MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
murkletins
About
- Username
- murkletins
- Joined
- Visits
- 2,050
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@Credius Looks like a great choice, myself will only make one change to the reminder text. To clarify it happens as it enters the battlefield, if it's one of the ones used. Or change it to a trigger.
-
@Reizon Just use the inbox at the top of your forum page to contact Corwinnn or mtgcardsmith. That's all you have to do to make a claim against the automated system.
-
@Reizon The issue is not that you're complaining. It's that your posting a wasteful thread when you should be speaking to a moderator via PM instead. They may be busy around this time of year, but you can wait a while for a reply. The forums are fo…
-
@Reizon Why are you commenting on flawed cards, that show no promise for improvement at the moment? Give the support and feedback to cards that are looking for it instead of complaining about some people who can't take feedback. This thread posted …
-
@Kingtalk Sorry, but all of your cards in your fist post have no credited artist. Hence myself can't accept them into this group of challenges. This is required since myself will need to reprint these in MSE for various reasons. In addition, myself…
-
Update is being made to the main post to state you can post up to three commander pairings each day, from now on.
-
@Corwinnn May you please close this thread, when you have free time?
-
@KorandAngels Sorry, this is for custom commanders only. If you'd like to deck build for existing WotC cards, that would be best done in one of the past threads for this subject. The main reason this challenge concept is viable, is it's harder to c…
-
If you feel this isn't an interesting challenge idea or dislike it, please leave feedback! All feedback is helpful in the process of experimenting.
-
Due to feedback, myself will close this challenge if it doesn't garner interest by tomorrow. The main reason for this possibly happening is that the commander might be not favored by the community. The later is myself don't want to offer premium if …
-
Deleted comment.
-
@KorandAngels It was in one of the iterations, but it seemed too complex for one card, given feedback. Myself agree to those statements and was experimenting with what myself could get away with on a mythic rare. Keep in mind, myself am still new t…
-
Now myself will head off to sleep. Then check in on the feedback in the morning. If you dislike this challenge or have any critical opinions, please comment! All feedback is helpful in my pursuits to making a fun commander deck w/ a custom CMDR.
-
So am assuming people are interested in the draft effects contest so far. As such myself think we'll do a challenge for that theme, unless we get more feedback soon.
-
@KorandAngels When we have at least four completed teams.
-
By the way, there's no need to ask in advance if the card is acceptable. If it doesn't match the theme, myself will just mention that to you.
-
Due to a lack of entries, myself am closing this challenge. @Corwinnn May you close this thread?
-
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos Yes, that's a perfectly fine entry.
-
@Corwinnn May you close this in the mean time, until someone starts it up again in the future?
-
@KorandAngels Will update the thread to allow old cards. Forgot to mention the subject. Edit: However, for fairness to those making fresh cards, old cards will not be able to win the grand prize.
-
@benw No worries, that is fine art.
-
By the way, if one of the cardsmiths from a team quits, the other partner will be allowed to continue competing in solo with no penalty. This is another safety valve for those partnered with someone leaving the competition. However, you may also in …
-
Ink Artwork 1 & Bump:
-
@TheWanderer Yes you're fine, lands don't have to be in the color identity since they are colorless. Formats using that rule now allow any land to be played in any deck. But remember, if your legendary isn't those colors of the mana ability, you ca…
-
@Mantis17 Just a warning you can only play spells of colors in your legendary's color identity. But if your legendary has an ability with that color of mana in it, you can also play it given this rule. So no literal splashing.
-
Other contests, challenges and sagas you might be interested in of ours! 1) Welcome to the Constance! Saga (W/ murkletins as host) 2) What is your fantasy? - Ongoing challenge Am making an effort to link other threads so myself can just bump one th…
-
Bump.
-
In Case of Scheduling Issues, Announcement: Hello fellow cardsmiths, myself am announcing a safety valve in case a cardsmith is unable to attend a challenge for one of the weeks every now and then, and myself want your opinion on if you feel this is…
-
Barrier to entry for @KorandAngels has been lifted from my contests/challenges due to a misunderstanding and poor communication on both sides.
-
No worries.