MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
stormbreath
About
- Username
- stormbreath
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,188
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
This card is one I enjoy. It's not the one I feel is the best balanced, or the one with the most meaningful lore for one of my custom planes, but it is one that is touching to a lot of people, and I like it for the symbol it represents.
-
@Mir-151414 first of all, I have no idea how you thought up the idea for using a double X mana to create tokens attached to a creature, which is something I've never seen before. In all honesty, this is a card that looks both over and underpowered…
-
I was born in Pennsylvania near Philadelphia(first capital of the US, but not the last), but I now live in the Finger Lakes region of New York(we're sort of sandwiched between the Appalachian Mountains and the Great Lakes) I started making cards wa…
-
@Temurzoa First things first, calling in spells from outside the game is incredibly overpowered, depending on what spells you have in your collection. That said, You do a nice job of balancing it by attaching it not just to a steep mana cost, but a…
-
@shadow123 Dying Dreams is an interesting anti-graveyard card. I can see it being a good sideboard card, but not part of a main deck except in standard. Tree of the Ancestors really nails Abzan lore to me. It's one of the things you don't see ofte…
-
I love the lore you've added to the sets, and Like what you've done with Esgar and Sylva. Too many people forget that White can be just as damaging as Black, and Black can be as soothing as white, in the right hands.
-
I hate saying this, Unless you're planning to play up some of White's negative aspects with Esgar, such as the social control that can easily tie into white beliefs like charity and community first, then I'm going to have to say that the lore conne…
-
Here's a new one that I don't think we will ever see, given the one plane the race appeared on was not very well liked. If it's not clear, she's meant to be a Kitsune, which in MTG terms, would be a Spirit
-
@Faiths_Guide Sounds good!
-
New order: A legendary creature that provides conditional benefits, preferably with white.
-
@Ranshi922 Good Game! I'd actually love to try and create a custom commander deck with you based around either Aliene or Adara, if that's something you're interested in. Well, I didn't expect to get too far in. And about Aliene, I've always thought…
-
Mine's in.
-
@KorandAngels correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't the only thing that separates a Conspiracy from an Enchantment is the fact that it's in the command zone? If you're going to make an entirely new card type, then have it go into the command zone to r…
-
Here's my submission:
-
1: Alyssa, Yue, Karin, Jayden 2: They/Them 3: Selesnya/Bant/Abzan 4: Midrange, Control, Tokens, 5: Support of my side, similar to Odric, master Tactician, or other similar effects.
-
I'd like to give this a try
-
@Je_Suis_Oluwa - Thank you for the feedback. I seem to be a balanced card designer in your eyes, and I'm not sure how to take that.
-
Name: Gilea species: unknown, presumed elf. Homeplane: Mirrodin Powers: fortune control/miracle-based spells(imagine lots of global buffs and tutors). Backstory: Gilea does not speak of her past all that often. all that is known by those around her…
-
Here's my entry. Inspired by Alien, even if it doesn't exactly look like it.
-
Introducing Fated, a keyword triggered effect similar to, say, Raid or Bestow. Fated works like this: Whenever you scry-effect Example:
-
@Je_Suis_Oluwa the reason Ravings of Madmen feels generic is because it is. I literally mashed two two-mana cards from Innistrad into one card and added an Entwine cost equal to its mana cost. It's not a flashy rare or game-breaking card, but it is…
-
@ningyouk My current problem is finding thematic and/or mechanical glue for the set. Currently the two possibilities are deck manipulation and/or exile. My major problem is coming up with a mechanic that fits the exile/deck manipulation theme while …
-
I think I've come up with one other type of Keyword that may or may not blend mechanically. I call it Vengance, it would appear in June colors, and activates whenever the creature it is on is dealt damage. I'm thinking of mostly using it for after-c…
-
Factions: I think I have decided on a few factions/Tribal themes that I want to have in Zolmira. Humans: Colors: all five, but primarily white and black. Associated keyword: Devoted. Themes: legendary creatures and the benefits of having them. …
-
@ningyounk You make very good points. Scry with Fated returning as an ability keyword that activated when you scry is something that would make sense. I know that you created Damocles, but I feel that we're looking at it in different ways. You see…
-
@KorlandAngels I am going to remove the Fated ability as a Keyword, given that it appears in so many different forms. I will also expand Scry since there will be a drop in keywords. @ningyounk Restless is planned to have other tokens similar to…
-
@Faiths_Guide I enjoy the ability, though the mana cost seems a bit high, even with Convoke. Maybe add a bit of Power/Toughness? Otherwise it's a solid card. Here's Mine: Two instants.