JMGreer41
About
- Username
- JMGreer41
- Joined
- Visits
- 54
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@CS101 no big deal, just my take. Haven't gotten into Strixhaven too much yet, so wasn't familiar. Its also a personal preference thing - I usually play free-for-all games with the same 3, 4 guys, so tend to work with things that build a little slow…
-
@CS101 Bolas' Inginutiy--the text confused me a little. Is it just the controller that exiles, or does each player exile in turn? Seems interesting, but that bit could use more clarity. Summoning the Rain Spirit --So, my experience has been that nor…
-
Thanks for the heads up about the contest....Here's my 3. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/fairy-led-leprechaun?list=set&set=59587 https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/leprechaun-cavern-scout?list=set&set=59587 https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/vale-o…
-
@Shadow123 Interesting ability. The card pairs with it fantastically, and it balances well with the cost. Well done. Haven't posted any of my own stuff for a while, so here's one for ya. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/nico-mantis-lord
-
@CassZero I like it conceptually, and the artwork is sound. The mechanics aren't bad either, I just wish there was a better/slicker way for it to look in the text. Not that that is your doing, either...you're working with what's available. But every…
-
@Temurzoa Simple, effective. Not sold on the artwork, but otherwise I like it. Here;s mine for today....https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wild-magic
-
@KorandAngels It's hard for me to critique these, as they seem very commander oriented, and I don't play commander very much, but I'll give it a go. #1 love the art. Particularly Orogo, good stuff. The Multipartner ability's interesting, but if on…
-
@CassZero Well....okay let's do this. Ability #1: maybe make it crank out trap tokens that are artifacts with a function, rather than 0/1 creatures called "beast trap"? Ability #2...okay, Ability #3. make sense, but Jerry never killed Tom. Maybe t…
-
okay...so lemme first say: @Crimsonspill - thanks for the feeback. the original wording was "As long as Islandcrowned Giantess is in play, lands you control produce U in addition to..." I'll tinker a bit and see if I can find a version that works …
-
@fire12 Extractor of Information: Not a bad card, but the multiple abilities make it feel busy to me. I tend to play a lot of multiplayer games, so something with this much happening would be a bit of a pain to keep track of/keep up with. I feel l…
-
@MemoryHead...my fault. didn't see that the page changed. Apologies to those I skipped over!
-
@fire12 Really like the concept. I did something similar with one of the GL Ring cards I did the other day (orange i believe). It's not worded incorrectly, but it's pretty wordy in general. Maybe something along these lines? "Remove all loyal…
-
@Ranshi I like it, but it seems insanely powerful for 2. There's a lot of stuff that replicates instants that could have you taking and extra turn without much effort at all the way this is worded. Maybe put the extra turn bit in as part of the …
-
@shadow123, Love it. Always been a fan of the proliferate ability. The casting cost seems low to me, though. I probably would've got 4G or 3GG, myself. Here's my latest attempt. I'm determined to get one, just one, without wording issue. lol Edit:…
-
@TerryTags I can't see anything wrong with it, just not sure its something I'd use myself. Maybe "Leveling The FieldS" would work better, as its Plains-specific? Just a thought. Here's mine for today. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/twister-maiden
-
@fire12 Man...I dunno what to say here. I love it and hate it all at once. I feel like if I had to play against it I'd never want to play that person again, just in case. On the other hand, I'd play 4 of them in a white soldier/knight deck without p…
-
@Ilmarinen, I like it, but I've always been a fan of the Samurai type & Bushido. The wording on the ability seems clunky to me, but I don't have a clearer way to put it, and the way you have it explains the purpose well enough. My pick for the …
-
three part post: A) @TerryTags I like it, but @Potato13 makes totally valid points. It could become quite a monster in the right situation. @fire12 I'm not seeing the difference between your version of the Technovirus text and mine, aside from …
-
@fire12 Love it. Favorited. I thought the cost was high at a glance, but it's spot on. Huge potential in a speedy creature deck. I actually liked this one better than the Purphoros card itself lol. My next offering (again, made when i was getting t…
-
@joemamajoe I actually quite like Watery Reprisal. I thought it was pricey (casting cost) at a glance, but after i thought about the potential for a few, it might actually be low. Varmord,,,the Fiery Ascendant version is far more balanced than The…
-
Love the art on the cards, and the mechanics are sound, but not necessarily MY cup o'tea. Here's a couple from me, Frostbound Giant inspired by a painting I liked. And Moonflower, based on my daughter's D & D character. https://mtgcardsmith.c…
-
lol...I've still browsing about, tbh. I do like Skrypt though, i remember that'n.
-
I know you can download other members cards if you spot one you like, but is there a way to do so with an entire set? I've seen a few I liked as a whole, but it'd take me days to click, download, goto set, click, download 100+ cards lol