MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
ningyounk
About
- Username
- ningyounk
- Joined
- Visits
- 9,187
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@LordTachanka123 No I'm genuinely confused XD Because Aven Gagglemaster does have an ability (in this case, a triggered ability), and it's also doing something a bit unusual which is caring about flyiers (it's not completely new, but not every s…
-
So you still want a mechanic? Let me clarify, among the following cards, could you please point out which one would be valid entries if they weren't real cards and if what they are doing was something completely new in their colour:
-
@TheEnderDragon Ooh, thanks! \o/ I'm a bit confused with the rules of challenge 3, are you looking for any kind of effect or do you specifically want a keyworded mechanic? If so, do you specifically want a keyword ability (like Mutate or evergree…
-
@LordTachanka123 Quite a few of those designs are the kind of things we'll probably add last as they're a bit too simple and we want to give priority to new concepts that synergise with the themes of the set. Typically, you'd rather have Karametra…
-
@LordTachanka123 XD I'm sorry but this is *still* not strong enough >.< Here's an example of a common that's strictly better than this, and another example of the power level you'd expect from this slot at uncommon:
-
@Faiths_Guide Repeatable token creation is really powerful, but at uncommon creating one 1/1 per turn conditionally usually costs around two mana (see Griffin Aerie or Hidden stockpile for instance) so I didn't want to push the mana cost too high…
-
Bonjour Unfortunately, the card maker of MTGCardsmith doesn't allow for french accents In addition, it only allows the card types to be selected from a list of English game terms. So, it's going to be complicated to do this directly online. Howe…
-
@Scaccogaming Don't worry you don't have to make the cards perfect at this stage, this is still just brainstorming ideas x) @dragonbornletter It's ok, you really need the word "target" in the ability for it to target so "put a +1/+1 counter on…
-
@Scaccogaming To be fair, WOTC themselves sometimes print cards that could be monocoloured in multicoloured slots which can become confusing XD But it's mainly in heavily multicoloured sets like Ravnica, or when they really want a specific effect…
-
@Scaccogaming About the "kind of monsters on Rezatta": This is called a creature grid! Each world usually have a few creature types for each colour for small, medium and large slots, each in a flying or non-flying variant (barring stuff like small…
-
@Scaccogaming Well now without the concept of making the creature as big as your life total it looks a little random to me. Sure, it's a possible card, but where would it fit in the set, I'm less sure. I do like the "as long as you have serran lif…
-
@Scaccogaming Yes, sorry that wasn't clear, I was talking about the massive +X/+X enchantment. As I was saying, it's a very risky mechanic, if we want to make it uncommon-friendly, we need to put some safety valves on it, so putting that effect on…
-
@shadow123 Nope, so it's definitely more confusing with Serran life in the mix but here's what would happen (basically life exchanges are just regular life gain and life loss effects): CASE 1: You have 15 life, including 10 regular life and 5 ser…
-
@Scaccogaming I'm not sure I understood the question about printing, do you mean posting them with the illustration and everything? If so, feel free to propose more fleshed-out cards if you want! It's ok if they don't have the rezatta set icon ^^ …
-
MTG_Sappy Absolutely ^^ The sum of all life gained and lost this turn (if nothing else happened) would be 6, the same as if you targeted your opponent.
-
Fade into Obscurity: I like the new stats, Looking at other similar cards I think it's much more in line with what uncommon white removal looks like. It seems on par with Reprisal, which is the most efficient of the bunch, with the downsides of givi…
-
Hey! I won something! \o/ Thanks for the challenge, it was fun and very well-organised May I request you to favourite those seven cards? 1) http://https//mtgcardsmith.com/view/suicide-doll 2) http://https//mtgcardsmith.com/view/all-who-is-meek…
-
@MTG_Sappy Sure, obviously what I said was in regards to putting it in the set itself but it's perfectly ok with the precons ^^ @Scaccogaming I really like this version, it's not too parasitic but still pushes you towards playing more Art, and i…
-
@LyndonF I've been trying to flesh out the green concepts you presented above, what do you think of those changes a priori: Galloping Frosthorn: Looking back, I was afraid it would be slightly underpowered so I added Daunt. This way you're als…
-
@MTG_Sappy You mean Stin? Well it's a bit too early to tell which higher rarity cards will get a slot in the file, but for it to be considered an option it will need to be two colours at most (the set doesn't have the proper mana fixing for tricol…
-
@Scaccogaming Acrylic Arcanophage: I really like that last ability, it's a really good idea to get abilities from Art creatures in the graveyard, it goes well with what the UBG archetype is trying to do ^^ I have a few issues with some of the …
-
@Scaccogaming Spring of Seasons: We don't have a four seasons theme in the set, it's just winter and spring really ^^ Still, the card looks interesting, but we'd need to find an innovative template to make this work and I'm not sure it's worth the…
-
Hey! If the idea of the rhythm thing actually picks up, here are a few additional comments on this concept: * You should definitely look into the contraption mechanic in Unstable. It has kind of the same rhythm vibe to it, so just dissecting how …
-
Hello! Here's some quick feedback from what I've see in the intro, essentially about the mechanics: * The version of Harmonise with the +1/+1 counters is slightly dicey because it will lead to a lot more land destruction in your set than normal, …
-
@Ral1000 Sure, I'll pass by and have a look ^^ @Scaccogaming Yeah ideally I'd like to see small incremental value rather than a big threat, but I think one +1/+1 counter per turn feels pretty different from Ajani's Pridemate which easily reach …
-
@Scaccogaming Don't worry, we'll probably try different cards for the same slot ^^ Yeah I like it better with vigilance, the problem with the lifelink version is that it was difficult to block so if you hit the opponent for 2 with lifelink, that t…
-
Since we're on the subject of Art pay-offs, I figured we probably want a Blood Artist that would be compatible with the Art recursion game plan. Alternatively, it might be an interesting WB signpost: The WB might hint too much at a token-centri…
-
@GameQnQ Serran Intervention: This could totally work ^^ I'm going to have to calculate the as-fan of life gain I want for the set to avoid drowning it in life gain though x) Caustic Critic: Hey I actually had a similar card at common at the beg…
-
LyndonF Opt to Discover: The idea is there, the only issue is that there is already a common spell doing the same thing but strictly worse so I'd like to find a new angle: Shimmering Art Chimera: I really like it, Blue could definitely use a car…
-
@Scaccogaming Well I'm not entirely sure, but I think that it's safe to say: • Keep the regular Renewal threshold of 3 life to get less confusing. • Remove lifelink because it's a bit too synergistic with itself. • Make it more White. Then, I don…