MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
tookie1
About
- Username
- tookie1
- Joined
- Visits
- 857
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@jpastor This is fine, though I don't like the fact that this is basically strictly better than an island in almost every circumstance. Maybe have it enter tapped? Other than that, nice work. Here's my card: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/reform-s…
-
Oh ok thank you!
-
Oh this looks super cool...would someone be able to ping me when the next one comes up? (I'm guessing no more entrants are being taken now)
-
I've voted!
-
Thanks for the card! I like it
-
Hold up...I got third!? wow. Thank you so much! I'll choose my faves a little later.
-
oh wow! I didn't expect to do well with that! Lucky me, I guess You can give my faves to @Ranshi since I liked their entries.
-
@RandomFandom That is very creative, but I feel like the effect is waaaaaay too powerful for what it does. This would definitely be a cool bargaining piece in EDH. I'd suggest upping the cost to 6 mana and maybe raising the p/t to 4/5 because this e…
-
This is for @Temurzoa , one of the few cardsmiths I follow and one of my biggest inspirations on this site. Their ideas are always so creative and amazing, so I tried to make a creative design for them in return: I hope you enjoy this card!
-
Aaaaahhhhhhhhh...I did well in this!?!? You can give my faves to @ChoyBoi since I liked their entry. @Ranshi Thanks so much!
-
@feralitator I think you'd need to have an ability that makes this a land rather than just having this start out as a land because you can't cast lands. Arixmethes is a Legendary creature and has an ability that makes it a land.
-
Did I...just win a contest...? Thank you so, so much @RohanDragoon!! This is the first time I've ever won a contest. I'm super happy you enjoyed my card. I'll message you with favorites sometime soon. Congrats to everyone else too. I'm still in s…
-
Yay!
-
For Ranshi (I already tagged them in another discussion, so I won't ping them here):
-
@Ranshi This is a card I just made for you depicting the end of your "War of 922 Ranshis" haha: Hope you like it : )
-
@Abu_Jafar Wow! I wake up and check mtgcardmith to find a card for me? What an amazing surprise. Thank you!
-
@CassZero Wow! That is AMAZING!!! My tiny nitpick as that usually avatars don't have any additional subtypes but that doesn't really mater. Thank you so much! I love this so much.
-
I love Simic colors and I also love the manifest mechanic.
-
@CassZero Could I get one if that's okay?
-
Congrats to all the winners! I didn't participate but I'm glad everything got cleared up!
-
This is my entry! I hope you like it:
-
Here's one from me: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/pull-into-oblivion-1 I think this is justified for a black counter since black generally has lots of creature hate. In addition to this, it doesn't hard counter anything, so it shouldn't be too ade…
-
Here's mine: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/callista-fungal-queen
-
@ningyounk I absolutely LOVE your designs!!
-
@Temurzoa Your champion is so awesome!!
-
@Arceus8523 I didn’t know about Cloudfin Raptor! I would have said the same thing as shadow123 if I didn’t know about that card. I like how this is turning out!
-
@KorandAngels I have a few thing to say about the card. Most of them are minor nitpicks, but here they are: 1. There is no period after first strike, and I believe the correct order is “First strike, haste” 2. Why is there a huge space in the middle…
-
@CassZero Oh my gosh! This is the first time I've placed in a contest1 Thanks so much for this! Could you fave any five of my recent cards? thanks! https://mtgcardsmith.com/user/tookie1/cards
-
Congrats @Usaername and @SteampunkDragon!!!!
-
@Ral1000 Harmonize has a certain mechanical interestingness to it. I love how it interacts with non creature permanents in an interesting way. It is flavorful and I feel like it adds to the set nicely. The way Nissa and Animating faerie do this effe…