MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
touchstone
Working on a custom set: Independence War. Check it out here: http://magicseteditor.sourceforge.net/node/12742.
About
- Username
- touchstone
- Joined
- Visits
- 422
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
You are right, Tempered doesn't work as written. I'll rework it.
-
I wasn't planning on hybrid being in the set (it's a mechanic as much as energy and +1/+1 counters are), but if you can make a good enough case for it, I'd allow it.
-
Planeswalkers will be a later contest. Currently, I'm trying to figure out how to get them to work in the set file.
-
@Lujikul I think I can allow some older cards for this challenge. If it gets put into the set file, I can always alter the flavor of it (assuming the flavor doesn't fit in the first place).
-
@ShadowKnight1224 You can do either. If you want to create a new card, go ahead, or you can choose one of your entries as the official card. @Rednaxela I like the card, but I feel like it's going two direction, and it needs to go one. Do you want i…
-
Alright, I meant to get this out yesterday, but oh well. It's here now. Total Scores @unicornsareevil13579 - 6.5 @Silumgar915 - 8.15 @Mordecai - 6 (Card only: -1 to score) @TastyCheez - 6.75 (Cards only: -1 to score) @Rednaxela - 3 @ArienStorm - 5.…
-
@MagicChess I appreciate all the time you took to develop a story and make cards, but judging had already begun, as I have posted multiple times. That means that only the entries made before my judging comments will be judged. However, I'm willing t…
-
Wackosaru Tarot, Starovek Guardian - Rank 6: I like this idea, but there's a major problem with it: the second ability doesn't do anything. If I remember correctly, combat goes as such: Declare attackers (Here's where "whenever CARDNAME attacks" tri…
-
Alright, sorry about the delay, life got busy. But I've got time on my hands now, so onto card judging! For consistency, cards will also be judged on a scale from 1 to 10, with 1 being the best, and 10 being the worst. After I finish this, and let y…
-
@Tomble123, check the judging post. I put that in. @cwwolfpack76 Temper is a cool idea, but it's a little wordy for my tastes. I think it might work better as "Whenever this creature blocks alone, it can block any amount of creatures and it gets +0/…
-
So, give everything submitted a tangible baseline, I'll be giving each mechanic a rating from 1-10. These relate directly to the ranks of the Storm Scale, which if you're not familiar with, check the OP. It has a link to a small primer on it. Anyway…
-
Judging has begun!
-
Dawn of the Final Day: 24 Hours Remain Get any last-minute changes in, guys!
-
You can suggest multiple mechanics, don't worry. As long as I can tell that though went into them, it's fine. Just remember, the winner is judged on all aspects of their submission; this includes both quantity and quality.
-
Round 1 will end in about a week
-
@unicornsareevil13579 I'm hesitant to include a new basic land type when Wastes didn't even get one. Especially considering how much more powerful Domian-like effects become once you do add more.
-
@Wackosaru Ah, my apologies. Misunderstood you. Elementals are fine, because while the plane is lifeless, elementals aren't exactly living beings in the first place. What has happened on the plane is undefined as of now, this round really only focu…
-
@Wackosaru I'm fine with giving feedback on ideas, but I need to leave something for judging! The main reason I haven't said anything on your idea is because it's pretty solid as it stands. Douse is an interesting mechanic, and there's nothing that …
-
@FireWolf767 Being in all colors is fine (we'll need some tribes with human-like spread-outness, seeing how planeswalkers are really the only living things on the plane). @unicornsareevil13579 I normally wouldn't do this, but I'm going to put a str…
-
I'm liking what I'm seeing! Oh, and @FireWolf767, I'd just thought you should know that Natural armor functions exactly the same as Absorb. If it gets put in, that would be the name used.
-
@ShadowKnight1224 Your cards are fine. Intervention is interesting, but it might need some tweaking if it makes it in (right now, it's really wordy).
-
@Rednaxela I am all for including Energy and Pulse in Sunya, but what I would like is for you to explain why there's energy on the plane. Is there an Aether Sphere around the plane, like Kaladesh? Something else, maybe more fragile and artificial? R…
-
bumping this up! Also, @unicornsareevil12578, I have realized I was a little harsh. I apologize.
-
Here's a concept I've been toying around with. Ruthless N - [cost] ([cost], T, Sacrifice a creature: Put N +1/+1 counters on this creature.)
-
@unicornsareevil13579 So, I get that you're just creating cards, but I want to make this clear: Spamming entries will not increase your chance of winning. Not only that, but because you're just creating cards left and right, there's no theme nor fl…
-
Here's a concept I'm playing around with: Counterattack N - [cost] ([cost], T: This creature deals N damage to target creature or player. Activate this ability only if you are being attacked.) Example: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/watchful-wallguard
-
So, the best of set are: Alhammarret, Called Upon by @Blazin_Biscuit Jace, Returned to Vryn by @Alvblanka Galvanic Dregs by @Beeswax Aetherstasis by @RedRageMage Aravaal, Drainer of Mana by @Gamerpg04 Reckless Use by @Lujikul And now for the podium…
-
GAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Oh my gosh, everyone! I am so sorry!!! A lot of stuff has happened over the past few months (computer went kaput and I ended up having to move...), so I put a lot of stuff off so I could focus on RL. Yet, …
-
Alright, and as of now, the 2nd CBC is entering judgement phase! Assuming real life doesn't get in the way, I should have the Best of Set, Winners, and Honorable Mention ready to reveal is about 2~3 days.
-
bump