MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
jaceberlin
Just your average Planeswalker. Was pretty tired after the battle with bolas so I planeswalked here and started a MTG cardsmith account (this plane's technology is amazing). Might leave to another plane sometime soon, I absolutely love this place so far though, it's only problem is the huge shortage of Mana, I'll probably stay for a while though.
About
- Username
- jaceberlin
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,523
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@ChoyBoi @LordTachanka123 @Fallen_Lord_Vulganos you participated befor
-
I honestly didn't expect to win 1st (or second) place. Here's the art. Credit: Eryk Szczygieł
-
@MTG_Sappy If @Fallen_Lord_Vulganos doesn't come soon, will we need a replacement?
-
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos
-
I'm killing this off due to lack of entries. As I do normally, everyone who joined gets the first place prize. Anyone who said they would join gets the 2nd place prize. @Arceus8523 @ChoyBoi @RandomFandom
-
@HenryMG Are you ever going to judge?
-
@KEdRuss I think Potato13 said everything that could be said, but I'll add a little more: The second card needs flavor text The first card is actually a pretty solid concept. Both cards would be very strong in commander, as you can return them to…
-
-
@KEdRuss you got your card commented on @zizick123 it would be better if you mentioned the person you are responding to
-
@IronCrusher Oh, sorry, i just thought it had been a while.
-
@IronCrusher isn't it judging time?
-
@HenryMG When does the contest end?
-
https://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/5462/id-rather-not-the-challenge#latest
-
Can I post an unset card just for the joke?
-
@KEdRuss Card 1: Very strong for a 3 CMC, you need to add flavor, and there are a few MTG typos Card 2: Reflect is a very strong ability, the last ability has a MTG typo, again, room for flavor.
-
@Potato13 you need to post a card. You can't just give advice.
-
Art
-
Don't let this die. Nobody talked in 2 days!
-
@ChoyBoi When are you judging again?
-
@ChoyBoi Great card! I love the idea and execution, but one thing bothers me: as Potato13 said, a 4/1with flying and haste for 3 mana is strong, but allowing it to come back twice for three mana is way to powerful, not to mention proliferate. I thin…
-
@FourEyesIsAFish The flavor I wanted to push is that it kills or destroys something. And it does it every day. Once you look at the clues and find things about it though. You can easily defeat it
-
The flavor is that as soon as you look at the clues (what it killed), it stops being mysterious and is easy to defeat, this killing it.
-
@FourEyesIsAFish In the MTG world selkies are very real. I do see how it could ruin the flavor though. Eh, the card is good without the last "er" as well.
-
@FourEyesIsAFish The card idea is awesome! But it still has a few problems. The rarity icon covers "shapeshifter". I know you didn't have room, so I'd remove the " enchantment" from the creature. The flavor text should probably be lowered to the bot…
-
@Jedidiah There are a few mistakes in the card, I'll list them here: There needs to be empty line after "flying" The second ability is missing the word "that" The explanation text for the second ability is falsely written On to the actual card thou…