UBG. Also, sorry for the awkward spacing on delve, mtgcs does a weird thing with mana symbols near the right side of the text box. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/funeral-fires…
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/inner-rage-3
-
Cipher is Dimir's signature mechanic (Blue/Black) in the RTR block. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/stampeding-frenzy