MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
ningyounk
About
- Username
- ningyounk
- Joined
- Visits
- 9,187
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
It's not a new card, but I feel it fits the theme of this contest so well I wanted to dig it out regardless xD If it's not an acceptable entry it's okay, I'll probably try to make at least one more anyways
-
@bnew07 Favourited! Some day, when I'm recovered from this marathon, we ought to host a proper multi-judges challenge series together! @Faiths_Guide could be the third judge? XD
-
@DomriKade @TheCenterOfTheUniverse Favourited! @KorandAngels Yeap, we have reached the final challenge of the GDS3!
-
@Undead Favourited! ^^
-
@Faiths_Guide Ooh I didn't think of that. Well that's pretty spicy. If you get -1 point per *DING* you receive in the competition... you and bnew07 are actually ex aequo for first place! As far as I'm concerned, you two where on each other's t…
-
Also, to celebrate the end of this long series of challenges, I tried to create some kind of global ranking over all challenges ^^ Not everyone participated in all challenges and the number of people who got ranked in each challenge varied so don't …
-
And now, the final results! It was quite complicated to judge this round because there are a lot of commons which are a difficult medium to show off in a contest. Also, I'm not as familiar with all the sets, so this might be the most subjective of m…
-
Alright! Thank you everyone for waiting, I know this judging period was longer than usual but I wasn't familiar with all the sets that were chosen so I had to read a bit about them ^^ As usual, I wrote a card-by-card review of each entry, I tried to…
-
@tuckerbarnes If we have a good idea for a White villain, we could try it ^^ It's usually about pushing White's traits to the extreme (so basically going for fascism etc.)
-
@Lujikul Yes, I guess you're right ^^ It just sounded a lot like Davriel, it would have been cool to have him as an official planeswalker.
-
@Lujikul Ooh I like it, it does fit with the themes of innovation and geniuses while also playing well within the same "mind" level as the emotion theme. Frankly, we could go for straight-up Davriel if we can find some fitting artworks. With his ma…
-
@tuckerbarnes Artifact destruction being an type of answer, it will mostly be tailoured around the artifact threats we have in the set ^^ So far, there is no reason to have more artifact destruction than usual since we don't have an artifact theme …
-
@tuckerbarnes That's pretty good, I think you're touching on a fitting feel about where the story can go ^^ Because we have only one set of non-chronological cards to convey the story, we cannot show that they're is a lack of ideas that push the wo…
-
It is now Sunday everywhere in the world which means... THE CONTEST IS CLOSED FOR JUDGING Thank you all for participating! Because this round is harder to judge than usual (there are more entries per contestant and I have to check design article…
-
REMINDER: 1 DAY BEFORE DEADLINE (FOR REAL THIS TIME) P.S: Yes, I messed that up before, the announced deadline is on Sunday, not Saturday as usual, my bad.
-
REMINDER: 1 DAY BEFORE DEADLINE
-
@sanjaya666 Yeap, the card interacting with non-Eldrazi creatures checks the box ^^ @bnew07 It does have to care about a unique type like Hound, Naga, Efreet or Cat Demon even if the set doesn't have a tribal theme around it. The point is to make…
-
@sanjaya666 & @bnew07 If figured I also should warn you two since you both made the same mistake by misreading the constraint #2. Both DeadWood Druid // It That Lurks the Wood and Sultai Ambassador are a type combination that is specific to thei…
-
@shadow123 Just realised you had the same problem as sanjaya666 xD You have three uncommons instead of two, would you mind removing one from your entry? ^^
-
REMINDER: 1 WEEK BEFORE DEADLINE
-
I believe bnew07 is right, the best way to do this is probably to refer to a difference ^^ I wouldn't change a word to what he proposed.
-
Sadly I couldn't fit the little "I'll keep watch text" I figured @kandra127 was mostly Grixis? I went with a Dimir oath: P.S: For the person after me, you can make me any oath really, but I'm usually an Esper player (and person in general xD)
-
@sanjaya666 Hey, I was re-reading your entry and realised I missed something really important, you have three uncommon cards instead of the two required x) Your entry is 9 cards, not 8! Can you remove an uncommon please? ^^
-
@Undead New tokens are possible, but they should make sense in the set. For instance, if the token is the same size and colour as another token from the same set, it would be less likely.
-
@shadow123 Note that it's not 100% forbidden to use existing illustrations (especially if you need to show something very specific to MTG lore like a character), but it's usually better to avoid it if you can ^^ Here are the two illustrations that…
-
@pstmdrn Hi! Unfortunately, Magic Origins is not a valid choice You need to select a Modern-legal black-bordered Magic expansion set and Magic Origins is a core set (so not an expansion set). The reason this rule is there is that Core sets are sim…
-
@Ranshi922 Well nothing that would go against the lore of the set, your goal is to design as if the cards were going directly into that set ^^
-
@Ranshi922 Your card should make sense in the set it's supposed to be, so if you make a Xenagos card it should fit within the lore of your set. In the case of Xenagos, in Born of the Gods he just became the God of Revels, so he's an available chara…
-
@sanjaya666 I'm afraid Liliana is not from Innistrad though, for the purpose of constraint number one, she's born on Dominaria. I realise the constraint may not have been clear enough, sorry about that The point is to prevent you from using planes…
-
@Ranshi922 No it isn't a problem, you can take your own spin on things. If I see a card like this, I'm going to assume there's a whole cycle in the set, which might have replaced the original one.