MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
fire12
About
- Username
- fire12
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,732
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@FangQuil Cody, the Helper seems very overpowered to me. Not only is he a one mana 2/2, which would be overpowered by itself, he also has an ability that can allow all permanents to gain indestructible until end of turn. Now, let me explain just how…
-
I figure I'll give this a whirl.
-
Farek got up, dazed. Where was he? Was he drunk? he tried to remember what happened last. A dragon had come... yes, a dragon had come to him with a job. He was to kill someone who could travel planes, and that Farek would know one when he saw one. F…
-
Entry 2 Please let me know if you find the artist. I tried, and failed. Entry 3: (Old Entry) Entry 4: (Old Entry)
-
@FORFUN I see where you're coming from, but I do not see how Flashbolt is powerful. At its best, you either scry 2, then deal a little damage, and lose a card, or you scry 2, reveal a card, then draw it. Have you even seen Preordain? This is basical…
-
@shadow123 Great card! While normally such an ability would be OP on a land, it has the limit of 3 times, plus it is legendary. All in all, I think you did a great job balancing it! Earns a fave from me. My card:
-
I'll see if I can participate
-
@AboveAndAbout Frozen Tithe is a pretty good card! If you post the link, I will give it a favorite. Paladin of the restless... hmmm... I'm not sure how to feel about this card. It's an okay common, but the design isn't that original. Next up:
-
First Entry:
-
@jrthompson7899 Urif is a bit all over the place. I would suggest getting rid of the ability to keep the copies, and getting rid of the X, replacing it with 4. Also getting rid of the red mana, replacing it with green. Red has basically nothing to d…
-
@NotTheCardSmith_1 The card's mana is a little off. You should have the colorless mana before the green mana. Following that, at the start of your turn doesn't really mean anything. You would have to specify, like "At the beginning of your upkeep...…
-
I nominate Sunbeam by @Ydoplus_of_Forduuath!
-
@Tommia Sorry, but I think I have to drop out.
-
@FireKing661 There are 2 options. 1: You can get a premium account. But, if you don't want to spend money, there is option 2: Make a new version of the card that has the changes.
-
Task 2, by @IronCrusher Task 3, by @Ydoplus_of_Forduuath Task 4, by @Brainifyer
-
@Spatialdebris You only have to wait 1 turn for 1 less mana, but you already spent 1 mana, so to make it worth it, you would have to wait at least 2 turns, which is a bad deal. Even if you have flash creatures, you still are waiting to use that 1 ma…
-
@spookoops I'm not sure there is much they can do about spam comments. Even if they block the user from the site, that user will just make another email and go onto disqus that way. The best thing to do is to report and block them. For BS cards, a l…
-
@Spatialdebris Yes, I understand that, but 2 turn wait for 1 mana less isn't that good. Also, the ability isn't red. Prowess is in red, but it is in blue and white to. I would suggest at least lowering the mana cost a little.
-
@Spatialdebris It should be "You may cast it from exile as though it had flash." Also, I don't see red being in the card. Probably should just be azorius, but I wouldn't know. Other than that, it seems pretty weak. For the ability to pay off, you wo…
-
Here's mine, using the 9th artwork:
-
@Tommia First, the enemy. Next: Permanent card that can beat the enemy. Finally: The non permanent that can beat the enemy. First of all, yes, I know that Wretched Removal should have blue, but Eclipsa shouldn't. …
-
@RandomFandom Kettengeist is a little overpowered. It could be a extremely powerful sideboard against a token deck, because if they just have an army of small tokens or a few huge tokens, you pay 6 mana for a 4/5 with protection against tokens, and …
-
Shouldn't it be "get favorites each week."?? Anyways, here's a card:
-
@Tommia Eclipsa of Day will be doing Option 1, but Eclipsa of Night will be doing Option 2, or option 3, if 2 is not possible.
-
@ChoyBoi There's not much to say about them, except for a few minor details. First: Inferno Gearhulk. It isn't really a black card. Menace, Trample, and its main ability are all very red mechanics. Other than that, it is pretty good! It's a simple d…
-
@TenebrisNemo I'm honored that you loved my card! Also, thanks, @Tomigon, for dropping by and giving the comment! I new something was wrong when i made it. Anyways, here is my favorite instant on Mtg Cardsmith: It's by one of my favorite Cardsmiths…
-
Melee attack
-
@Temurzoa Extremely overpowered. You can cast it without paying its mana cost, which the card by itself with that ability is powerful, but then, you infinitely are exiling the opponents creatures and planeswalkers! A instant speed exile target creat…